User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Need some sort of X-Factor
Page:
 
aquatix
offline
Link
 
Let me start by saying I've played every football game under the sun.

This game is great and has a TON of potential but it needs some sort of "X-Factor"

By that, I mean some sort of "volatilty" rating for players. We need "boom" or "busts."

The problem now is, if there is a team in my league that averages one level higher across the board, we'll never catch them. I know they'll be 1 level higher than us next year, and the following and the following etc...

We need a few Ryan Leafs... who start out with all the potential in the world, but never amount to anything. We also need some "Zach Thomas's" who nobody thinks will amount to anything, but become great.

Perhaps it doesn't need to be that extreme, but some players should go up faster than others so you are never quite sure what to expect.

Perhaps giving each player a "volatility" rating is a good idea. The higher a player is in this stat, the greater chance they have to "boom" or "bust". If a player has low volatility, you can expect that they will pretty much go up slowly on a week to week basis. Owners can take risks on volitale players just like they do in real life (ie. Randy Moss).

This will add some excitment and unpredictability to the game. As it is now, the bottom feeders will remain bottom feeders unless they get very lucky in the FA market.

Just my 2 cents...

 
KGrob
offline
Link
 
While I agree that would add a fun depth to the game, I'd hate to be one of those players who got a DuD player. LoL.

Nonetheless, I think it would be fun for the game.

Good idea.
 
aquatix
offline
Link
 
Well, you could choose your volatility when you create your player. If you want it high, you risk being a boom or bust. That would be the players choice on conception.

Whether or not to go with the volatility rating is no big deal, the game just needs something so player levels aren't so predictable.
 
Link
 
good idea. a ''potential'' rating. i like.
 
KGrob
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aquatix
Well, you could choose your volatility when you create your player. If you want it high, you risk being a boom or bust. That would be the players choice on conception.

Whether or not to go with the volatility rating is no big deal, the game just needs something so player levels aren't so predictable.


Yes, that might be a good way to do it. You could voluntarily enter into the "Volitility" by selecting the level of risk you would like.

A setting of "Zero" would ensure you get exactly what you expect, nothing more, nothing less...just as things are now.

A setting of "Five" would mean that you may have anything from a total BUST all the way up to an ALL PRO. Other settings in between would reduce Volatility accordingly.

Heheh,

I really like this idea, especially if the player himself can decide how much risk he is willing to take.

I love it.

 
aquatix
offline
Link
 
ya, that's a good way to do it.
 
ArthurRiot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KGrob
Originally posted by aquatix

Well, you could choose your volatility when you create your player. If you want it high, you risk being a boom or bust. That would be the players choice on conception.

Whether or not to go with the volatility rating is no big deal, the game just needs something so player levels aren't so predictable.


Yes, that might be a good way to do it. You could voluntarily enter into the "Volitility" by selecting the level of risk you would like.

A setting of "Zero" would ensure you get exactly what you expect, nothing more, nothing less...just as things are now.

A setting of "Five" would mean that you may have anything from a total BUST all the way up to an ALL PRO. Other settings in between would reduce Volatility accordingly.

Heheh,

I really like this idea, especially if the player himself can decide how much risk he is willing to take.

I love it.



Except for one problem; there's no penalty for dumping a player (retirement) and just starting a new one.

I could just set my player to a high volitility, and see how his stats are doing. If they are shit, dump him and start over. Repeat process until I have a Randy Moss. It wouldn't be fair to everyone else.

As it stands now, HOW you build your character matters. Do you up his field vision and sacrifice stamina? Is he a fast linebacker or a strong one? Etc etc...

And besides, every season you can 'boost' your player 3 levels. If you build him/her properly, isn't that already creating special players?
 
aquatix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ArthurRiot
Originally posted by KGrob

Originally posted by aquatix


Well, you could choose your volatility when you create your player. If you want it high, you risk being a boom or bust. That would be the players choice on conception.

