User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
about 90 vision favors hb passes, ronde #1 option, dude is wide open, throws to a covered guy.....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818263&pbp_id=6798578

Is the passing game completely random>? Is it too much to ask that our qb's with 90+ vision throw to the open man?? I know we are on the realism kick, and we are just going for realistic stats, but when a guy is uncovered, even a blind man can see he is open. Fix this please
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
I'm guessing the progression goes:

WR3
TE
WR2
WR1
HB


First 2 reads were double covered. 3rd one was single coverage with the CB behind him on a hook route. Perfectly legit QB read progression. Sure, the HB was completely uncovered, but the QB probably never got that far in his reads.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Why if the QB #1 target = hb, is the hb the last target. A guy who is #1 target, and we put that play in bc we noticed they leave him uncovered in that situation, set the qb to make him #1 priority, so he streaks down the field wide open, and we don't get the call....
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Here's how it works:

You have to look where the player is when the QB starts his throwing motion, so pause the play there.

The QB calculates the "risk value" for each player based on several things (sort of in order-ish):

1) Being the primary receiver
2) How far down the checkdown list he is
3) How many defenders are nearby
4) How good those defenders are in comparison
5) How close the player is to the play's set distance (short/medium/long)
6) How close the player is to a first down (on 3rd/4th down plays)
7) The player's catching ability

He has to make a vision check to "see" each player, so if he fails the check, a player may go completely unnoticed. He'll then pass to the guy he sees whose risk is furthest under his "acceptable risk" value, which is determined by pressure and how long the play has taken, etc.

 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
Why if the QB #1 target = hb, is the hb the last target. A guy who is #1 target, and we put that play in bc we noticed they leave him uncovered in that situation, set the qb to make him #1 priority, so he streaks down the field wide open, and we don't get the call....


Hmmm last time we had a situation like this, it wassthe SB Flanker Drag play and the culprit was a misplaced comma that invalidating both HB and WR1 as valid targets in the checkdown list for the QB. (The checkdown lists for the QB's each play are separated by commas, like so: HB,WR1,WR2,TE, WR3, etc. For the Flanker Drag bug the first comma was missing and so it was telling the QB to look for a player with the id HBWR1, and HB and WR1 were never thrown to because they didnt exist in the QB's binary eyes....)

Do we have any instances of the HB ever getting a pass target from this specific play?
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by Bort

Here's how it works:

You have to look where the player is when the QB starts his throwing motion, so pause the play there.

The QB calculates the "risk value" for each player based on several things (sort of in order-ish):

1) Being the primary receiver
2) How far down the checkdown list he is
3) How many defenders are nearby
4) How good those defenders are in comparison
5) How close the player is to the play's set distance (short/medium/long)
6) How close the player is to a first down (on 3rd/4th down plays)
7) The player's catching ability

He has to make a vision check to "see" each player, so if he fails the check, a player may go completely unnoticed. He'll then pass to the guy he sees whose risk is furthest under his "acceptable risk" value, which is determined by pressure and how long the play has taken, etc.



Great. So it doesn't work.
He was #1 priority according to tactics. No defender near. Wide open. 3rd down and 17.5, he was right at the marker completely undefended. 45 catching. Pretty much 0 reason he didn't get targeted. Thanks for confirming the bug matt
 
Link
 
Interesting theory/thought, I wonder if you wouldn't have selected him as a primary target, if the QB would of found him then.
Depending on how fast the QB goes through those checks/reads, the HB would of been first, since he was primary, which means he would of still been breaking out of the backfield and not past the RDE. Could it be possible the Qb started looking up field because of that?
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Interesting theory/thought, I wonder if you wouldn't have selected him as a primary target, if the QB would of found him then.
Depending on how fast the QB goes through those checks/reads, the HB would of been first, since he was primary, which means he would of still been breaking out of the backfield and not past the RDE. Could it be possible the Qb started looking up field because of that?


The HB isn't the primary receiver.
http://goallineblitz.com/images/plays/179.gif
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sixx
The HB isn't the primary receiver.
http://goallineblitz.com/images/plays/179.gif


Correct. Neither was the guy he threw too..

Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Interesting theory/thought, I wonder if you wouldn't have selected him as a primary target, if the QB would of found him then.
Depending on how fast the QB goes through those checks/reads, the HB would of been first, since he was primary, which means he would of still been breaking out of the backfield and not past the RDE. Could it be possible the Qb started looking up field because of that?


on 3rd and 17.5 you would sure as hell hope not.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Sixx
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Interesting theory/thought, I wonder if you wouldn't have selected him as a primary target, if the QB would of found him then.
Depending on how fast the QB goes through those checks/reads, the HB would of been first, since he was primary, which means he would of still been breaking out of the backfield and not past the RDE. Could it be possible the Qb started looking up field because of that?


The HB isn't the primary receiver.
http://goallineblitz.com/images/plays/179.gif


When I said primary reciever, I actually meant from the QB's tactics. My B for being a little vague, typing out loud

Originally posted by David Stern
Why if the QB #1 target = hb, is the hb the last target. A guy who is #1 target, and we put that play in bc we noticed they leave him uncovered in that situation, set the qb to make him #1 priority, so he streaks down the field wide open, and we don't get the call....



 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by Sixx

Originally posted by driftinggrifter


Interesting theory/thought, I wonder if you wouldn't have selected him as a primary target, if the QB would of found him then.
Depending on how fast the QB goes through those checks/reads, the HB would of been first, since he was primary, which means he would of still been breaking out of the backfield and not past the RDE. Could it be possible the Qb started looking up field because of that?


The HB isn't the primary receiver.
http://goallineblitz.com/images/plays/179.gif


When I said primary reciever, I actually meant from the QB's tactics. My B for being a little vague, typing out loud

Originally posted by David Stern

Why if the QB #1 target = hb, is the hb the last target. A guy who is #1 target, and we put that play in bc we noticed they leave him uncovered in that situation, set the qb to make him #1 priority, so he streaks down the field wide open, and we don't get the call....





Just making sure.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
about 90 vision favors hb passes, ronde #1 option, dude is wide open, throws to a covered guy.....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818263&pbp_id=6798578

Is the passing game completely random>? Is it too much to ask that our qb's with 90+ vision throw to the open man?? I know we are on the realism kick, and we are just going for realistic stats, but when a guy is uncovered, even a blind man can see he is open. Fix this please


I HIGHLY doubt that a blind man could see that the open man was open.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
Great. So it doesn't work.
He was #1 priority according to tactics. No defender near. Wide open. 3rd down and 17.5, he was right at the marker completely undefended. 45 catching. Pretty much 0 reason he didn't get targeted. Thanks for confirming the bug matt


My guess is that it did work actually. Primary receiver was C-Ya Later who was double covered strait away, so the QB probably checked off right away and looked at his favorite target Ronde. But Ronde was only at the line of scrimmage at that time while Mr Sandman was 5 yards past it. Taking in the calculated risk, my guess is the QB knew Sandmans catching was good enough to make a catch in man to man coverage when Sandman came back on the hook and already 5 yard deeper than Ronde. The QB could have also been looking that way since the LDE was already around your ROT and didnt have time to look back across the field taking his peripheral off the LDE.

Something like that.

Needs more vision.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
My guess is that it did work actually. Primary receiver was C-Ya Later who was double covered strait away, so the QB probably checked off right away and looked at his favorite target Ronde. But Ronde was only at the line of scrimmage at that time while Mr Sandman was 5 yards past it. Taking in the calculated risk, my guess is the QB knew Sandmans catching was good enough to make a catch in man to man coverage when Sandman came back on the hook and already 5 yard deeper than Ronde. The QB could have also been looking that way since the LDE was already around your ROT and didnt have time to look back across the field taking his peripheral off the LDE.

Something like that.

Needs more vision.


with football genius he was at 91 vision.....

The Sim should be recognizing it is 3rd and 17.5, and when the qb threw the ball the hb was closing in on the 1st down marker, further down field then the receiver who was targeted. I feel like everything you just typed was completely wrong in every sense of the word.
Edited by David Stern on Oct 24, 2009 00:31:37
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
I noticed on 3rd down, it's VERY rare the QB will throw underneath and let his receiver get the rest of the yards. You can see in the replay, WR2 is closer to the 1st down marker, so that's why he did it.

Basically QBs have no common sense, and there's no way they can tell "this receiver will have room to run after the catch, and maybe pick up the first. If not, at least he'll get close and we'll have better field position".

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.