my pee wee team is set to run 70 to 75% of the time depending on the down and yardage. I checked the AI and on every input I did have the Auto Adjust turned off. Yet in todays game we ran the ball 10 time and tried to pass 42 times. That is 81% pass and 19% run. instead of the 70% run it should be on 1st and 2nd down, and 75% on third and short; and inside the five.
Captain Kaos
offline
offline
Do you have auto-adjust turned off in the Basic Settings?
Also, IIRC, the AI is set around an RNG -- meaning it could come out to 100% pass if you have at least 1 pass play in every input, hypothetically. It doesn't call plays according to the %s you have them set at in the AI, that's just the % chance they have at being called.
Also, IIRC, the AI is set around an RNG -- meaning it could come out to 100% pass if you have at least 1 pass play in every input, hypothetically. It doesn't call plays according to the %s you have them set at in the AI, that's just the % chance they have at being called.
Sixx
offline
offline
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3393659&page=1#29583834
I believe he completely misunderstood.
Invite someone to look at your AI so they can verify it, or this thread will probably get locked too.
I believe he completely misunderstood.

Invite someone to look at your AI so they can verify it, or this thread will probably get locked too.
einar_90808
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sixx
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3393659&page=1#29583834
I believe he completely misunderstood.
Invite someone to look at your AI so they can verify it, or this thread will probably get locked too.
that is a good idea. I will do just that so they can see how the AI is set right now.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3393659&page=1#29583834
I believe he completely misunderstood.

Invite someone to look at your AI so they can verify it, or this thread will probably get locked too.
that is a good idea. I will do just that so they can see how the AI is set right now.
Captain Kaos
offline
offline
Results of Scouting -- without giving away tactics:
18 First Downs
4 rushes, 14 passes
17 Second Downs
5 rushes, 12 passes
12 Third Downs (6+ Yards)
12 passes
I think it was just a bad case of luck with the RNG. And I just noticed, the O AI does say "% Chance, not % Called".
So I would look at is as "_____ play has a __% chance of being called every time this situation appears".
The sim will not adjust to match your %s exactly, my best interpretation of it is throwing in a ticket for each % chance you have it set at -- throwing all those tickets in a hat and picking one randomly every time the situation occurs. If you really want to pass the ball only about 10-20% of the time during the game, adjust the % chances of the pass plays to not equal more than 10%, imo.
Unfortunately, I don't think it's a case of a broken sim. Imo, it's more of bad luck with the RNG during the game.
Does this make sense?
18 First Downs
4 rushes, 14 passes
17 Second Downs
5 rushes, 12 passes
12 Third Downs (6+ Yards)
12 passes
I think it was just a bad case of luck with the RNG. And I just noticed, the O AI does say "% Chance, not % Called".
So I would look at is as "_____ play has a __% chance of being called every time this situation appears".
The sim will not adjust to match your %s exactly, my best interpretation of it is throwing in a ticket for each % chance you have it set at -- throwing all those tickets in a hat and picking one randomly every time the situation occurs. If you really want to pass the ball only about 10-20% of the time during the game, adjust the % chances of the pass plays to not equal more than 10%, imo.
Unfortunately, I don't think it's a case of a broken sim. Imo, it's more of bad luck with the RNG during the game.
Does this make sense?
Originally posted by cwisler
Results of Scouting -- without giving away tactics:
18 First Downs
4 rushes, 14 passes
17 Second Downs
5 rushes, 12 passes
12 Third Downs (6+ Yards)
12 passes
I think it was just a bad case of luck with the RNG. And I just noticed, the O AI does say "% Chance, not % Called".
So I would look at is as "_____ play has a __% chance of being called every time this situation appears".
The sim will not adjust to match your %s exactly, my best interpretation of it is throwing in a ticket for each % chance you have it set at -- throwing all those tickets in a hat and picking one randomly every time the situation occurs. If you really want to pass the ball only about 10-20% of the time during the game, adjust the % chances of the pass plays to not equal more than 10%, imo.
