User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > New financial plan hurts starter teams
Page:
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
This is a comparison of the new way and the old way. I am going to use a cap 4 team that I co-own and that is being built for the long term, so minimum contracts and maximum stadium construction.

*I am assuming that although Catch based his numbers on 1.4 times, that a starter team will only be able to charge expected.

The process for a new team is take out an initial loan, buy Corner and Endzone, and spent some money to buy level 100 seats. We ended up with 10K 100 Sidelines, 800 100 Clubs, 1840 100 Corners, and 2760 100 Endzones. Both examples assume sell outs for all 8 games. I am going to ignore playoff revenue, since half the teams do not make the playoffs, so counting it into the equation really only considers the best teams while ignoring the worst.

The old way (what actually happened, number rounded for ease of comparison).

Ticket Revenue - $8,100,000
Concessions - $2,800,000
Loan repayment - $1,500,000
Additional Seat costs - $3,500,000
Salary - $854,000 (started at minimum, but some contracts needed renegotiating for training costs)
EQ Costs - $576,000

Money for S16 construction = $4,470,000


The new way:

Ticket Revenue - $5,200,000
Concessions - $1,700,000
Loan repayment - $1,500,000
Additional Seat costs - $3,500,000
Salary - $840,000 (48 players at minimum)

Money for S16 construction = $1,060,000 (and that is assuming no promotions are bought).

---------------------

FWIW, if you use 1.4 times expected for ticket prices in the new system, the numbers are a bit better.

Ticket Revenue increases to $7,200,000 so the money for S16 construction goes up to just over $3 million. However, that is still lower and I am skeptical that new teams will be able to get the same price as established teams with near max fan support.

----------------------

Consider that all of the above is a very aggressive, long term first season financial plan. Many owners will not be as efficient and will find themselves in an even bigger hole with respect to stadium expansion.
Edited by Plankton on May 5, 2010 09:56:03
 
The Smith
offline
Link
 
good comparison
and good luck getting all players at minimum salary
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Smith
good comparison
and good luck getting all players at minimum salary


We were able to since we have a solid group of agents that like to play together, but that is a good point as well. This is not only a very aggressive financial plan but using players that are all on the same page. If you were truly starting off fresh and had to recruit 40+ players, it might be very difficult to break even, much less buy stadium. I think I'll do a comparison of less efficient stadium building, and see what the numbers show.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
I'm at a complete loss. This does not bode well.

Financial systems are horribly flawed. No testing was being performed and I can't recall that we were even asked to run the numbers etc.

Game just became a LOT harder for new owners. Established teams with full stadiums have things much easier.

Is there any point to these changes Catch/Bort? I can't seem to locate any threads where people were asking for the game to be even harder/onerous as an owner and lower level teams screwed.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
This comparison will use a more "normal" team. 40 players signed at the median salary. Owner expands 3 Corners but no seats. Thus, he has 8000 100 Sidelines, 600 Clubs, 5520 Corners.

The old way:

Ticket Revenue - $6,600,000
Concessions - $2,500,000
Loan repayment - $1,500,00
Salary - $1,100,000 (double lvl 1 minimum, but no renegotiation + some signing bonuses)
EQ Costs - $576,000

Money for S16 stadium construction = $5,924,000 (although they have fewer seats)

The new way:

Ticket Revenue - $4,700,000
Concessions - $1,500,000
Loan repayment - $1,500,000
Salary - $3,500,000 (40 players at the median salary is over the salary cap, so using salary cap as the value)

Money for S16 stadium construction = $1,200,000

Again, if 30/10/0 support can get the same as 100/85/50, then using 1.4 times will add $1.8 million but the new way still has the starter team having at least $3 million less for stadium construction.
 
PING72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Smith
and good luck getting all players at minimum salary


And don't forget, that even if you do manage to sign them all at minimum salary that with the other new changes, playing for the minimum salary will hurt morale!
 
Sal Basss
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PING72
Originally posted by The Smith

and good luck getting all players at minimum salary


And don't forget, that even if you do manage to sign them all at minimum salary that with the other new changes, playing for the minimum salary will hurt morale!


No, it won't. You won't get any bonus to morale, but you don't get penalized either.
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Doesn't really matter since everyone has the same limitations.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
I'm at a complete loss. This does not bode well.

Financial systems are horribly flawed. No testing was being performed and I can't recall that we were even asked to run the numbers etc.

Game just became a LOT harder for new owners. Established teams with full stadiums have things much easier.

Is there any point to these changes Catch/Bort? I can't seem to locate any threads where people were asking for the game to be even harder/onerous as an owner and lower level teams screwed.


