User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Lv 30 Minor Leagues > Lv 30 Minor League #3 > African Arms Dealers vs Tilburg Lightning (When game bugs attack!)
Page:
 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3785752&page=1#33493040

And AAD it was a great game and much respect to you guys. Just too bad that this possession ended up being the game. Ofcourse we had plenty of chances later and AAD's defense came up big with some huge plays to stop us.

Edited by Kotoll on Feb 17, 2010 19:15:49
 
lbrlove
offline
Link
 
Definitely a good game, sorry both teams do not get the W. Turn your evidence over to the admins though. I have already found a bug in the DAI resultant from the addition of the I Form tag and some faulty parsing logic. Screwed by that one earlier this season, although not very dramatically in terms of game situation.

Bottom line, I not so boldly predict that nobody is getting out of this season unscathed. There are just too many well-coached teams with good rosters, all pretty well used to winning. And if it has been brutal already, just wait until the playoffs. Kudos to Bort for the Elite leagues - whoever wins a conference or league here will have done something real.
 
Lambda
offline
Link
 
there are certainly bugs with the OAI (and DAI) calling plays that are not in the playbook in situations where a specific input should be triggered. it doesn't happen often, but when it does it can suck because it's usually a terrible or at least inappropriate play. i've only had that happen to me on a single play a couple times throughout the game, not an entire drive however.

one specific example i remember was last season we played a team with a tagged scrambler. i didn't touch the DAI (and no one else on the team did) since the last game featuring a tagged scrambler, but it called a random base AI play the entire game when the scrambler was in out of a certain formation. only that formation, and only that particular game. still without changing anything, the next game called the correct tag plays against that formation, and every game since has been fine.

that said, you didn't really need to announce this to the league. it comes off as a little petty even with the semi-props at the end. you're obviously a playoff team, show everyone how good you are the rest of the season and especially in the playoffs.
Edited by Lambda on Feb 17, 2010 21:31:34
 
mrbungle151
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lambda
that said, you didn't really need to announce this to the league. it comes off as a little petty


QFT

 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
Well like I said I have done this awhile and heard grips but I have never seen it myself. I actually posted more for the reason to get feedback like yours Lambda and others who might have experienced something like this. Here at least we get responses from good coordinators instead of some fucking moron from casual.

 
herbdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
Well like I said I have done this awhile and heard grips but I have never seen it myself. I actually posted more for the reason to get feedback like yours Lambda and others who might have experienced something like this. Here at least we get responses from good coordinators instead of some fucking moron from casual.



They are just that much better then your team ...IMO
 
pratt1130
offline
Link
 
nothing to see here
Edited by pratt1130 on Feb 18, 2010 08:06:49
Edited by pratt1130 on Feb 18, 2010 05:14:16
 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pratt1130
Why does everyone have to make excuses when they lose?? You lost your previous game to Atlanta Traffic and you blamed that one on ST's. Can't you just say good game and then seek revenge in the playoffs instead of coming off as a sore loser?


We did ? Atlanta Traffic gave us a beat down and had a better game plan going in. Nothing more.

And we had many chances after the the first possession to beat AAD and we didn't. This is more about the game having a serious bug then a loss. AI errors happen alot due to the users not setting them correctly. Thats part of the game. But having the AI error up randomly isn't. No one that does OC or DC work wants to see that ever happen and it shouldn't
 
pratt1130
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
Originally posted by pratt1130

Why does everyone have to make excuses when they lose?? You lost your previous game to Atlanta Traffic and you blamed that one on ST's. Can't you just say good game and then seek revenge in the playoffs instead of coming off as a sore loser?


We did ? Atlanta Traffic gave us a beat down and had a better game plan going in. Nothing more.

And we had many chances after the the first possession to beat AAD and we didn't. This is more about the game having a serious bug then a loss. AI errors happen alot due to the users not setting them correctly. Thats part of the game. But having the AI error up randomly isn't. No one that does OC or DC work wants to see that ever happen and it shouldn't


As you can see I deleted that post. lol I was confusing you with someone else. Still hate excuses. I have had some bad losses on AAD and I either come in here and say GG or say nothing at all. No need to make a thread about it deminshining the other teams win. Shit hapens.
 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 


Originally posted by pratt1130
As you can see I deleted that post. lol I was confusing you with someone else. Still hate excuses. I have had some bad losses on AAD and I either come in here and say GG or say nothing at all. No need to make a thread about it deminshining the other teams win. Shit hapens.


Nothing is set in stone this season on who makes the playoffs and who doesn't. There is some good teams out there that will be disappointed, Lightning could easily be one of those teams.Every win is extremely important here. But if the GLB Gods do us right we'll see you in the playoffs.