Unfortunately, I don't think it's a case of a broken sim. Imo, it's more of bad luck with the RNG during the game.
Does this make sense?
I just made a very rough estimate of the probability to roll from a 70% run offense (1-2 downs) a less then 25% run game (9/35 ~ 25%) . Assuming there are enough plays (and 35 is reasonably enough), the distribution is a Gaussian distribution around 70% with square standard deviation ~8%. So we are talking about a result which is about 5.5 sigma away from the mean. This is something like 1/10^6 event !
How many GLB games are there ? I guess something like a few thousands per day. That excuses of a "statistical fluke" (so away from the settings) cannot be used more than once per season on all GLB.
I did the calculation late at night and quickly, so I may of got some numbers wrongs. !
Results of Scouting -- without giving away tactics:
18 First Downs
4 rushes, 14 passes
17 Second Downs
5 rushes, 12 passes
12 Third Downs (6+ Yards)
12 passes
I think it was just a bad case of luck with the RNG. And I just noticed, the O AI does say "% Chance, not % Called".
So I would look at is as "_____ play has a __% chance of being called every time this situation appears".
The sim will not adjust to match your %s exactly, my best interpretation of it is throwing in a ticket for each % chance you have it set at -- throwing all those tickets in a hat and picking one randomly every time the situation occurs. If you really want to pass the ball only about 10-20% of the time during the game, adjust the % chances of the pass plays to not equal more than 10%, imo.
Unfortunately, I don't think it's a case of a broken sim. Imo, it's more of bad luck with the RNG during the game.
Does this make sense?
I just made a very rough estimate of the probability to roll from a 70% run offense (1-2 downs) a less then 25% run game (9/35 ~ 25%) . Assuming there are enough plays (and 35 is reasonably enough), the distribution is a Gaussian distribution around 70% with square standard deviation ~8%. So we are talking about a result which is about 5.5 sigma away from the mean. This is something like 1/10^6 event !
How many GLB games are there ? I guess something like a few thousands per day. That excuses of a "statistical fluke" (so away from the settings) cannot be used more than once per season on all GLB.
I did the calculation late at night and quickly, so I may of got some numbers wrongs. !
einar_90808
offline
offline
Originally posted by tragula
I just made a very rough estimate of the probability to roll from a 70% run offense (1-2 downs) a less then 25% run game (9/35 ~ 25%) . Assuming there are enough plays (and 35 is reasonably enough), the distribution is a Gaussian distribution around 70% with square standard deviation ~8%. So we are talking about a result which is about 5.5 sigma away from the mean. This is something like 1/10^6 event !
How many GLB games are there ? I guess something like a few thousands per day. That excuses of a "statistical fluke" (so away from the settings) cannot be used more than once per season on all GLB.
I did the calculation late at night and quickly, so I may of got some numbers wrongs. !
I have no clue what you just said so I will take your word for it.
I just made a very rough estimate of the probability to roll from a 70% run offense (1-2 downs) a less then 25% run game (9/35 ~ 25%) . Assuming there are enough plays (and 35 is reasonably enough), the distribution is a Gaussian distribution around 70% with square standard deviation ~8%. So we are talking about a result which is about 5.5 sigma away from the mean. This is something like 1/10^6 event !
How many GLB games are there ? I guess something like a few thousands per day. That excuses of a "statistical fluke" (so away from the settings) cannot be used more than once per season on all GLB.
I did the calculation late at night and quickly, so I may of got some numbers wrongs. !
I have no clue what you just said so I will take your word for it.
einar_90808
offline
offline
so it seems that if I want to run most of the time I need to set the AI to what 95% run?
monsieur mangetout
offline
offline
Originally posted by einar_90808
my pee wee team is set to run 70 to 75% of the time depending on the down and yardage. I checked the AI and on every input I did have the Auto Adjust turned off. Yet in todays game we ran the ball 10 time and tried to pass 42 times. That is 81% pass and 19% run. instead of the 70% run it should be on 1st and 2nd down, and 75% on third and short; and inside the five.
