User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Change the new League leader formula
Page:
 
roronoa_zoro
offline
Link
 
Well i first kinda posted this as a bug as didnt know where to post and was sent here so bleagh.

Well yea the new league formula is clearly a step in the wrong direction.

The way its deciding on blowout games is simply not good enough.

I mean useing my team as an example because i cba to find a higher level team this has happend to.
Today we played a team and beat them 189-0 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=964146.

Now yes we beat them badly but why should this become a blowout result when effecting league leaders, if you look at there team there average level is about 22 which is only 2 levels lower than ours.
Now you cant tell me one of the other teams in the league isnt going to play them with the same average level as mine and have a close game. Which in turn will hurt the players less in the respect that the league leaders wont be over adjusted, which in turn will put them above my teams simply for the fact we were the better team and beat them by more.

This new formula is basically sticking its middle finger up to all the good teams and giving all the medium strength teams in the league the advantage simply because there games will be closer. (Obviously they will score less but it doesnt matter as where'as they will get 1 whole Td for the TD my team will only get half a TD for the TD) Now this would mean i have to score double in every game just to equal that of a average team.

Well why should i have to do this, at the end of the day they are as stated a AVERAGE team. The old league leader formula is as clear as day better because everyone faces everyone and it rewards the better teams for scoring more. Why the hell should anyone have to score twice as much just to equal a player half as good as him.

This is basically telling everyone that if you join a team that goes 16-0 all your players suck, but if you join a team that goes 8-8 all your players are the best and would score the most. Comeon is it just me or is something wrong there. I think everyone who likes the new way is a idiot, i mean if they were the best they would go 16-0 not 8-8 wouldnt they.

Now i dont know how to fix but at the end of the day there was nothing wrong with the old and simple way, as everyone faces everyone and the people that get the most go on top simple as.
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
While I agree, what is the solution?
One thing most people miss out on is the idea that MVP = Most Valuable Player to Their Team.
League leader is not always the MVP.
 
roronoa_zoro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skoll Wolfrun
While I agree, what is the solution?
One thing most people miss out on is the idea that MVP = Most Valuable Player to Their Team.
League leader is not always the MVP.


Well i dont know of a exact solution but yea. You could do lots of things like make average team levels count in the formula or have it change from the other teams scores aswell. Eg if all the other teams were within 2 Tds but you won something silly like 70-0 you should get the full 70 Tds worth as you simply outplayed every other team.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by roronoa_zoro

This is basically telling everyone that if you join a team that goes 16-0 all your players suck, but if you join a team that goes 8-8 all your players are the best and would score the most. Comeon is it just me or is something wrong there. I think everyone who likes the new way is a idiot, i mean if they were the best they would go 16-0 not 8-8 wouldnt they.


this has been my issue with adjusted stats since the day bort announced it last season.
 
bigg987
offline
Link
 
stats are stats are stats.

some people look at them, stick their hand in their pockets and more than smile. to others theyre meaningless and only the win column counts.

i agree with the OP, why the hell should a guy who actually led the league be adjusted out of top spot? those blowout teams have 15 other teams to let have killer stats too, so the guy that got a load of stats in one game, potentially has 15 other guys doing the same.... so the stats will be competitive and relative to the league anyways without fudging them to make a shit dot's agent feel his guy is great!!! if he was great he would of posted the same stats, would he not?

if this is how the MVP formula has been working, then there is no wonder people scratch their heads each season.
just remove the formula completely. give the top guys their dues and have the MVP follow the leaders too.

 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Better fix to just throw out the out of conference game in week 1 and use the real stats IMO. Of course this has been hashed out, and those "smart guys" ( ) chose what we have now as the best solution......... wtg.....
Edited by We_Rule on Dec 11, 2009 18:24:22
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Of course, we don't really know what the effects are in our league yet, because the sim is officially -4 hours and 24 minutes late, and 3 games still haven't simmed even though the problem was brought to their attention 2 days ago when our last pre-season game was 2 hours late. Again...... wtg!
Edited by We_Rule on Dec 11, 2009 18:26:24
 
FBfan4life
offline
Link
 
So, are we supposed to water down a game because some chump team did not put the time in to recruit, or they dont gameplan, or they just dont know what they are doing, or they just cant build a dot, or they are slow buildling, or they have gutted, or they are throwing a game at the end of the season so they dont go up a few levels farther.