BTW any of your losses due to random game bugs in your AI? Or did those fall under excuses and were never fixed or brought to attention?





 
pratt1130
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
Originally posted by pratt1130

As you can see I deleted that post. lol I was confusing you with someone else. Still hate excuses. I have had some bad losses on AAD and I either come in here and say GG or say nothing at all. No need to make a thread about it deminshining the other teams win. Shit hapens.


Nothing is set in stone this season on who makes the playoffs and who doesn't. There is some good teams out there that will be disappointed, Lightning could easily be one of those teams.Every win is extremely important here. But if the GLB Gods do us right we'll see you in the playoffs.

BTW any of your losses due to random game bugs in your AI? Or did those fall under excuses and were never fixed or brought to attention?


No worries man. Not trying to get into a big arguement about it.


Edited by pratt1130 on Feb 18, 2010 10:08:10
 
lbrlove
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
BTW any of your losses due to random game bugs in your AI? Or did those fall under excuses and were never fixed or brought to attention?


Cannot speak for pratt, but I know over the seasons I have blown a game or two with mistakes in my AI. I have seen actual, verifiable bugs on only two occasions, season 5 and this season. Neither cost me a game in the latter cases, but concerned me because they were extant.

Bottom line, I am a long-time IT guy and programmer. We learn early to resist the urge to blame the compiler. Better than 99% of the time the error is in logic. Sometimes it is a logical error that is not evident, meaning there are some undocumented "rules" underlying the thing. But nonetheless, it is bad practice to blame the system first (like within the near hours after a game).

The other thing I notice is that people are very quick to start rooting through things after blaming the system and making changes. Once you make a change of any kind, whether germane to the observed problem or not, you have made it conveniently so that you cannot seek admin scrutiny. When they see the update timestamp on the DB logs, they know you have tampered with the thing and will not touch it. That is a smart policy for them, but I guess it gives the would-be submitter some sort of limp license to gripe.

General advice, not directed at anybody in particular:

If you suspect you were screwed by an actual bug, DO NOT CHANGE ANYTHING. Send your evidence along with helpful pointers (team ID, game ID, links as appropriate) to the admins via a Bug Report. They will know from the DB logs if you changed anything, so resist the urge.

Obviously, you should not do this unless you have a high degree of certainty it is a bug, and be prepared to be shown where you are wrong. The lion's share of cases will humble the irate submitter. But you definitely might learn something (some of those undocumented "rules") so it would be worthwhile if your curiosity exceeds your pride.
 
joshv12345
offline
Link
 
The play in question had a lot of weird circumstances surrounding it. fourth and inches, on a .5 yard line. Run it through the offensive AI tester with all the same info from the game and see what comes up. If your AI outputs changed between 6/7 yards to go (IE 2nd 7-10 input then a 2nd 4-6 input) you might just need to change the order to cover that gap of the .5 yard. I know this happened to me one time when I set up my AI. I had something similar to my example above, but neither of the out puts pick up 6.5 yards. I figured out that if I wanted to cover the half yard lines, the out puts had to be set up 6-10 ytg, then 4-6. (just an example, not a sneak peak into my AI).

I have had a couple instances where I though I was screwed by the sim, and extremely pissed off about a "L". Most of the time, I found that it was my fault, and that there was a small mistake in the AI. Not saying you made a mistake, just trying to help you figure out what might have went wrong.
 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
lbrlove I completely agree and actually thought I might have screwed something up. I changed short yardage plays a little and my redzone. But I went through it again and found nothing amiss. After that I had some trusted friends look at the AI to see if they could find anything to explain it. Nothing.

So right now the AI hasn't been changed and two Bug Mods will be looking at my AI to see if its the AI or an actual bug. Either way it will be good to have an answer. NOTHING has been changed after that game and will stay like that until the mods have a look.

And like you two guys said. Almost 99% of the time its us that screwed up our AI and caused the plays in game. Been over a year and half that time I have OC'd off and on. This is the first time though I couldn't find my mistake or anyone else. If the mods find a error or if its my AI i'll make sure to let you all know.
Edited by Kotoll on Feb 18, 2010 14:05:32
 
lbrlove
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
So right now the AI hasn't been changed and two Bug Mods will be looking at my AI to see if its the AI or an actual bug. Either way it will be good to have an answer. NOTHING has been changed after that game and will stay like that until the mods have a look.


Awesome, that is the attitude that makes the game better for everyone. Since you are willing to put your proverbial money where your mouth is, sounds good. And for the record, I am not stating it is not a bug (despite our spies pratt spoke of and filming your walk-throughs, I wouldn't know). Like I said, I have seen them before, but they are rare.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.