User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Recaps > Why isn't this a fumble?
aces250
offline
Link
 
the HB catches it then looks like he starts running with the ball; then the ball is on the ground

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=816616&pbp_id=7359634
 
Link
 
Because pj hill sucks!!

Seriously though I have NO idea the pbp says caught:

Joe. Flacco. pass to pj hill, hurried by Hey Sioux Sioux, up the right side, caught [missed diving tackle: Cody Thickstacker], knocked loose by Robert "Hitman" Vaugn [deflected by Robert "Hitman" Vaugn] (incomplete)



DMP
 
BauerVHL
offline
Link
 
According to NFL's definition, that is a fumble. The player made a football move (moving to avoid defenders), dodges a tackle, and then is hit and loses the football. Should have been a completion, then fumbled.
 
Clackity
offline
Link
 
What a shock more bugs for bort to ignore.
 
Link
 
you can't fix the refs
Edited by Timetoshine-Beta on Oct 24, 2009 15:36:21
 
JIX
offline
Link
 
his knee was down?..........lol
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
PJ is above fumbles
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BauerVHL
According to NFL's definition, that is a fumble. The player made a football move (moving to avoid defenders), dodges a tackle, and then is hit and loses the football. Should have been a completion, then fumbled.


They got rid of the "football move" vagueness. Now all the receiver has to do is:

1) Come down on both feet.
2) Have control of the ball.


Either way, yeah, it's a completion if you just go by the dots.
 
Vin4DaWin
offline
Link
 
He must've done a Superman dive or something.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
This has been happening since Bort first introduced the Jackhammer VA (I would be the house that that SS is equipped with it).
 
Link
 
Hmm, maybe you should post this in the Bugs forum. Looks like a legit issue.
 
IAMKING
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aces250
the HB catches it then looks like he starts running with the ball; then the ball is on the ground

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=816616&pbp_id=7359634


Because Bort hasnt finished coding the challenge flag
 
IAMKING
offline
Link
 
I just noticed my LB played on that team and I made that field
 
Lockdown U
offline
Link
 
Because rthe replay says

Joe. Flacco. long pass to pj hill, hurried by Hey Sioux Sioux (ROT-Muapi Umanga), up the right side, caught [missed diving tackle: Cody Thickstacker], knocked loose by Robert "Hitman" Vaugn [deflected by Robert "Hitman" Vaugn] (incomplete)
 
Qunqun24
offline
Link
 
Maybe he was juggling the catch. So He "caught" it, but didnt have control.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.