User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Fix the Promotion System
Page:
 
Jayadamo
Vol4Life
offline
Link
 
I have read the rules and do agree that this team http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=5966 has done everything they needed to do to go from a cap 14 to a cap 18 league but the system is flawed. This team is all level 22s but because they went 8-8 and missed the playoffs they only have to move up 1 level.

The other teams in the League are from cap 4 and are all around level 15. Hell we can't even recruit level 22 players to try and compete with them.

This looks like a common sense thing. Team is all level 22s, there is a cap 22 League, put the team there. This completely ruins what could have been a great and unpredictable league. Looks to me like the League champs are already crowned.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I agree with this, you can't just look at playoff records and what not.

this team tanked on purpose I would imagine so they can get a lol18 cap trophy

also I know a team that did not make the playoffs and got promoted to AAA

if they can't make the playoffs in AA how are they going to do in AAA?
 
amace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jayadamo DTD
I have read the rules and do agree that this team http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=5966 has done everything they needed to do to go from a cap 14 to a cap 18 league but the system is flawed. This team is all level 22s but because they went 8-8 and missed the playoffs they only have to move up 1 level.

The other teams in the League are from cap 4 and are all around level 15. Hell we can't even recruit level 22 players to try and compete with them.

This looks like a common sense thing. Team is all level 22s, there is a cap 22 League, put the team there. This completely ruins what could have been a great and unpredictable league. Looks to me like the League champs are already crowned.



high levels =|= good dots
 
Jayadamo
Vol4Life
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by amace

high levels =|= good dots


no clue what that means
 
Jayadamo
Vol4Life
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
I agree with this, you can't just look at playoff records and what not.

this team tanked on purpose I would imagine so they can get a lol18 cap trophy

also I know a team that did not make the playoffs and got promoted to AAA

if they can't make the playoffs in AA how are they going to do in AAA?


not sure they purposely tanked, they did finish 8-8 but regardless it is BS.
 
amace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jayadamo DTD
Originally posted by amace


high levels =|= good dots


no clue what that means


high levels don't equal good dots.

but mainly I'm just posting crap. it does need to be fixed.

I say, for promotions, if you have any players over the cap, you move up automatically. You should be allowed to fit into the lowest possible cap you qualify for. If you have any players over that cap, you move up, no questions asked.

Thats really the only fair way to do it. Forcing a playoff team to move up 2 caps doesn't work. There are 7-9 teams making the playoffs, if they can barely make it in one league, they'll have no chance 2 caps up.
 
Sprocket
offline
Link
 
Working as intended. Unfortunately.

It should be done by effective levels, which is what I thought was going to happen this season.
 
Jayadamo
Vol4Life
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by amace
high levels don't equal good dots.

but mainly I'm just posting crap. it does need to be fixed.

I say, for promotions, if you have any players over the cap, you move up automatically. You should be allowed to fit into the lowest possible cap you qualify for. If you have any players over that cap, you move up, no questions asked.

Thats really the only fair way to do it. Forcing a playoff team to move up 2 caps doesn't work. There are 7-9 teams making the playoffs, if they can barely make it in one league, they'll have no chance 2 caps up.


thank you I agree
 
amace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sprocket
Working as intended. Unfortunately.

It should be done by effective levels, which is what I thought was going to happen this season.


effective levels are crap.

my solution is quite simple, and will easilly work.

Force teams into the lowest cap they qualify for unless they request a higher cap. no more teams full of level 15s in cap 22, no more teams with mostly level 28's and a 39 runningback merking cap 28, they move up to cap 42, or cut the runningback.
 
Jayadamo
Vol4Life
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by amace
effective levels are crap.

my solution is quite simple, and will easilly work.

Force teams into the lowest cap they qualify for unless they request a higher cap. no more teams full of level 15s in cap 22, no more teams with mostly level 28's and a 39 runningback merking cap 28, they move up to cap 42, or cut the runningback.


 
temujin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by amace
effective levels are crap.

my solution is quite simple, and will easilly work.

Force teams into the lowest cap they qualify for unless they request a higher cap. no more teams full of level 15s in cap 22, no more teams with mostly level 28's and a 39 runningback merking cap 28, they move up to cap 42, or cut the runningback.


 
Squeally
offline
Link
 
You guys need to consolidate threads...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4024653
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
if players are over the league limit at the beginning a team should have 2 choices:
a: cut everyone over limit on day 41.
b: take another promotion to a level their players fit on day 42.
 
cdd757
offline
Link
 
I like this. imo, leagues should not be decided based on how you did last season, but on your team's player levels. Competitive/Elite leagues should be the only thing looking into previous standings.
 
Link
 
For this particular situation, I would agree that it appears the system has failed.
I guess it works if you're a commie.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.