Hi everyone! Anyone else feel its a tad bit unfair to have level 22 teams in our level18 league? The rest of us cant even sign level 19 players nevermind level 22 players!
Frankiejames
offline
offline
I contacted support on this matter, and I know several other people in our league have as well. I haven't heard back from them yet. Further investigation has led me to believe the issue isn't unique to our league, though. I found this thread in level 18 minors #2.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4024305&page=1
Seems to indicate that they contacted support about a similar issue and were basically told that it is the way it's supposed to be. Searching through their league I found this team ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5966 ), which I suspect is the team that prompted them to send the query. It appears to me that these teams found a loophole in the promotion system, be it intentionally or not, we might be stuck with them.
You might notice that on your team page, it identifies you has being in the "Competitive Minors", and I think that might be why we have teams stacked over the level cap.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4024305&page=1
Seems to indicate that they contacted support about a similar issue and were basically told that it is the way it's supposed to be. Searching through their league I found this team ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5966 ), which I suspect is the team that prompted them to send the query. It appears to me that these teams found a loophole in the promotion system, be it intentionally or not, we might be stuck with them.
You might notice that on your team page, it identifies you has being in the "Competitive Minors", and I think that might be why we have teams stacked over the level cap.
Jazlotus
offline
offline
Does this mean we are better just sucking this season then? playing to lose? not boosting? how does this benefit the game? it makes no sense at all to me, and makes me think i may as well quit the game rather then get annoyed with it.
Frankiejames
offline
offline
I'm going to wait till I hear from support before I decide what to do, but I'm afraid we probably are stuck with these teams. Philosophically I agree with you, this is detrimental to the game as a whole, and really makes no sense. What they're saying is essentially that minors aren't worth worrying about, and ostensibly aren't meant to be competitive, despite what the name might suggest. If this is the way these leagues are really meant to be set up, I'm definitely going to the admins about this, it's really just wrong.
I wouldn't say that if we are stuck I'd be playing to lose, I think that by the playoffs we can catch up enough to take a shot at competing with these teams, but until then it's unlikely we'll be able to realistically beat them, especially those with rosters full of lv22s.
EDIT: I would go so far as to say that I will stop boosting and CEQing my players until something is done about this, and actively encourage others to do the same.
I wouldn't say that if we are stuck I'd be playing to lose, I think that by the playoffs we can catch up enough to take a shot at competing with these teams, but until then it's unlikely we'll be able to realistically beat them, especially those with rosters full of lv22s.
EDIT: I would go so far as to say that I will stop boosting and CEQing my players until something is done about this, and actively encourage others to do the same.
Edited by Frankiejames on May 20, 2010 15:25:30
Clemson Tigers
offline
offline
I agree that it sucks to be stuck with teams with players that are older and over our heads in levels, but I think it is still valuable to compete for the playoffs. That will get you out of the minors quicker and into the real leagues of AA and up (I have heard disparaging remarks about AA, but I think you all get my drift). If teams sandbag it to be a top team the next season, well, they will eventually get into high enough leagues where they won't be able to do that, and those are the leagues we are all after. This of course is just my opinion.
Edited by Clemson Tigers on May 20, 2010 15:29:48
Jazlotus
offline
offline
I will do what all u guys think is best, i just feel that its a waste of time now, because im sure u guys are like me and we play to win, and when winning is impossible........ whats the point?
Frankiejames
offline
offline
Honestly I agree with both of you on this one, to some degree. I'd hate to think it's impossible to win now, but that isn't going to stop me. Like Clemson said, once we advance to higher levels this kind of thing won't happen, and if we're stuck with it now, the best we can do is just grin and bear it; do our best in spite of the circumstances. Hopefully they fix this problem in the future, though.
Fumblerooski
offline
offline
I don't know their specific situations, but these teams were likely in a 14 capped league last season and got promoted 1 cap only because they missed the playoffs. Here's Catch22's May 2nd announcement on how promotions were handled this season:
"- If you finished 12-4 or better or made it to the 3rd round of the playoffs, you are going to move up two levels. This preempts all the below. it does not matter if you have all your players below the cap, you are not eligible for an exception.
- If you made the playoffs and did not make it past the 2nd round and were 11-5 or worse, you can request to move up one level if all of your players are below the cap.
- If you didn't make the playoffs and everyone is below the cap, you can remain at the same level. However, choosing to do this will result in having your team's cash and stadium reset to the tier you are staying at, unless you are a 15th/16th place team.
