User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Ok, while we figure out a more efficient (and more objective) process of selecting the top 10 each week, I decided to go ahead and start off w/ a preseason top 10 for fun.

1. Manila Warlords (The only 2 teams that beat them last season are now in the Pro league).
2. Utopia Cobras (Alpha conference runner up)
3. Pa Dong Dragons (16-0 in the regular season, 0-1 in the playoffs)
4. South Austin Bats (Finished 4th in the Zeta conference last season, behind Manila and two now-pro teams.)
5. Bandar Lampung Pigskin Pirates (SEA AA champs are looking to continue their championship run).
6. Neo Armstrong Cyclone Jet Armstrong Cannon (By far the most bizarre name here,NACJAC won a Canadian AA league before making the move over here).
7. Cagayan Rattlers (Posted a 13-3 record last regular season, but have their work cut out for them if they want to improve on that mark.
8. Danang Tigers (SEA AA runner up from last season. They look like they will be pretty competitive here)
9. Perrinton Panthers (Started off great last season, but took a tumble late. Can they pick themselves back up?)
10. Tongduchon Cowboys (Upset the then-Seattle Seabirds in the first round of the playoffs. Is this a sign of things to come, or was that a one-time affair?)

Honorable Mention:
Ujung Padang Supreme Were pretty solid last season, but were blown out in the first round of the playoffs. Could fly under the radar like last season).

Medan Mustangs Were solid during the regular season and lost a heartbreaker to Cagayan in the first round of the playoffs)
 
joe
46 Defense
offline
Link
 
looks good
 
Ceteral
offline
Link
 
I am offended! No Taiwan Dragons?! lol, just kiddin' this looks pretty good.
 
ChicagoBlitz
offline
Link
 
Nice job dude! I know I dont belong here anymore, but AAA was a ton of fun. I will be interested to see what happens this season.
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
How about this: first have one person that's going to add up the votes. After each game, each team's owner/GM can PM their votes to the person responsible for adding up. The following rules would make it easier for the person adding the votes:

1. One vote per team, each team can decide who represents the team in voting. It can be the owner, GM or a player. But each team only can have one entry.
2. Teams can't vote for themselves. If you are good, the others will vote for you.
3. On the PM sent to the vote counter, the message should be in the following format:
Team name: Name of the team that voted
#1: XXXXX
#2: XXXXX
....

4. I would recommend keeping the votes to top 10 teams or something like that. Most people don't have time to really analyze the teams at the bottom, so it probably won't be accurate. NCAA polls only have top 25, not the whole 109 or whatever number of teams they have now.

Anyhow, just my two cents.


I say we do this.


Team owners dose this sound good?

You will send the votes to me and I will post them. After every game. Only do the top 10 thoughs.
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Nice job Punk Im glad to see Pa Dong at #3
 
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
How about this: first have one person that's going to add up the votes. After each game, each team's owner/GM can PM their votes to the person responsible for adding up. The following rules would make it easier for the person adding the votes:

1. One vote per team, each team can decide who represents the team in voting. It can be the owner, GM or a player. But each team only can have one entry.
2. Teams can't vote for themselves. If you are good, the others will vote for you.
3. On the PM sent to the vote counter, the message should be in the following format:
Team name: Name of the team that voted
#1: XXXXX
#2: XXXXX
....

4. I would recommend keeping the votes to top 10 teams or something like that. Most people don't have time to really analyze the teams at the bottom, so it probably won't be accurate. NCAA polls only have top 25, not the whole 109 or whatever number of teams they have now.

Anyhow, just my two cents.


I say we do this.


Team owners dose this sound good?

You will send the votes to me and I will post them. After every game. Only do the top 10 thoughs.


I agree w/ 1,3, and 4. As for #2, I think we should still be able to vote for ourselves. Of course, we'd have to be mature about it and be as objective as possible.
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by James1985

How about this: first have one person that's going to add up the votes. After each game, each team's owner/GM can PM their votes to the person responsible for adding up. The following rules would make it easier for the person adding the votes:

1. One vote per team, each team can decide who represents the team in voting. It can be the owner, GM or a player. But each team only can have one entry.
2. Teams can't vote for themselves. If you are good, the others will vote for you.
3. On the PM sent to the vote counter, the message should be in the following format:
Team name: Name of the team that voted
#1: XXXXX
#2: XXXXX
....

4. I would recommend keeping the votes to top 10 teams or something like that. Most people don't have time to really analyze the teams at the bottom, so it probably won't be accurate. NCAA polls only have top 25, not the whole 109 or whatever number of teams they have now.

Anyhow, just my two cents.


I say we do this.


Team owners dose this sound good?

