User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
I had a game today where my opposition ran the ball every time a certain HB was IN the game, so I set up a defense to limit his yardage inside. This worked as intended....until the opposition called a 5wr play where there was no HB at all. So, of course, the AI put in my tagged play.

WHY? It easily cost us the game. Just wondering why it would put in a defense that had a player tagged, when he wasn't in the game.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mstr_October
I had a game today where my opposition ran the ball every time a certain HB was IN the game, so I set up a defense to limit his yardage inside. This worked as intended....until the opposition called a 5wr play where there was no HB at all. So, of course, the AI put in my tagged play.

WHY? It easily cost us the game. Just wondering why it would put in a defense that had a player tagged, when he wasn't in the game.


without looking at your defense I would have no clue BUT

1. did you have a 5WR defense set up?
2. if so, post a link of the replay and what should have been called, also list as much info about your settings. (screen shots always help the bug mods)
 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
About to go to work, so I don't have the time for all that Robb, but I will tell you this, and I know this is the problem. The defense was first on the check list and was set for 'any formation', 0-6 WRs...I know this is the reason it went in.

Yes I have 5 wr defenses, but they were behind this play.

My real question is this, why was this defense allowed without this HB in the play at all. I know I should have set the receivers at 0-3, but I never would have thought this defense would go in when the tagged HB was not in the play at all. I thought the whole reason to tag a player was that the play would only be called when his presence was on the field of play.
 
bobdakota
offline
Link
 
for anyone interested I think this must be the game and the type of plays he was talking about http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818319&pbp_id=8447712

Edited by bobdakota on Oct 28, 2009 03:52:47
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Definitely a bug, since that tagged player is not in the game.

Unfortunately, all you are going to get in the bugs forum is people telling you how to fix it, not that it's a bug (even though it is). Small bugs like this are why this game will never get out of beta (because they are overlooked).
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I don't see this as a bug but I can see how you think it should be changed. Definitely something to be noted as I'm sure others share your same frustration.

Basically you want the input to use the RB check, even if a RB isn't in the play. Your input fulfilled the situation, outside of the tagged RB check. Since it was Shotgun 5WR (no RB), you expected it to be passed over based on your tagged RB being selected. But that isn't even checked (because no RB is in the play).
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I don't see this as a bug but I can see how you think it should be changed. Definitely something to be noted as I'm sure others share your same frustration.

Basically you want the input to use the RB check, even if a RB isn't in the play. Your input fulfilled the situation, outside of the tagged RB check. Since it was Shotgun 5WR (no RB), you expected it to be passed over based on your tagged RB being selected. But that isn't even checked (because no RB is in the play).


I added that to report to see if that could be a possibility. Thanks Mat.
 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I don't see this as a bug but I can see how you think it should be changed. Definitely something to be noted as I'm sure others share your same frustration.

Basically you want the input to use the RB check, even if a RB isn't in the play. Your input fulfilled the situation, outside of the tagged RB check. Since it was Shotgun 5WR (no RB), you expected it to be passed over based on your tagged RB being selected. But that isn't even checked (because no RB is in the play).


Yes. Exactly. I tagged a player that I wanted a defense run for. The play should absolutely only be run when and if he is the HB, or hell, even in the play at any position. If the tagged player is not on the field, the play should not be run under any circumstances. At least, that is the way I feel about it.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I don't see this as a bug but I can see how you think it should be changed. Definitely something to be noted as I'm sure others share your same frustration.

Basically you want the input to use the RB check, even if a RB isn't in the play. Your input fulfilled the situation, outside of the tagged RB check. Since it was Shotgun 5WR (no RB), you expected it to be passed over based on your tagged RB being selected. But that isn't even checked (because no RB is in the play).


If it's not a bug, then it's the least logical way to implement the feature. Either way, it needs to be changed. Oh sure, we can get around it. How long are we going to continue using "Any I" in our D AI instead of Bort actually fixing something he fucked up and hasn't touched since day 1?

Same deal, but the more things he implements half-assed, the harder he makes it on his paying user base.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hm, looks like I already updated that logic, and it's on the test server, but it is not live. Guess I realized it was counter intuitive already

It seems to work for me, but I guess it could use a test game run to make sure.


Running a test game now.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
http://test.goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1492

Seems fixed to me. If you notice anything, please let me know. If HB is on field, it should go 4-3. 5WR should be Dime.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.