This is just plain stupid. How the hell can you throw 2.27 TDs, or have 0.21 Forced fumbles and all the other numbers that are coming out. Just plain stupid.

 
youngtater
offline
Link
 
Stats are stats and they shouldn't be changed. We had a QB in our league in season 12 go out and throw for 1,500 yds and like 30 TD's. It helped him get a TD trophy. If Bort is trying to get this more like the real things then leave the stats alone. It will all work out in the end. If not tough shit!!!!
 
Michael Vick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
Better fix to just throw out the out of conference game in week 1 and use the real stats IMO. Of course this has been hashed out, and those "smart guys" ( ) chose what we have now as the best solution......... wtg.....


I agree with this. If it's conference MVPs and such then the first game shouldn't be counted anyway and as previously stated every other team gets the same oppurtunity to play that team. The only way this new formula would come into effect is to compare players of other conferences/leagues and really someone could just make a script for they, could they not?
 
Link
 
I agree....the partial stats for blowouts is crap. A TD is a TD, a tackle is a tackle. Count them for what they are worth. Don't screw with the stats themselves.

If you want to put in reduction multipliers for the blowout games in the MVP formula, that is one thing, but reducing the "stats" a player has is bullshit.

I realize that coding that would be a bitch, but giving guys partial credit just because the game was a blowout is BS.
 
Luckylouse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigg987
stats are stats are stats.

some people look at them, stick their hand in their pockets and more than smile. to others theyre meaningless and only the win column counts.

i agree with the OP, why the hell should a guy who actually led the league be adjusted out of top spot? those blowout teams have 15 other teams to let have killer stats too, so the guy that got a load of stats in one game, potentially has 15 other guys doing the same.... so the stats will be competitive and relative to the league anyways without fudging them to make a shit dot's agent feel his guy is great!!! if he was great he would of posted the same stats, would he not?

if this is how the MVP formula has been working, then there is no wonder people scratch their heads each season.
just remove the formula completely. give the top guys their dues and have the MVP follow the leaders too.



Bigg is right as usual. This is crap and players who put up the big numbers should be given credit for everything they did in the game. I'm sure with enough complaints they'll change it back.



 
vinman
offline
Link
 
Stats are part of the enjoyment of the game,watering them down makes no sense.If i wanted to see decimals i would
go play a math game.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
This is what Hazy and I had posted on the test server if it helps you guys at all.

Originally posted by thehazyone

Yea, all you have to do is when you get up by 63, have AI in place to not score.

How about weighing stats based on score (and not sharing the formula with any one):

For example 0-70 points - 100%, 71-100 points - 50%, 101-150 points - 25%, >151 points - 10%


Originally posted by cwisler

I wouldn't put a score limit on it, but I like the idea Hazy has come up with here. If you put a score limit on it, and one team is significantly better at gameplanning than the others, they're going to have more blowout games -- therefore having more stats not count for them.

I would either use Hazy's idea, or include the games against the top # teams in the conference (Preferrably the top 8 since they all make playoffs). You have to make sure that every player gets the same amount of games credited to his/her stats though. It would be unfair to have some players get 9 games credited to their stats while others get only 5, etc.
 
bigg987
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
This is what Hazy and I had posted on the test server if it helps you guys at all.

Originally posted by thehazyone


Yea, all you have to do is when you get up by 63, have AI in place to not score.

How about weighing stats based on score (and not sharing the formula with any one):

For example 0-70 points - 100%, 71-100 points - 50%, 101-150 points - 25%, >151 points - 10%


Originally posted by cwisler


I wouldn't put a score limit on it, but I like the idea Hazy has come up with here. If you put a score limit on it, and one team is significantly better at gameplanning than the others, they're going to have more blowout games -- therefore having more stats not count for them.

I would either use Hazy's idea, or include the games against the top # teams in the conference (Preferrably the top 8 since they all make playoffs). You have to make sure that every player gets the same amount of games credited to his/her stats though. It would be unfair to have some players get 9 games credited to their stats while others get only 5, etc.


it sheds some light, but it still isnt right.
a stat is a stat is a stat and as dave(3 or 4 posts up) said a tackle is a tackle, not 1,13456 of a tackle.
please put the stats as stats. cak about with formula for the MVP if you must. but please leave the stats as stats., next it will be 1.123456 wins if you win a close game!!!!

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.