User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=898397&pbp_id=17885218

If you look his first step after the interception is back... he caught the ball on the 0.5 yet it is called a touch back... should have been a safety imo. Wonder if this is a coded bug that doesn't call safety's in this situation or was this really a touch back?
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
Disregard... this is a replay rewrite code issue there... but still looking into it.
Edited by Stobie on Nov 19, 2009 08:09:15
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
This would be the tick right before he catches the ball...

[{id: 'ball',x: 36,y: 39.25,z: 7.5}

Here is sequence after...

[{id: 'ball',x: 31,y: 31.5,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 33.25,y: 30.25,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 36,y: 29.25,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 39,y: 28.75,z: 4}

So in this case... obvious legend is....

X is where the ball is on the X axis such as East/West or Left/Right movement. 0 is far left and + numbers are to the right.
Y is where the ball is on the Y axis such as North/South or Forward/Backward movement. 0 is back of north endzone and + goes south.
Z is where the ball iz on the Z axis such as Altitude. 0 is ground level and + is going up.

So..... player has possession of ball at X 31 and Y 31.5 but continues to go towards the end zone to end at Y 28.75. IMO this is a safety as he has control of ball outside of enzone and then enters endzone.

I will look at another TD and verify what the actual goal line is but my guesses are that its Y = 30.0
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
We are going to use this play as verification of what the goal line is.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=898397&pbp_id=17885809

[{id: 'ball',x: 90.25,y: 40.5,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 90.5,y: 41.25,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 90.75,y: 42.25,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 91.25,y: 43.5,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 91.5,y: 45.25,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 91.25,y: 48,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 91.75,y: 45.5,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 92.75,y: 42.75,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 93.75,y: 40.25,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 95,y: 37.5,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 96.25,y: 35,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 96.5,y: 33.75,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 96.75,y: 32.25,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 97,y: 30.75,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 97.25,y: 29.5,z: 4}

So it seems the goal line would be the Y = 30.75 - 29.5

With this view the previous interception that player had the ball at the 31.5 but ending at the 28.75 verifies that it was a catch at the ~ 1 yd line and he ran into the endzone... thus this should be a safety not a touchback.
 
acrnobrnja
offline
Link
 
Momentum carried him in? It's only a safety if the defensive player intentionally retreats back into the endzone...
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
I would say that but if you watch the replay he is standing there to get the INT then makes a cut move to the right and into the endzone.
 
acrnobrnja
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stobie
I would say that but if you watch the replay he is standing there to get the INT then makes a cut move to the right and into the endzone.


That's true but aren't we told to never follow the visual? It's just supposed to be an aesthetic thing.
 
bobdakota
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by acrnobrnja
Originally posted by Stobie

I would say that but if you watch the replay he is standing there to get the INT then makes a cut move to the right and into the endzone.


That's true but aren't we told to never follow the visual? It's just supposed to be an aesthetic thing.


"The text is always right"

I have heard that since day 1.
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by acrnobrnja
That's true but aren't we told to never follow the visual? It's just supposed to be an aesthetic thing.


That's my point though... I looked at the code. Code shows that it was a pause then a move to avoid the WR and he ends up in the end zone.
 
acrnobrnja
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stobie
That's my point though... I looked at the code. Code shows that it was a pause then a move to avoid the WR and he ends up in the end zone.


I dunno then.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stobie
This would be the tick right before he catches the ball...

[{id: 'ball',x: 36,y: 39.25,z: 7.5}

Here is sequence after...

[{id: 'ball',x: 31,y: 31.5,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 33.25,y: 30.25,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 36,y: 29.25,z: 4}
[{id: 'ball',x: 39,y: 28.75,z: 4}

So in this case... obvious legend is....

X is where the ball is on the X axis such as East/West or Left/Right movement. 0 is far left and + numbers are to the right.
Y is where the ball is on the Y axis such as North/South or Forward/Backward movement. 0 is back of north endzone and + goes south.
Z is where the ball iz on the Z axis such as Altitude. 0 is ground level and + is going up.

So..... player has possession of ball at X 31 and Y 31.5 but continues to go towards the end zone to end at Y 28.75. IMO this is a safety as he has control of ball outside of enzone and then enters endzone.

I will look at another TD and verify what the actual goal line is but my guesses are that its Y = 30.0


I think you're making some assumptions.

You don't actually know when the CB has possession of the ball - that's not in the code. It's certainly possible he was still "catching it" for a few ticks while it went back into the endzone. This is really part of the larger issue of you don't know why he moved backwards - was he intentionally moving that direction, was he still catching the ball, was his momentum not turned around, etc.

Regardless, I'm already convinced from prior incidents (no links, sorry) that the code ALWAYS gives a touchback in the case where a defensive player is downed in the endzone with the ball. That may not be worth fixing anytime soon, as I don't know if the game has a sense of "momentum" vs "intentionally moving backwards".
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
I think you're making some assumptions.

You don't actually know when the CB has possession of the ball - that's not in the code. It's certainly possible he was still "catching it" for a few ticks while it went back into the endzone. This is really part of the larger issue of you don't know why he moved backwards - was he intentionally moving that direction, was he still catching the ball, was his momentum not turned around, etc.

Regardless, I'm already convinced from prior incidents (no links, sorry) that the code ALWAYS gives a touchback in the case where a defensive player is downed in the endzone with the ball. That may not be worth fixing anytime soon, as I don't know if the game has a sense of "momentum" vs "intentionally moving backwards".


Yah in this case its a very close call? But if you look at his Z factor... its very very stable after he assumes possession, but I like you have never seen a safety in this manner... and it should have been.
 
entee
offline
Link
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safety_(football_score)

says if the momentum carries him into the endzone, it doesnt count as a safety
Edited by entee on Nov 19, 2009 14:23:04
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by entee
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safety_(football_score)

says if the momentum carries him into the endzone, it doesnt count as a safety

Momentum isn't the issue here.


Originally posted by Stobie

I looked at the code. Code shows that it was a pause then a move to avoid the WR and he ends up in the end zone.


 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.