- Some exceptions will be made - for example if you only made the playoffs because 8 teams in your league were CPU (this means CPU not lower level owned human teams), then we will evaluate that and you could possibly remain at the same level if all of your players are below the cap.
- Requests for single tier promotion may still be denied if we deem your team to be unsuited to the tier you are requesting based on effective level.
- The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. "
"- If you finished 12-4 or better or made it to the 3rd round of the playoffs, you are going to move up two levels. This preempts all the below. it does not matter if you have all your players below the cap, you are not eligible for an exception.
- If you made the playoffs and did not make it past the 2nd round and were 11-5 or worse, you can request to move up one level if all of your players are below the cap.
- If you didn't make the playoffs and everyone is below the cap, you can remain at the same level. However, choosing to do this will result in having your team's cash and stadium reset to the tier you are staying at, unless you are a 15th/16th place team.
- Some exceptions will be made - for example if you only made the playoffs because 8 teams in your league were CPU (this means CPU not lower level owned human teams), then we will evaluate that and you could possibly remain at the same level if all of your players are below the cap.
- Requests for single tier promotion may still be denied if we deem your team to be unsuited to the tier you are requesting based on effective level.
- The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. "
Edited by Fumblerooski on May 20, 2010 17:39:26
Frankiejames
offline
offline
Interesting info, so that's the rule that got them here, but I still feel like it's something of a loophole. At very least we should be able to recruit some higher level players to compensate.
Also yeah, this is my favorite episode too
, right in the prime of the show.
Also yeah, this is my favorite episode too
, right in the prime of the show.Frankiejames
offline
offline
"Hi Frankiejames,
Thank you for reaching out to us. When teams are promoted/demoted to a specific cap for performance reasons they are allowed to keep their players that are over the cap that are signed to their team as ling as they are under contract. They can not sign free agents who are over the cap. This is to help them be competitive, otherwise there would be no point to the demotion. Obviously if a team performs really well they will be promoted to a new league, taking care of the issue.
We would step in if an owner asked to be demoted to a level 13 cap and then tried to keep their level 40+ players. Those players would be removed from the team. The teams you pointed out have moved to their current cap by naturally following the promotion process.
I hope that this makes more sense, best of luck in the season. Please let me know if I can help with anything else.
EB"
Got the response; just what Fumble said.
Thank you for reaching out to us. When teams are promoted/demoted to a specific cap for performance reasons they are allowed to keep their players that are over the cap that are signed to their team as ling as they are under contract. They can not sign free agents who are over the cap. This is to help them be competitive, otherwise there would be no point to the demotion. Obviously if a team performs really well they will be promoted to a new league, taking care of the issue.
We would step in if an owner asked to be demoted to a level 13 cap and then tried to keep their level 40+ players. Those players would be removed from the team. The teams you pointed out have moved to their current cap by naturally following the promotion process.
I hope that this makes more sense, best of luck in the season. Please let me know if I can help with anything else.
EB"
Got the response; just what Fumble said.
Edited by Frankiejames on May 21, 2010 00:19:54
Jazlotus
offline
offline
This is what i got from support:-
Hi again, Jazlotus. Ah, I've looked at the teams you mentioned, and can tell you why they are in that league. They were in level 14 leagues, last season, and did not make the playoffs. According to the promotion system, teams like that are moved up 1 level for the following season. I understand your frustration in this matter, but it really wouldn't be the “honorable” thing to move those teams. I say that because moving those teams would mean ignoring the rules that are in place for every other team, and punishing them for following those rules.
I see that your team was in level 4, last season, and did very well. Imagine, though, if the team hadn't done well, and had only won 4 games. Even though you have level 15 players, the team would have been moved the required 1 level. It would be unfair to punish your team by making a last minute rule change, when your team had only followed the established rules. As long as the same rules are used for everyone, the system is fair. To change the rules of a particular team, based on the wishes of other teams, is very unfair.
Here's a link with information about the promotion/demotion process, if you're interested:
http://goallineblitz.com/demotion_faq.html
Hi again, Jazlotus. Ah, I've looked at the teams you mentioned, and can tell you why they are in that league. They were in level 14 leagues, last season, and did not make the playoffs. According to the promotion system, teams like that are moved up 1 level for the following season. I understand your frustration in this matter, but it really wouldn't be the “honorable” thing to move those teams. I say that because moving those teams would mean ignoring the rules that are in place for every other team, and punishing them for following those rules.
