User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AAA Leagues > South America AAA #1 > New Pro bowl voting for next year.
Page:
 
OtisDriftwood
offline
Link
 
First I would like to get into contact with who did the excel voting last season. If they are still planning on doing it again or did their team move up or whatever. I have a idea that will let everyone participate and its easier no chances of cheating. I for one wasnt able to vote because I didnt have excel to open up the file. So the easiest way to do this would be to create an account for AAA South America at Poll daddy and only send the links to the owners pm accounts. Then we can post the results here after each owner has voted. I created a account already but would like to hear some opinons on this before I put in work on it for this coming season.


Feedback? Anyone who knows the dude that did it last season have him contact me or whatever.
 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
I like this idea since I don't have excel ether
 
brookjacoby5
offline
Link
 
I just copied the different positions and then PM'ed my responses to the guy running it. I think my vote still counted. I never used it excel or the website they had.
 
Korak
offline
Link
 
That idea sounds good.
 
viperz2k5
offline
Link
 
sounds good
 
Ra4xGambit
offline
Link
 
He told everyone who didn't have excel they could just PM him their selections....

Not saying that is a better option than polldaddy by any means, but I am saying that he did give that option.
Last edited Jun 11, 2008 01:15:47
 
Link
 
Sounds good to me.
 
deathmage
offline
Link
 
tht wouldnt be to bad of an idea to do but looks like the moderator for this area is mia an not doing anything not even predictions for this season im about ready to comb through all the teams an do it
 
OtisDriftwood
offline
Link
 
well shouldnt they send a result of the votes? I mean how does anyone know the votes we're counted? The poll will show the exact # of votes.
 
ej dydasco
offline
Link
 
Ok fellas, I was the one who did the vote tallying...Toward the end of the 2nd season I put out threads to inform them to send in their votes in the format specified. Like Ra4xGambit said I gave an alternate way to send in. Only 5 coaches sent in their votes so the outcome was based off of those sent in. The poll way sounds good and I thought of doing it that way but that would be entirely too much names too handle. Doing it the way I did left it to a fair voting from the coaches. If too many people start voting it is hard to track votes(meaning, people might vote more than once on a certain player or even their own.) Unless someone is willing to get all the names from every team that the team wants to nominate for every position then I feel the way I did it was best. This is just my opinion and by all means this is not my baby, I just took the reigns when the topic was brought up..Got to remember that it takes time because if you want it to be fair you have to wait until the regular season is over. Anyways, any advice and suggestions is always welcome, or better yet anyone who wants to take over is more then welcome...P.S. you can go to the AAA S. America forum and look under the (New) All-AAA South America Team to view the results. Trust me when I say that the tallying was tottaly unbiased and was done with the utmost integrity. Thanks.
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
I don't think anyone's actually suggesting that you were unfair, or somehow showed some lack of integrity. In fact, I'm pretty sure everybody really appreciates the work you put into it, ej.
Last edited Jun 13, 2008 06:42:13
 
nearmiss
offline
Link
 
I think the work you put in is amazing. Anything extra is great. Only thing I would like to throw out there, is that all GM / Coachs etc need to vote for players not on roster. I think most of the picks had to be a bit bias so yea. Lets go for a diff approach maybe? Iuno just an idea!
 
Ra4xGambit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nearmiss
I think the work you put in is amazing. Anything extra is great. Only thing I would like to throw out there, is that all GM / Coachs etc need to vote for players not on roster. I think most of the picks had to be a bit bias so yea. Lets go for a diff approach maybe? Iuno just an idea!


Only 2 votes were allowed for a player on your roster. So it is pretty impossible for "most" picks to be biased. I didn't even vote for 2 on my roster.
 
ej dydasco
offline
Link
 
Thanks fellas...I was just replying the way I did to let everyone know that I did the tallying fairly. I wanted to do the poll but it would mean too many names and not enough votes...Can't be having twenty LB's or whatever awarded. I think the coaches who actually turned in votes took the time and checked stats and performances of the players selected. Anyways, thanks everyone.
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ej dydasco
Thanks fellas...I was just replying the way I did to let everyone know that I did the tallying fairly. I wanted to do the poll but it would mean too many names and not enough votes...Can't be having twenty LB's or whatever awarded. I think the coaches who actually turned in votes took the time and checked stats and performances of the players selected. Anyways, thanks everyone.


i am in this year!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.