User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=915687&pbp_id=5207572


Come on... how long is it going to take before Bort realizes the length of time after a catch is made for a "knocked loose" roll to activate is waaaaaaay toooo lonnnng.

That is my wr in the replay and even I admit that should have been a fumble. Either it should have been a fumble or it should have been a tackle. A knocked loose roll should not have occurred at that point.

Before some douche gives me a "he was bobbling the ball for that long" well then that is a bug too as the play text should read "caught, bobbled, [knocked loose by soandso]".
 
PP
offline
Link
 
He actually travels with the ball for 4 yds...That said, I'd bet the house that it's a KL roll that caused it, which is why it is reported as KLed. I'd also bet the house that if you remove the KL roll then it's a completed pass and the WR doesn't fumble. Since Bort programmed it to work that way, I don't really see it as a bug, just something that doesn't make sense (I know, talking semantics here).

Here's how I think we could help change this....I'll leave this thread open. Pls refrain from debating anything here. Instead, whenever someone sees a really late KL, just paste it here. Then, when things either settle down a little or something is brought up on the test server where this will at least sort of fit, I or one of the other testers will bring this up and link this thread. If there's enough good examples here, it will really help to make the point. As it stands right now, I suspect Bort is going to be too focused on fixing exploit blitzes to fit much else in, anyway.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
He actually travels with the ball for 4 yds...That said, I'd bet the house that it's a KL roll that caused it, which is why it is reported as KLed. I'd also bet the house that if you remove the KL roll then it's a completed pass and the WR doesn't fumble. Since Bort programmed it to work that way, I don't really see it as a bug, just something that doesn't make sense (I know, talking semantics here).

Here's how I think we could help change this....I'll leave this thread open. Pls refrain from debating anything here. Instead, whenever someone sees a really late KL, just paste it here. Then, when things either settle down a little or something is brought up on the test server where this will at least sort of fit, I or one of the other testers will bring this up and link this thread. If there's enough good examples here, it will really help to make the point. As it stands right now, I suspect Bort is going to be too focused on fixing exploit blitzes to fit much else in, anyway.


Fair enough!!
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=878638&pbp_id=13584525 - WR makes catch, CUTS, and runs at least 5 yards, then KL'd
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=886986&pbp_id=16070888 - This HB manages to spin, and then get it knocked loose. If you spin, you definitely have possession.

It seems like the KL roll is based on the number of ticks after the receiver has the ball rather than if they actually have possession or not.
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=822149&pbp_id=13235077
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=822149&pbp_id=13238762
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=816616&pbp_id=7359634
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=878818&pbp_id=6157088

There's a few I dug up from past bug threads.
 
PP
offline
Link
 

Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I've made a little bit of progress on some of this stuff in the last couple days:

* Change knocked loose to include distance traveled (instead of just ticks)


From last night....Haven't seen it tested yet and don't believe it's live, but he's trying to address it at least (may have succeeded)
 
Malvado
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
Not trying to argue anything, but keep in mind that the replays are 100% accurate of what really happened. By that I mean, the replay might make it look as if the WR caught it and ran 4 yards, but the actual sim might read it differently.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malvado
Not trying to argue anything, but keep in mind that the replays are 100% accurate of what really happened. By that I mean, the replay might make it look as if the WR caught it and ran 4 yards, but the actual sim might read it differently.


Honestly that isn't a very valid argument as far as distance traveled. Have you ever seen a pitch where it looks like they got 10 yards but they only got 5? In 100% of the replays I've seen so far you can tell how far a dot has traveled.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
The catch roll for a receiver is not all or nothing. Depending on the catch roll, it is possible for a WR to "Bobble" the ball. If in the process of Bobbling the Ball he is hit by a defender, and the ball is not caught, then it is considered "knocked loose".

 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP

Originally posted by Bort

Ok, I've made a little bit of progress on some of this stuff in the last couple days:

* Change knocked loose to include distance traveled (instead of just ticks)


From last night....Haven't seen it tested yet and don't believe it's live, but he's trying to address it at least (may have succeeded)


Thanks for getting him to look at this!!
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
The catch roll for a receiver is not all or nothing. Depending on the catch roll, it is possible for a WR to "Bobble" the ball. If in the process of Bobbling the Ball he is hit by a defender, and the ball is not caught, then it is considered "knocked loose".



But we can actually see a bobbling action when it happens.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Thanks for getting him to look at this!!


It was actually me, but you're welcome.
 
Malvado
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Honestly that isn't a very valid argument as far as distance traveled. Have you ever seen a pitch where it looks like they got 10 yards but they only got 5? In 100% of the replays I've seen so far you can tell how far a dot has traveled.


Yes, yes I have. There are plenty of times where I've seen ball carriers get tackled and the next play is spotted 2 yards further or shorter then from the spot they were tackled etc.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
But we can actually see a bobbling action when it happens.


So you think maybe a text should be added for a "bobble" or a visual of it added to the replays? I think it would be hard to show in replays, but a text of it could probably be added.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
I can safely say I've never seen that and I've watched hundreds of full games. Remember don't look at the first down marker, because that's often really inaccurate.
Edited by Sik Wit It on Dec 19, 2009 15:57:10
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.