I see that your team was in level 4, last season, and did very well. Imagine, though, if the team hadn't done well, and had only won 4 games. Even though you have level 15 players, the team would have been moved the required 1 level. It would be unfair to punish your team by making a last minute rule change, when your team had only followed the established rules. As long as the same rules are used for everyone, the system is fair. To change the rules of a particular team, based on the wishes of other teams, is very unfair.
Here's a link with information about the promotion/demotion process, if you're interested:
http://goallineblitz.com/demotion_faq.html
Alexxx
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jazlotus
This is what i got from support:-
Hi again, Jazlotus. Ah, I've looked at the teams you mentioned, and can tell you why they are in that league. They were in level 14 leagues, last season, and did not make the playoffs. According to the promotion system, teams like that are moved up 1 level for the following season. I understand your frustration in this matter, but it really wouldn't be the “honorable” thing to move those teams. I say that because moving those teams would mean ignoring the rules that are in place for every other team, and punishing them for following those rules.
I see that your team was in level 4, last season, and did very well. Imagine, though, if the team hadn't done well, and had only won 4 games. Even though you have level 15 players, the team would have been moved the required 1 level. It would be unfair to punish your team by making a last minute rule change, when your team had only followed the established rules. As long as the same rules are used for everyone, the system is fair. To change the rules of a particular team, based on the wishes of other teams, is very unfair.
Here's a link with information about the promotion/demotion process, if you're interested:
http://goallineblitz.com/demotion_faq.html
There you go.
This is what i got from support:-
Hi again, Jazlotus. Ah, I've looked at the teams you mentioned, and can tell you why they are in that league. They were in level 14 leagues, last season, and did not make the playoffs. According to the promotion system, teams like that are moved up 1 level for the following season. I understand your frustration in this matter, but it really wouldn't be the “honorable” thing to move those teams. I say that because moving those teams would mean ignoring the rules that are in place for every other team, and punishing them for following those rules.
I see that your team was in level 4, last season, and did very well. Imagine, though, if the team hadn't done well, and had only won 4 games. Even though you have level 15 players, the team would have been moved the required 1 level. It would be unfair to punish your team by making a last minute rule change, when your team had only followed the established rules. As long as the same rules are used for everyone, the system is fair. To change the rules of a particular team, based on the wishes of other teams, is very unfair.
Here's a link with information about the promotion/demotion process, if you're interested:
http://goallineblitz.com/demotion_faq.html
There you go.
Clemson Tigers
offline
offline
I am not accusing any of the teams we are talking about of doing this, but I do know of some teams who once they figure out they are not going to win a championship, they don't game plan, or game plan badly, to lose as many games as possible, so they don't make the playoffs. They know that they will probably be the best team in their league in the next season. I know this is done because I had a team owner admit this to me in the league forum one time. I thought it sucked at the time, and I still do. I think some people have their heads shoved so far up their butts about lol trophies, that they forget that this is a game, and it is supposed to be about competition, and getting better. There is no getting better when you sandbag one season, to win the next. You feel that there is not need to get better. Besides, the goal is to get out of the minors as quickly as possible, so that you can start earning your stripes and get into the pro and wl. If a team sandbags, they move up one level, and when they win a championship the next season, they move up two levels (if a team hasn't enough integrity to fight it out when they aren't going to win a championship, then they aren't going to move up three levels by winning a championship), that is three levels in two season. If the team had fought to get a playoff spot the first season, gotten better, and gotten a playoff spot the second season, then they are up four levels in four seasons. They may not have a cartoon trophy, but at least they are higher in the minor league cloud.
There, I have ranted, I feel better.
To the teams in this league that have players with high levels, I want to repeat that I am not accusing any of you of this. I wish everyone luck, and may the best team win. I just hope any team that eliminates themselves from title contention doesn't try the sandbag approach to things, because that makes it less fun for everyone else.
There, I have ranted, I feel better.
To the teams in this league that have players with high levels, I want to repeat that I am not accusing any of you of this. I wish everyone luck, and may the best team win. I just hope any team that eliminates themselves from title contention doesn't try the sandbag approach to things, because that makes it less fun for everyone else.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























