User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Alcoholism and obestiy
Page:
 
LT2501
offline
Link
 
So I was reading through Drakus' thread that was locked and it got me thinking.

Is there really anyone that believes alcoholism and obesity are diseases? I know I dont, as I know or have known both alcoholics and obese people, throughout my young life and I dont think any of the people with the pre-formentioned issues would say they had a disease.

I know many people will say, especially in relation to alcoholism, that not being aware of their "disease", or addiction as people like myself would put it, is an indication of how it is a disease, however I myself dont buy into that. So anyway I just thought I would start this discussion again, as I was pretty interested in Darkus's thread.
 
FredEx
offline
Link
 
man, I am being pulled closer and closer to supporting meritocracy by the day
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
noocracy.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
I'm less inclined to weigh in on the alcoholism issue because I haven't actually looked into the facts.

Obesity is, generally speaking, not a disease. The vast majority of obese people are in that state due to their lifestyles. I do however know at least one person who is overweight due to medical issues, so while obesity is not a disease in and of itself it can in specific circumstances be a symptom of other issues.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
and obesity is a symptom, caused by everything from hypothyroidism to eating disorders to side effects from treatment.

and alcoholism is a chemical dependency, caused by everything from physical/psychological addiction to clinical depression to bad choices.
 
LT2501
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
I'm less inclined to weigh in on the alcoholism issue because I haven't actually looked into the facts.

Obesity is, generally speaking, not a disease. The vast majority of obese people are in that state due to their lifestyles. I do however know at least one person who is overweight due to medical issues, so while obesity is not a disease in and of itself it can in specific circumstances be a symptom of other issues.


I agree with you there, I know that many people are obese due to issues such as overactive thyroids ( I think that is correct) however i refuse to let other people in many cases blame their adiction to alcohol or over eating purely on a "disease" that is non existent.
 
LT2501
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
and obesity is a symptom, caused by everything from hypothyroidism to eating disorders to side effects from treatment.

and alcoholism is a chemical dependency, caused by everything from physical/psychological addiction to clinical depression to bad choices.


alcoholism is a chemical dependency? For every alcoholic? Are you sure? really?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LT2501
alcoholism is a chemical dependency? For every alcoholic? Are you sure? really?


pretty much the definition, yes. ethanol is the chemical and the -ism is the dependency.

but also note → http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3951859&page=4#35206500
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LT2501
I agree with you there, I know that many people are obese due to issues such as overactive thyroids ( I think that is correct) however i refuse to let other people in many cases blame their adiction to alcohol or over eating purely on a "disease" that is non existent.


underactive thyroids -- hypothyroidism.
 
RocketSlime
offline
Link
 
Both alcoholism and obesity are diseases and do not require my/your belief in them to be so.
 
vuvuzela
offline
Link
 
can we call alcoholism and obesity conditions or am i not understanding the concept of conditions? but i do not think they are diseases
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RocketSlime
Both alcoholism and obesity are diseases and do not require my/your belief in them to be so.


well, they are only technically diseases because the AMA has filed them as addictive disorders, but anyone thinking that such disorders behave like the common cold is missing the entire point of the medical definition of 'disease'.

and that's without going into the politics of the AMA -- of course they call everything a disease. there's big money in that.
 
FredEx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
well, they are only technically diseases because the AMA has filed them as addictive disorders, but anyone thinking that such disorders behave like the common cold is missing the entire point of the medical definition of 'disease'.

and that's without going into the politics of the AMA -- of course they call everything a disease. there's big money in that.


going into cdcollins mode here: THIS.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nl319
can we call alcoholism and obesity conditions or am i not understanding the concept of conditions? but i do not think they are diseases


depends on your definition of disease.

for example -- the AMA considers suicidal ideation to be a disease. why? because you've got the brain telling the body to kill itself and that's not normal. it's basically a dismissal of the mind/body problem so that things can crank through the FDA and drugs can be distributed through normal channels. similarly, chemical dependencies of whatever stripe are once again the brain telling the body to harm itself, so the AMA treats it the same way.

really, it depends on where you fall on the mind/body problem. the AMA considers the brain to be wholly part of the body, so there ya go.
 
RocketSlime
offline
Link
 
Yes, there are lots of people that think all diseases act the same. I mean, heart disease and the common cold are so god-damned similar.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.