User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Issue with Automatic? - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
This has been bugging me for some time, I more and more get the impression that high levels of Automatic are actually detrimental on short FG attempts for some reason, particularly in the 20-29 range. Evidence so far is circumstancial, but looking at five kickers on the Pro teams I have access to seems to back up that feeling, I am sticking to seasons where I know how much Automatic they have/had. Maybe some other agents can submit their numbers as well.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1061927&playoffs=0
Last season WEPL for E-City, this season WEPL for Korb, 16 Automatic, 140+ kicking:
Over the last two seasons including preseason he is:
1/1 9/15 16/19 14/17 15/22

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1239991
This WEPL for E-City, Automatic 12, 130+ kicking:
This season including preseason games:
1/1 1/3 5/5 1/1 3/8

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=804412
Last season WL for Korb, this season WEPL for Nordic, Automatic 11, kicking 130+:
Last two season including preseason:
2/2 9/14 19/20 27/31 8/14

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=836151
Last season Graz WL, this season Graz WEPL, Automatic 6, kicking 130+
Last season games with Graz and this season including preseason:
0/0 4/7 8/11 7/9 2/7

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=660601
Last and this season Phantoms, Casual Pro: Automatic 11, kicking 125+ :
1/1 17/24 16/21 28/29 9/15

Given that the description of Automatic reads "at very high levels accuracy becomes nearly 100%" I would say that this is enough evidence to prove that something is wrong here, as all these guys have a better accuracy in the 30-49 range than in the 20-29 range, and four of them have 10+ Automatic, which I'd say would qualify as "very high level". Spread over five different players, five different teams and two seasons I would say that there is something wrong with how Automatic works, or maybe it does not work at all.

Edited by VolBrian on Jun 7, 2010 15:34:47 (Closed as not a bug)
Edited by Asdlfef on Jun 7, 2010 10:01:05 (FGs from 20-39 are made at a higher % than 40+ in most instances.)
Edited by Zickzack on Jun 7, 2010 09:44:45
 
Asdlfef
offline
Link
 
Basing my ruling on the regular season only and only the most recent full season (15):

Player 1: Made a slightly higher percentage of FGs from 10-40 than 40+

Player 2: Made a higher percentage of FGs from 0-40 than 40+

Player 3: Made a lower percentage of FGs from 0-40 than 40+, however 20-29 range has a fairly small sample size to make any determinations.

Player 4: Made a higher percentage of FGs from 0-40 than 40+

Player 5: Made a higher percentage of FGs from 0-40 than 40+

Although the description states that accuracy becomes nearly 100%, that does not mean it is full proof. Position on the field, pressure, vision, strength, etc. can all factor into whether or not the FG is made. It appears that in most of these cases accuracy is also better at closer range than 40+ which is the way it should be. The difference between 20-29 and 30-39 does appear to be slightly off, but the above conditions can all play into it. I do not believe that this is a bug and will mark it as such.
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asdlfef
Basing my ruling on the regular season only and only the most recent full season (15):


So preseason games d not count? Sorry but that does not make any sense, as no setting aside from maybe the range for long FGs will be affected by it being preseason ratehr than a regular game. I also checked several other kickers from WEPL, without knowing their Automatic of course, but for almost everyone accuracy in the 20-29 range is worse than it is for 30-49. Be it linked to Automatic or not, there clearly is a problem with short FG accuracy. It is specifically that range I call into question, not the 0-40 range that you base your decision on. About every kicker I have looked at is automatic from 10-19, and almost every one of them is worse from 20-29 than from 30-49.
 
Bobmachinegun
offline
Link
 
Season FGM FGA 0-19 20-29 30-39 40-49 50+
12 21 22 1/1 11/11 8/9 1/1 0/0
13 26 28 0/0 3/3 13/13 9/11 1/1
14 11 11 0/0 0/0 2/2 9/9 0/0
15 4 4 0/0 1/1 3/3 0/0 0/0
16 1 1 1/1 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0