Whether or not to go with the volatility rating is no big deal, the game just needs something so player levels aren't so predictable.


Yes, that might be a good way to do it. You could voluntarily enter into the "Volitility" by selecting the level of risk you would like.

A setting of "Zero" would ensure you get exactly what you expect, nothing more, nothing less...just as things are now.

A setting of "Five" would mean that you may have anything from a total BUST all the way up to an ALL PRO. Other settings in between would reduce Volatility accordingly.

Heheh,

I really like this idea, especially if the player himself can decide how much risk he is willing to take.

I love it.



Except for one problem; there's no penalty for dumping a player (retirement) and just starting a new one.

I could just set my player to a high volitility, and see how his stats are doing. If they are shit, dump him and start over. Repeat process until I have a Randy Moss. It wouldn't be fair to everyone else.

As it stands now, HOW you build your character matters. Do you up his field vision and sacrifice stamina? Is he a fast linebacker or a strong one? Etc etc...

And besides, every season you can 'boost' your player 3 levels. If you build him/her properly, isn't that already creating special players?


I agree that the problem of "dumping" players would need to be solved (perhaps a stricter retirement punishment).

However, I don't believe that's already creating special players if everyone does it.
 
daftuprising
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of being able to spend points in like a potential stat when your first created. Like a scale of 1-5 and every 3 point raises your potential one point. If you spend all 15 points on potential, you get .5 more EXP(or slightly more complex algorithms, just an example), per play.Maybe your player is a little worse the first couple of levels, but you could gain maybe 1 more exp per year.

Another idea is each one costs 5 points to begin with and every level your player grows you get .3 continuous more skill points. So if you dump all 15 into potential you can gain 1 more skill point every time you level up.
 
Vyeth
offline
Link
 
All they would need to do, is at the begining of next season and to all new crated characters before nxt season, just secretly add a luck attribute to everyone. No one can see it but the devs and everyones luck attribute would be a totally random number from 1 - 100 with 100 being your absolute tom brady's and of course 's being your ryan leafs. Your luck attribute could help you pull off certain things in the clutch as well as boost your stats a little more after gaining a level. But we could never just LOOK at someone and automaticly KNOW if they are going to be good or not (like some of you guys are wanting).

This way it would add some of that unknown factor BUT will allow some players to become GREATER than others even at the same level, but in order to KNOW that they are greater you'd have to scout them. I think this would make a great addition to the game and allows for greater variation in team buildup because honestly we cant all be GREAT super stars.. just doesn't work that way..
 
aquatix
offline
Link
 
Owners wouldn't be able to LOOK and see if someone will be great... they would LOOK and be able to see that they may be great, or may be a bust... like Randy Moss was seen the day before his draft.
 
Fandom
offline
Link
 
Why would "dumping" players need to be resolved.

Most players in the NFL are "Dumped" after only a short time.

I think it's perfectly acceptable to "dump" anyone you want at anytime you want to.

Once you figure out that your player is a turd, you simply delete him and start a new rookie.

I think that would be much more like Pro Ball than what we have now.
 
stregone
offline
Link
 
I think the main random factor should be calculated at the beginning of the season, and then another minor random factor calculated for each game. That way you can get a good or bad season, but it won't be exactly uniform.
 
Fandom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stregone
I think the main random factor should be calculated at the beginning of the season, and then another minor random factor calculated for each game. That way you can get a good or bad season, but it won't be exactly uniform.


There are tons of good ways to do this. Yours is probably one of the better ones I've read.

But I also like the idea that I read above of making it voluntary for each player owner.

That way, owners could get exactly what they want, or they can gamble and get something totally unknown. And the unknown might vary widely. I think that would be fun.

Leave it up to the players themselves to select their own "X Factor".

Totally fun idea.

 
aquatix
offline
Link
 
Any of these work great... whatever it takes so players/teams aren't so predictable in terms of player level.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.