User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Look how late this knocked loose pass comes.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=878638&pbp_id=13584525

The WR catches it, runs with it, MAKES A CUT, then it's knocked loose.
 
Lennac
offline
Link
 
Looks like a fumble to me...
But hasn't the reason always been the replays aren't "exact" just sort of examples? I could be wrong, but I remember being told to not take the visuals as 100% accurate.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Still though, they are exact enough to where we can see if they're making cuts.

And yes, it should have been a fumble if the ball came loose. I think the problem is though that the KL window is too large, so Jackhammer is active for too long. Now ask yourself this...would he still have dropped the ball if the Jackhammer bonus wasn't there anymore?
 
Stu618
offline
Link
 
Why does it look like the ball is disappearing to me?
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stu618
Why does it look like the ball is disappearing to me?


Something changed in the sim. If you disable RR, it doesn't disappear.

Just another ninja nerf to something in the sim code, I guess.
 
Chop_Lobster
offline
Link
 
two more from another game..

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=822149&pbp_id=13235077 TE gets about 3.5 yards down field before knocked loose

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=822149&pbp_id=13238762 arguable but the WR seems to make a pretty distinct cut w/ the ball
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Bump
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
if Bort reduces the KL window (which he should have done a long long long time ago), he will have to increase the KL rate to keep thing in balance. So at the end of the day, he hasn't fixed this because it works a intended I suppose.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
C'Mon..... When the game SIMs there is all this information that has to be converted into the PBP.....

Please remember that the field is about half the size that it should be.... so in reality the KL window is small.... but it appears larger than it actually is.... (just like your sideview mirrors), because all the events from the SIM data have to be interpreted into the PBP...
 
Mr. Likable
offline
Link
 
Its not fixed if its not right. If a player catches it and then runs down field and then it gets knocked loose, that is a fumble not an incomplete pass. So it is not fixed and Bort should fix it.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
C'Mon..... When the game SIMs there is all this information that has to be converted into the PBP.....

Please remember that the field is about half the size that it should be.... so in reality the KL window is small.... but it appears larger than it actually is.... (just like your sideview mirrors), because all the events from the SIM data have to be interpreted into the PBP...


It's not so much the distance he ran or how long it took him to run it. It's the fact that he clearly caught it, moved down the field, and made a cut. I think no matter how different people think the replays are from the PBP, we can all agree that we are able to see cuts.

In football, once you make a "football move" you have possession. It doesn't matter how long you have the ball or how far you move with it. I could also point to those instances where you see a WR catch it, break a tackle by spinning, then get the ball KLed. I don't have any handy right now, but I've seen it happen a lot.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

In football, once you make a "football move" you have possession. It doesn't matter how long you have the ball or how far you move with it. I could also point to those instances where you see a WR catch it, break a tackle by spinning, then get the ball KLed. I don't have any handy right now, but I've seen it happen a lot.


How do you know he wasn't bobbling the ball while making his move?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Sik Wit It


In football, once you make a "football move" you have possession. It doesn't matter how long you have the ball or how far you move with it. I could also point to those instances where you see a WR catch it, break a tackle by spinning, then get the ball KLed. I don't have any handy right now, but I've seen it happen a lot.


How do you know he wasn't bobbling the ball while making his move?



Actually from what Bort has said on the topic, there is a period of time that it takes to secure the ball after a pass (or a pitch for that matter), and that period amounts to "bobbling" in the sim with regards to having full possession. The period is reduced by making a cleaner catcch, and by having better carrying attributes (which help secure the ball after a catch).

I don't see these extreme examples very often...in either GLB or NFL. But they do happen in each.

It does look a little annoying (since you can't see the details of the ball handling) but I don't see it enough to think it is a serious issue, or a bug.

jmho.

Edited by tautology on Nov 11, 2009 18:17:20
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.