My kicker has 5 automatic since long time ago due to this rumor about automatic being buggy. He is 100+ since season 12.
Edited by Bobmachinegun on Jun 7, 2010 10:25:27
 
jkdog855
offline
Link
 
0 points in an SA
6 1 5 0/0 1/2 0/3 0/0 0/0 4 4 1
7 18 28 2/2 7/9 7/14 2/3 0/0 66 68 11
8 11 12 2/2 1/1 5/5 3/4 0/0 99 103 11
9 20 21 0/0 7/7 7/7 6/6 0/1 243 248 27
10 29 35 3/3 6/6 7/7 9/9 4/10 164 169 7
11 26 28 2/2 6/6 8/8 5/5 5/7 125 128 0
12 19 21 1/1 2/3 8/8 7/7 1/2 268 272 6
13 23 24 1/1 4/4 9/9 6/6 3/4 150 152 0
14 25 29 2/2 4/4 7/7 9/9 3/7 493 500 0

added points into CN and BB
15 24 29 1/1 4/4 7/8 6/8 6/8 315 327 18

Overall
Career 197 233 14/14 42/46 65/76 54/58 22/39 1,927 1,971 81
 
frankiebee
offline
Link
 
I was just about to post something about this. My team just lost a game because the syytem for some reason thought our kicker couldn't make a 30 yard field goal. Its actually bullshit. If its not one thing with this shit SIM its another. It has nothing to do with automatic but didnt want to start a new thread about FG's. It has to do with the "auto" FG distance
Edited by frankiebee on Jun 7, 2010 10:51:19
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by frankiebee
I was just about to post something about this. My team just lost a game because the syytem for some reason thought our kicker couldn't make a 30 yard field goal. Its actually bullshit. If its not one thing with this shit SIM its another


Not very helpful, there is always a chance that any given FG is missed, no matter which distance, what is of interest is the long term trend, and to me that trend seems to indicate that Automatic is not really helping or might even be detrimental in the 20-29 range.
 
azrolator
offline
Link
 
I don't have a kicker myself, so my only credentials are having watched football games I guess. But it seems to me that the shorter the range, the better the chance of making the kick regardless of any SA. It's not a ton of examples above, but from what was posted it looks to me like there is a slightly better percentage from those short ones to the next range. I would kind of expect that anyways from the shorter distance and it seems to me that with 10+ skill into it that there should be some kind of difference you could really notice. The SA does appear to be claiming that easy kicks should be "automatic" after all. Though without knowing the numbers behind it, maybe 16 points of it only gets you up to the 19 yard range.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Automatic is notoriously not a useful SA.

My kicker Grundle has not missed a FG under 40 yards during the regular season since season 8 (and 59/62 from 40-49 during that same stretch), and has missed none under 50 in his career in the playoffs. Only this past offseason did I push automatic past 2; I pushed it to 11 with AE.

I don't think it's so much that it doesn't actually have a benefit I think it's due to the utter lack of parity for kickers. At higher levels, kickers simply don't miss very often, with or without automatic. My theory is that automatic simply turns a huge chance of making any given fieldgoal into a very slightly larger chance. So slight it's not really noticeable at the rate of 4-6 FGAs a season. For example, let's say a level 50 kicker with 0 automatic has a 99% chance to make a 25 yard FG. So 1/100 times he'll miss. The same kicker with a 10 in automatic gets an accuracy bonus, making his chance to make the same field goal 99.2%. For all intents and purposes the odds are identical. You'd need the ability to kick 1000 or so 25 yard FGs in a season to really make a noticeable difference. And even then you'd need to run it a bunch of times to prove anything solidly.

EDITed for grammar
Edited by TheGreatPuma on Jun 7, 2010 19:19:20
Edited by TheGreatPuma on Jun 7, 2010 14:25:53
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma

I don't think it's so much that it doesn't actually have a benefit I think it's due to the utter lack of parity for kickers. At higher levels, kickers simply don't miss very often, with or without automatic. My theory is that automatic simply turns a huge chance of making any given fieldgoal into a very slightly larger change. So slight it's not really noticeable at the rate of 4-6 FGAs a season. For example, let's say a level 50 kicker with 0 automatic has a 99% chance to make a 25 yard FG. So 1/100 times he'll miss. The same kicker with a 10 in automatic gets an accuracy bonus, making his chance to make the same field goal 99.2%. For all intents and purposes the odds are identical. You'd need the ability to kick 1000 or so 25 yard FGs in a season to really make a noticeable difference. And even then you'd need to run it a bunch of times to prove anything solidly.


This is an excellent interpretation of this issue imo. I'm not sure Automatic should be expected to make a kicker 100% accurate and successful on short FG's. Even if it is named "automatic" Gotta agree with asdlfef here, not a bug.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.