User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Lv 18 Minor Leagues > Lv 18 Minor League #1 > What Do You Think About The New Changes?
Page:
 
SlashNDash
DASHING
offline
Link
 
It's on the announcement page, so no need to link to it.

Thanks to the changes to finances, it appears that I'll be gutting the Trap Road Spiders after this season, and just playing until my flex runs out. I started playing this game because I thought the fun/work quotient would be about even. After reading about the changes, I'm done. I refuse to pay someone money to take on a second job, which is what this game is turning into.

Every time I turn around lately, my ass hurts.

What do you guys think of the new changes?
 
Jrob24
offline
Link
 
I am all about improving the game. There is definitely a lot in these changes that will impact the game. But I still love the dots and will continue to do what it takes to see them play hard.
 
Link
 
I've had a quick look through and i'm all in favor of adding new levels of complexity to the game.

As good as it was to bring in rules to stop teams gutting and piling up cash - alot of them had been doing it for awhile and they are swimming around lowish levels with stupid amounts of cash.

A general reset depending on level sounds good.

A salary cap would very welcome aswell - for the reasons statetd above - instead of just going into the market and outbidding everyone else for higher level players you'll have to choose carefully what players you want...at the expense of others.

I'm hoping the coaches thing doesn;t mean i have to employ any - i'd rather run it all myself - to that end - its my money and that how i'd like to spend it.

So we'll see how that goes,.

All-in-all it looks pretty positiive.
 
SlashNDash
DASHING
offline
Link
 
ESB

Coaches will add a certain boost to the players. So I'd imagine that after a while, it'll be hard to win without them. So, whether you want to do it all yourself or not, you may get to the point where you have to hire some to be competitive.

On my team, I am the HC/DC/OC/CFO/STC, etc. Through it all, the game wasn't getting in the way of my fun (even the archetypes which I wasn't particularly a fan of, but I understood the need for them). The more they add, the more they tilt the scales on the work-to-fun ratio. So far, the great majority of the people in the discussion thread feel the same way. Of the more than 17 pages I've read thus far, there has been a grand total of maybe three people who are in favor of the financial changes. It was a healthy even mix when the archetypes were announced.

I'll likely be going back to playing Cyber Nations instead of this. Too many arbitrary changes lately . I understand this is a beta, but input from paying customers would actually be nice every now and then...

 
SlashNDash
DASHING
offline
Link
 
To better articulate what I was saying, here is a quote from one of the load testers....

Originally posted by

Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by jdbolick


Dude, please look at what people are posting. Long-time, dedicated agents like myself who spend way too much fucking time on this site are looking at these proposed changes and just coming away feeling like it's time to stop playing. I'm not saying that to manipulate you or to try and get you to do something different, the reality is that I'm just really damn tired of how complicated this game is becoming. It's not fun anymore. You and Bort need to spend more time finding out what your customers want instead of just doing whatever you think would be neat.


This will be my only comment on this and I'll shutup, but I have to agree with jdbolick. No matter how easy the interface is, 4 of the changes will require ppl to invest more time and only 1 will save time (eliminating the EQ fund, and that virtually took next to 0 time). Honestly, I think in theory these are all great ideas. The burn is that many, many, many of us are already spending more time here than we can afford and just don't have more to play a game.

Also, I was all for making conf & energy mean something, but increasing its importance again this next off ssn and then the new changes outlined here is making it way over the top, IMO. Dots with low stamina & confidence are already painful enough to watch.

As promised. I'll shut up about this now and I'll do my damnedest to do my part to help make it work. I just wish we were making the game less time consuming and more fun to watch our dots, instead of the opposite.




Pretty much sums up how I'm feeling about this right now...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SlashNDash
ESB

Coaches will add a certain boost to the players. So I'd imagine that after a while, it'll be hard to win without them. So, whether you want to do it all yourself or not, you may get to the point where you have to hire some to be competitive.