Any AI packages?
my pee wee team is set to run 70 to 75% of the time depending on the down and yardage. I checked the AI and on every input I did have the Auto Adjust turned off. Yet in todays game we ran the ball 10 time and tried to pass 42 times. That is 81% pass and 19% run. instead of the 70% run it should be on 1st and 2nd down, and 75% on third and short; and inside the five.
Any AI packages?
Originally posted by einar_90808
I have no clue what you just said so I will take your word for it.
Late night = broken English.
The probability to get less than 25% run game when you set the OAI to 70% run is 1 per million. I am quite sure cwisler answer is misleading. The result you seen are likely due to:
1) You are not aware of your own OAI settings.
2) You have some problem in the OAI setup that generate this
3) A sim bug.
My guess that either (1) or (2), or both are the issue here.
Originally posted by einar_90808
so it seems that if I want to run most of the time I need to set the AI to what 95% run?
No.
With an error free OAI, you usually get similar results to what you set for. However you should understand that a 10-15 % deviation from your percentage will happens from time to time due to the statistics, (assuming my late night calculation are correct).
Originally posted by monsieur mangetout
Any AI packages?
Packages work fine (for the offense) no need to blame them.
I have no clue what you just said so I will take your word for it.
Late night = broken English.
The probability to get less than 25% run game when you set the OAI to 70% run is 1 per million. I am quite sure cwisler answer is misleading. The result you seen are likely due to:
1) You are not aware of your own OAI settings.
2) You have some problem in the OAI setup that generate this
3) A sim bug.
My guess that either (1) or (2), or both are the issue here.
Originally posted by einar_90808
so it seems that if I want to run most of the time I need to set the AI to what 95% run?
No.
With an error free OAI, you usually get similar results to what you set for. However you should understand that a 10-15 % deviation from your percentage will happens from time to time due to the statistics, (assuming my late night calculation are correct).
Originally posted by monsieur mangetout
Any AI packages?
Packages work fine (for the offense) no need to blame them.
Edited by tragula on Oct 19, 2009 13:20:04
Edited by tragula on Oct 19, 2009 13:18:50
PING72
offline
offline
I also looked over his AI for him and I couldn't find anything amiss, or any situations in which his AI would not fire.
To the question 2 posts above, he does use AI packages, but there aren't any run/pass mixture packages. Meaning, it's set-up as a x% chance to run this package, but within that package it's all run or all pass. So I don't think that should have an impact.
To the question 2 posts above, he does use AI packages, but there aren't any run/pass mixture packages. Meaning, it's set-up as a x% chance to run this package, but within that package it's all run or all pass. So I don't think that should have an impact.
Originally posted by PING72
I also looked over his AI for him and I couldn't find anything amiss, or any situations in which his AI would not fire.
To the question 2 posts above, he does use AI packages, but there aren't any run/pass mixture packages. Meaning, it's set-up as a x% chance to run this package, but within that package it's all run or all pass. So I don't think that should have an impact.
Just by judging his first post on the subject, I am sure he made errors. "The way I set the AI it should look at the running packages first, and see if their number comes up (likely with the %s I put in) then move to the passing packages after, instead it keeps going to the pass first, and not the run. This should not be... what is the problem? " - Doesn't make any sense.
I also looked over his AI for him and I couldn't find anything amiss, or any situations in which his AI would not fire.
To the question 2 posts above, he does use AI packages, but there aren't any run/pass mixture packages. Meaning, it's set-up as a x% chance to run this package, but within that package it's all run or all pass. So I don't think that should have an impact.
Just by judging his first post on the subject, I am sure he made errors. "The way I set the AI it should look at the running packages first, and see if their number comes up (likely with the %s I put in) then move to the passing packages after, instead it keeps going to the pass first, and not the run. This should not be... what is the problem? " - Doesn't make any sense.
Edited by tragula on Oct 19, 2009 14:27:10
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