Testers, including a Lead Tester (or two?) are coming out off the woodwork now with similar sentiments.

Lovely.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
Doesn't really matter since everyone has the same limitations.


This is true down the road, when every team that was started the old way are promoted high enough or have demoted and reset. However, in the short term the new teams have to play existing teams will suffer.

Consider the brand new cap 18 team that starts off with only slightly better than a starter stadium, but also has $600,000 higher salary cap. That same cap 18 will be playing my team that has a full completed 100 Level. As our two teams progess, the costs of stadium sections will make it hard for the new guy to catchup. It will take more seasons and during that time he will have to sacrifice promotionals to maximize his stadium or he will never catchup.

The old system allowed just about any team to complete a stadium in three or four seasons. With this new system, it will take longer, and thus hurt the new owner.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
In fact, let's look at that brand new cap 18 team. He starts off with both sidelines and 1 corner + $2 million. He gets $1.5 million more via a loan, so he has $3.5 million to expand. That would buy an EZ and two Corners, bringing his initial stadium to 8000 100 SL, 600 100 Club, 5520 100 Corners, 2760 100 Endzones.

Ticket Revenue - $5,400,000
Concessions - $1,800,000
Loan repayment - $1,500,000
Salary - $4,200,000 (40 players at the median salary is over the salary cap, so using salary cap as the value)

Money for S16 stadium construction = $1,500,000 (assuming no promotionals).

That + a loan will only give him enough to finish the 100 level (add 100 corner and 100 EZ) plus start to work on seat expansion. There is very little room to expand seats in the preseason, since he will need all of the money from selling out his first two games just to pay off the loan, and still needs some money for salaries on day one. Thus, he really needs to sell out his first 3 games in the preseason, so there is little to no room for maximizing pricing.

----

My team (Cap 18)

For the sake of comparison, going to use the same ticket prices. The reality is that we should be able to charge more than the startup Cap 18 team, since we are at 100/53/22 support. With a completed 100 level and some seat expansion done, I will have 10000 100 SL, 800 100 Club, 7800 100 Corners, 5520 100 Endzones.

Ticket Revenue - $7,600,000
Concessions - $2,500,000
Loan repayment - $1,500,000
Salary - $4,200,000 (40 players at the median salary is over the salary cap, so using salary cap as the value)

Money for S16 stadium construction = $4,400,000 (assuming no promotionals).

I will pay off the loan after selling out one and a half games and may have money for seat expansion. I excluded that from this, but it would only further stretch the difference in the two teams. With $4.4 million + $1.5 million from a loan, I could buy both sidelines for Season 17.

------

I can take this on and on, but the point is that reducing everything but stadium expansion hurts new teams and their ability to build their stadium, as compared to teams which are already on their way. Over time, that difference may lead to significant financial advantages. In the end, this whole change is to avoid that very situation, so it seems like this should be looked at.

-------
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Testers, including a Lead Tester (or two?) are coming out off the woodwork now with similar sentiments.

Lovely.


Hoping I'm not included in this.

I'm looking forward to the changes.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Prices were reduced for the various moral reserve/bonus items... This is cool.

I'm just very surprised at the out of the blue 40% reduction in the earnings of a team. Those make sense when one looks at the costs being reduced for the boosters, but the original stadium pieces etc are still expensive.

Likely closer to 'reality' but just not sure its 'fun' and it does put new teams/new stadiums at a marked disadvantage. Its goign to take them longer, so it appears, to build their stadium up AND if they want to maintain competitiveness, they'll have to be matching other teams expenditures for the reserve items.

Not such a big deal if you are in a cap 4 with other people starting as cap 4. But there's going to be some areas where a team has moved down/failed to move up and not lost stadium bits and have a significant advantage.

Sure, this means they will likely then start moving back up....

I'm just not sure that it makes a lot of sense though to make stadium building that much more difficult/barrier to entry for new owners so much more steep.

Team Owners are what make the game possible and popular IMO.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Testers, including a Lead Tester (or two?) are coming out off the woodwork now with similar sentiments.

Lovely.


Hey, I haven't said a damn thing either way on this for a while now....Whether I agree or disagree, it is what it is and I'll do what I have to do to work with what is being implemented. So, I'd rather not be lumped into this either. Enkidu98 is just going on a steam blowing and troop rallying mission. Like it or not, I've been involved long enough with the more inside stuff to believe it isn't going to change anything and Enkidu98 knows that too, if he's been paying any attention at all.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
No offense, but if you guys want to fight about testers' attitudes, please go to one of the other multitude of threads which are basically flame fests.

I would like to keep this one on target at least until Bort/Catch sees it and weighs in on if this was an over-sight or working as intended. Thanks.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.