On my team, I am the HC/DC/OC/CFO/STC, etc. Through it all, the game wasn't getting in the way of my fun (even the archetypes which I wasn't particularly a fan of, but I understood the need for them). The more they add, the more they tilt the scales on the work-to-fun ratio. So far, the great majority of the people in the discussion thread feel the same way. Of the more than 17 pages I've read thus far, there has been a grand total of maybe three people who are in favor of the financial changes. It was a healthy even mix when the archetypes were announced.

I'll likely be going back to playing Cyber Nations instead of this. Too many arbitrary changes lately . I understand this is a beta, but input from paying customers would actually be nice every now and then...



I see. Well I guess we;ll see how it easy to go about finding coaches..so I can tell them excatly what I want doing...and how I want it done!!

I enjoy the extra stuff to study - lets be brutally honest here there are plenty of idiots who make players, own teams etc - they'll get weeded out because they cant handle what they are doing right now.

I'm absolutely in favor of the financial stuff because it should make you earn extra money with good strategy instead of cheating the old system by gutting teams and transferring money with players.

It seems to be moving to what the real game is about.

Now if they can get back to fixing tackling on outside runs i'll be happy
 
Jrob24
offline
Link
 
i hope they don't fix the tackling on outside runs.
 
boogiee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Empire_Strikes_Back
I see. Well I guess we;ll see how it easy to go about finding coaches..so I can tell them excatly what I want doing...and how I want it done!!

I enjoy the extra stuff to study - lets be brutally honest here there are plenty of idiots who make players, own teams etc - they'll get weeded out because they cant handle what they are doing right now.

I'm absolutely in favor of the financial stuff because it should make you earn extra money with good strategy instead of cheating the old system by gutting teams and transferring money with players.

It seems to be moving to what the real game is about.

Now if they can get back to fixing tackling on outside runs i'll be happy




Can't you just create multiple accounts and that way you can control all the coaches? I ask because I don't know if you can create multiple accounts cause I've never had a reason to try it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by boogiee


Can't you just create multiple accounts and that way you can control all the coaches? I ask because I don't know if you can create multiple accounts cause I've never had a reason to try it.


No you can't.

Guy tried doing that on a team I was DC'ing for and he got caught - he had to delete the extra account and got warned.
 
SlashNDash
DASHING
offline
Link
 
ESB

That's part of my point as well. The sim is still SOL&PWF (shit out of luck and pretty well fucked), but what they are doing now is the wholesale major changes they've decided to make? It just seems so misguided and drawkcabssa (assbackward). I get little to no change for the extra work they're giving me to do. In the end, people will still be stuck with a FB who lead blocks like he's a dyslexic epileptic.
Edited by SlashNDash on Apr 15, 2010 20:53:59
Edited by SlashNDash on Apr 15, 2010 20:53:03
 
OBFuSCaTe
offline
Link
 
I'll reserve judgement until once I see the implementation. Face value, I believe everything that has been posted so far adds to the game and will make it more interesting. Problem is, the way it will be implemented has increased the complexity of the game substantially. Ultimately I think this complexity will lead to fewer owners as there is just too much that needs to be done. Also the training system has become substantially more complicated then previously. I think this will turn off casual players as they don't want to think about playing the game.

In the end I'm fine with the general idea of the changes but would have preferred the implementation being done better. There is simply too much that needs to be considered as you go forward. Lets face facts, when the changes are so substantially long that you need cliff notes and examples to understand what is going on, then clearly that is an issue.

I'll give the changes about 2 seasons worth of play then decide how I feel. Then figure out how much I want to play and in what capacity.
Edited by OBFuSCaTe on Apr 15, 2010 22:05:42
 
Link
 
Originally posted by OBFuSCaTe
I'll reserve judgement until once I see the implementation. Face value, I believe everything that has been posted so far adds to the game and will make it more interesting. Problem is, the way it will be implemented has increased the complexity of the game substantially. Ultimately I think this complexity will lead to fewer owners as there is just too much that needs to be done. Also the training system has become substantially more complicated then previously. I think this will turn off casual players as they don't want to think about playing the game.

