User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Too Many and Unbalanced Penalities in Lower Level Leagues - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Ryiotgear
offline
Link
 
I've been watching quite a bit of dotball this season in the level 14 cap leagues and I've been really surprised by the amount and lack of balance in penalties at this level. False start penalties make things extremely difficult for the offenses right now.

I assume this is fairly pervasive across the board until dots start to hit a certain level of maturity. Bort could easily query penalty data across all leagues & levels to find these answers, hence the limited scope of my review. I don't necessarily think this is a bug in the traditional sense, but there is no way this is working as intended.

So here is what I was seeing. I looked at all 32 games from Minors Level 14 #1 ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=111 ) and Minors Level 14 #10 ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=153 ) that simmed this evening. In those 32 games there were a total of 462 penalties! This comes out to just around 15 penalties per game. To get an idea of what those penalties are, I used the pbp filter to quickly view all penalty plays only. I looked at 4 games in this manner across 2 normal level 14 capped teams ( 2 games from this team http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=470 and 2 games from this team http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4242 ). In those 4 games, 65 of the 66 penalties were false starts - this means approximately 99% of penalties go against the offense... and remember, we aren't talking 99% of 4 or 5 penalties - this is from 15 penalties per game.

So 2 questions: 1) Is the penalty rate too high? 2) Why is this so unbalanced? Could Bort's nerf to encroachments/Hard Count have inadvertently swung the balance of penalties wildly at the lower levels?

Penalties from Minor League Level 14 #1 - 02/03/2010 Sim
Average = 14
Max = 19
Min = 6
19
6
14
19
10
14
19
9
14
11
19
13
14
16
14
10

Penalties from Minor League Level 14 #10 - 02/03/2010 Sim
Average = 15
Max = 24
Min = 8

19
15
12
10
18
10
13
8
20
21
17
24
9
22
14
9



Edited by Catch22 on Feb 4, 2010 13:14:01
Edited by Eamz on Feb 4, 2010 10:25:23 (LIKELY NOT A BUG)
Edited by Guppy, Inc on Feb 4, 2010 09:16:05 (tagged as not likely a bug, altho personally i think it should be called it a bug)
 
Squab
offline
Link
 
There are a variety of factors that go into this, very complicated. One of the main problems is that vision/energy are the two main factors in false starts, and in the lower leagues, offensive lineman haven't touched either vision or stamina, and a lot of times, there are less players on teams, and they are forced to play too much time, and their energy goes very low.
To me, it seems like a couple of things could be looked at here:
1. False starts/penalties in general should be less frequent in the lower leagues, or at least, the rolls for them should be loosened, since the players don't have good enough attributes to pass them.
2. The data here is important, but really what we need to see is a scrimmage between two competitive, full teams, and see how many penalties there were there.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
this is really more of a suggestion than a bug
 
Ryiotgear
offline
Link
 
Squab - I agree there are legitimate attribute driven reasons why penalties occur for low level dots. I think loosening the requirements is a decent option, but the bigger concern is why do 99% of penalties go against the offense?

Guppy - the suggestion is considering if the frequency of penalties should be toned down a little. The bug is that 99% of penalties go against the offense. There is no way that can be working as intended.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
well the defensive penalties were toned down this season, so this actually doesnt surprise me since it seemed like offense got more penalties even b4 this.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
well the defensive penalties were toned down this season, so this actually doesnt surprise me since it seemed like offense got more penalties even b4 this.


Yeah, I believe that I demonstrated that with the false start chains that I discussed at the end of last season where it seemed that penalties seemed to generally come back-to-back on offense.

Perhaps Bort or someone could explain exactly how a false start happens. Not the formula, but what goes into the roll for the forumla. Many people are going under the assumption that it is vision and confidence mixed with morale, but those are still just assumptions. What we were noticing with false starts is that one false start tends to queue up a whole bunch more false starts...

It just seems that a team either gets a bunch of FS penalties in a game or very few, and that because of their supposed effect on morale they tend to bunch up and be on one or two drives where you just get a whole bunch.

Bort should look at how that is coded and see if that is really his intention... perhaps a bug fix would be to decrease the likelihood of a false start based on player level similar to what Bort did with the passing game.

 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
Yeah, I believe that I demonstrated that with the false start chains that I discussed at the end of last season where it seemed that penalties seemed to generally come back-to-back on offense.

Perhaps Bort or someone could explain exactly how a false start happens. Not the formula, but what goes into the roll for the forumla. Many people are going under the assumption that it is vision and confidence mixed with morale, but those are still just assumptions. What we were noticing with false starts is that one false start tends to queue up a whole bunch more false starts...

It just seems that a team either gets a bunch of FS penalties in a game or very few, and that because of their supposed effect on morale they tend to bunch up and be on one or two drives where you just get a whole bunch.

Bort should look at how that is coded and see if that is really his intention... perhaps a bug fix would be to decrease the likelihood of a false start based on player level similar to what Bort did with the passing game.



i've never figured it out. guys with almost no vision/confidence and getting pounded on the line will not have a single penalty. meanwhile on the other team, guys with decent vision/conf and dominating the defense will get called time after time. personally i wish penalties would go away due to what seems no logic besides per randomness in their being called.

i need to tagged this as something, and since i think this is the way bort wants it, i'm going to tag as not likely a bug, but I dont really agree.
 
fnordish
offline
Link
 
Since there is no design doc anyone has to look at for what the rough % of penalities should be I personally would suggest:

Do the same size sampling for 2 preseason games of season 13 and 12 for peewee leagues
Then compare penalities per play for each season.
 
Eamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
i've never figured it out. guys with almost no vision/confidence and getting pounded on the line will not have a single penalty. meanwhile on the other team, guys with decent vision/conf and dominating the defense will get called time after time. personally i wish penalties would go away due to what seems no logic besides per randomness in their being called.

i need to tagged this as something, and since i think this is the way bort wants it, i'm going to tag as not likely a bug, but I dont really agree.


I agree that penalties seem to be purely random. I would throw this data in as a suggestion to get some traction behind it since this isn't likely to be a bug.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
This is more of a suggestion than a bug - it's working as intended right now. It's meant for lower level players to make more mistakes due to their lower attributes.

Closing as not a bug.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.