You will send the votes to me and I will post them. After every game. Only do the top 10 thoughs.


I agree w/ 1,3, and 4. As for #2, I think we should still be able to vote for ourselves. Of course, we'd have to be mature about it and be as objective as possible.


Thing is If teams vote for themselves a lot of the time they will vote for them selves even if they no that they arnt as good as they are ranking.

There are 32 team owners in SEA AAA#1 and only 10 team we are voting for.
If you belong in the top 10 you will be there.
Last edited Jun 11, 2008 00:54:55
 
Chadstroma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

Originally posted by James1985


How about this: first have one person that's going to add up the votes. After each game, each team's owner/GM can PM their votes to the person responsible for adding up. The following rules would make it easier for the person adding the votes:

1. One vote per team, each team can decide who represents the team in voting. It can be the owner, GM or a player. But each team only can have one entry.
2. Teams can't vote for themselves. If you are good, the others will vote for you.
3. On the PM sent to the vote counter, the message should be in the following format:
Team name: Name of the team that voted
#1: XXXXX
#2: XXXXX
....

4. I would recommend keeping the votes to top 10 teams or something like that. Most people don't have time to really analyze the teams at the bottom, so it probably won't be accurate. NCAA polls only have top 25, not the whole 109 or whatever number of teams they have now.

Anyhow, just my two cents.


I say we do this.


Team owners dose this sound good?

You will send the votes to me and I will post them. After every game. Only do the top 10 thoughs.


I agree w/ 1,3, and 4. As for #2, I think we should still be able to vote for ourselves. Of course, we'd have to be mature about it and be as objective as possible.


Thing is If teams vote for themselves a lot of the time they will vote for them selves even if they no that they arnt as good as they are ranking.

There are 32 team owners in SEA AAA#1 and only 10 team we are voting for.
If you belong in the top 10 you will be there.


The other side of the coin is that if there are 31 other votes, it should even out any of the morons who think their team is #1 when everyone else thinks they are not even in the top 10.

I could go either way with it. Vote for your team or not. In the end, I think the voting should end up about the same.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chadstroma

The other side of the coin is that if there are 31 other votes, it should even out any of the morons who think their team is #1 when everyone else thinks they are not even in the top 10.

I could go either way with it. Vote for your team or not. In the end, I think the voting should end up about the same.


I would have no problem with people voting for themselves. I just think this way we would avoid some potential controversies. There is always a homer or two in any league.
 
Chadstroma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Chadstroma


The other side of the coin is that if there are 31 other votes, it should even out any of the morons who think their team is #1 when everyone else thinks they are not even in the top 10.

I could go either way with it. Vote for your team or not. In the end, I think the voting should end up about the same.


I would have no problem with people voting for themselves. I just think this way we would avoid some potential controversies. There is always a homer or two in any league.


I agree, I just think with 32 teams voting the homers would be out voted anyways. But, then again, if a team that most teams think is really a 9 or 10 votes themselves #1 then it might actually pull them up to 7 or 8. I think I will put my full weight behind not voting for yourself.

Vote top 10 teams without you. Team #1 gets 10 points. Team #2 gets 9. etc... to Team #10 gets 1 point. Added up and whoever has the most points is #1 and so forth.
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by Chadstroma



The other side of the coin is that if there are 31 other votes, it should even out any of the morons who think their team is #1 when everyone else thinks they are not even in the top 10.

I could go either way with it. Vote for your team or not. In the end, I think the voting should end up about the same.


I would have no problem with people voting for themselves. I just think this way we would avoid some potential controversies. There is always a homer or two in any league.


I agree, I just think with 32 teams voting the homers would be out voted anyways. But, then again, if a team that most teams think is really a 9 or 10 votes themselves #1 then it might actually pull them up to 7 or 8. I think I will put my full weight behind not voting for yourself.

Vote top 10 teams without you. Team #1 gets 10 points. Team #2 gets 9. etc... to Team #10 gets 1 point. Added up and whoever has the most points is #1 and so forth.


Sound good.
 
bulletsb
offline
Link
 
where are the ragoon raiders?
 
patsfan4lyf
offline
Link
 
Rattlers ready to improve after dissapointing 2nd round loss in playoffs
 
Chadstroma
offline
Link
 
So, are we all agreed? James1985 gets PM's from the owner/desginate from all teams in SEA AAA with their top 10 teams.

He compiles them giving 10 points to each 1st place vote, 9 points to each 2nd place vote, etc down to 1 point for each 10 point vote. Give a 1 day time limit on it? Same day as games played?

Then shows top 10 (perhaps honarable mentions) by highest point totals. I would suggest he gives it to nutrumpet for him to write it up with some journalistic flair.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.