In the end I'm fine with the general idea of the changes but would have preferred the implementation being done better. There is simply too much that needs to be considered as you go forward. Lets face facts, when the changes are so substantially long that you need cliff notes and examples to understand what is going on, then clearly that is an issue.

I'll give the changes about 2 seasons worth of play then decide how I feel. Then figure out how much I want to play and in what capacity.


I absolutely agree with the part about the added complexity forcing owers out of the game.

I've read plenty fo comments from people complaining about being forced to spend more money on the game - I think the man issue is the workload they are putting on people.

Its very possible they are allowing their statistical geekery to work against their business model - it should be more inclusive not less so.

I find the casual tactics unworkable for the most part - just too simple to gain any enjoyment - yet they obviously exist for a reason.

Now these people are being forced to take on extra stat crunching etc - it would also help if they provided GLB spreadsheets that you could plug various numbers into to see what woriks best.

I don't fancy doing a part time course in accountancy just to build a new stand.
 
OBFuSCaTe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Empire_Strikes_Back
I absolutely agree with the part about the added complexity forcing owers out of the game.

I've read plenty fo comments from people complaining about being forced to spend more money on the game - I think the man issue is the workload they are putting on people.

Its very possible they are allowing their statistical geekery to work against their business model - it should be more inclusive not less so.

I find the casual tactics unworkable for the most part - just too simple to gain any enjoyment - yet they obviously exist for a reason.

Now these people are being forced to take on extra stat crunching etc - it would also help if they provided GLB spreadsheets that you could plug various numbers into to see what woriks best.

I don't fancy doing a part time course in accountancy just to build a new stand.


I agree with most everything you said. The new additions pretty much means one day when I'm bored at work I'll need to bring out excel and figure out what exactly is the best route. Do I want to do that? No. If it is a one time thing then I guess I can swallow it. But I already spent a lot of time recruiting & game planning. If this forces me to spend more time on the game then eh, I'll probably give up ownership.

But as I said, I'll give it 1-2 seasons. If it is too much of a headache I might actually end up just keeping a casual team. Or if iron leagues come out, I'll go that route. In the end a game should be fun, not a workload. I already have one job, I'll pass on a second.
 
NUNYO
offline
Link
 
I've read a bit on it, and being a owner of two team and DC of 4 others, I am going to have to seriously think about making some changes myself. I already spend to much time on this site to begin with. I like the game and think it could be more than it is. It would be great if they could figure out a way to have real players and games that we could watch like video game football. Ya right!!!! But to create a game so complex that the average Joe coming off the street will be turned off due to the complexity of the sign ups now. You have to get a credit check done to join now from what I heard. Guess what I'm really trying to say is, I'm unhappy with the way the game is going and I may be forced to down size my players to be able have coaches for my teams to be able to compete, and me personnally putting any more cash into this is not going to happen. I have a few players retiring at the end of the season and their flex and my others will take me as far as I'm going to go.

Game is being ruined!!!!
 
LT56
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lemmonkeith
I've read a bit on it, and being a owner of two team and DC of 4 others, I am going to have to seriously think about making some changes myself. I already spend to much time on this site to begin with. I like the game and think it could be more than it is. It would be great if they could figure out a way to have real players and games that we could watch like video game football. Ya right!!!! But to create a game so complex that the average Joe coming off the street will be turned off due to the complexity of the sign ups now. You have to get a credit check done to join now from what I heard. Guess what I'm really trying to say is, I'm unhappy with the way the game is going and I may be forced to down size my players to be able have coaches for my teams to be able to compete, and me personnally putting any more cash into this is not going to happen. I have a few players retiring at the end of the season and their flex and my others will take me as far as I'm going to go.

Game is being ruined!!!!


I tend to agree with a lot of what you're saying.

It's no longer a game to me. ...it is becoming a job.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.