Hey, I was wanting to make this post after the preseason but I figured I'd wait for more game data. The passing game is absolutely horrendous and it's making the game quite boring. I cannot speak for other leagues and caps, but in our league, passing is become a liability. Passing to keep a defense honest, even when they're focusing on the run, is a recipe for a pick-6 disaster. It's probably easier to get points from your defense than it is from your passing game.
Before everyone rushes in and criticizes my QB's build, I'm going to break down every single QB in my team's league. You'll also notice how little some of the good teams actually pass due to their coordinators recognizing that passing is inferior to running (except 1 team that can pull off passing). I talked a little bit with an owner of a top team in the other conference, and they actually signed another HB because they couldn't get passing to work either. It's funny seeing QBs of elite teams near the bottom of attempts/passing yardage.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?league_id=143&conference_id=0
Since the stats are tainted with gutted teams, I've broken them down by filtering out anything where the difference in score was >55 points. I'm only using regular season games. I also excluded CPU QBs and QBs with less than 30 total pass attempts.
Name - QB Rating - Comp/Att - Pct - Y/A - TD/INT - Sack
Blake Titan - 70.9 - 21/39 - 53.8 - 5.7 - 0/0 - 1
Steve Roberts - 62.2 - 8/16 - 50.0 - 4.4 - 0/0 - 0
Chandler Harnish - 92.8 - 31/45 - 68.9 - 6.2 - 1/0 - 3
Jack Albert Elway - No suitable games
Roland 'The Gunslinger' Deschain - 23.8 - 7/18 - 38.9 - 2.1 - 0/1 - 3
Jack McGarrett - 72.0 - 71/135 - 52.6 - 5.4 - 4/2 - 2
Benjamin Armstrong - 152.1 - 8/10 - 80 - 16.1 - 1/0 - 0
Bryan Fischer - 55.4 - 38/77 - 49.4 - 4.2 - 0/1 - 10
Todd (the starter) Boeckman - 67.9 - 81/163 - 49.7 - 5.0 - 3/1 - 5
Blackbird XXX - No suitable games
Josh Coyne - 94.1 - 25/42 - 59.5 - 8.3 - 1/0 - 1
Tyler Maguire - 30.2 - 27/70 - 38.5 - 3.3 - 0/3 - 9
Vick Michael - 64.4 - 42/80 - 52.5 - 5.5 - 0/1 - 1
Master OfTheDrive - 87.9 - 18/30 - 5.9 - 1/0 - 0
Dunta' Pillowpants - No suitable games
Guiseppe Goodberry - 71.4 - 33/63 - 53.4 - 4.9 - 1/0 - 2
Brad "The Rifle" Winchester - 51.3 - 42/93 - 45.2 - 3.2 - 2/2 - 7
Cod-y Green - 51.0 - 13/32 - 40.6 - 3.6 - 0/0 - 2
Gabriel J Lyons - 62.2 - 32/61 - 52.5 - 4.3 - 1/1 - 0
Victor Carr - No suitable games
Kaan Kanan - No suitable games
5 Dieter Brock - No suitable games
Rick_ Lyons - 74.0 - 29/51 - 56.9 - 4.3 - 1/0 - 5
Eli Nelson Manning - 86.7 - 26/37 - 70.3 - 6.2 - 0/0 - 0
Christopher Spencer - No suitable games
George Boyd - 55.7 - 23/43 - 53.5 - 4.5 - 0/1 - 5
Vandar Tokare - 53.3 - 30/72 - 41.7 - 3.4 - 3/2 - 1
Smoove Harris - No suitable games
Joe "the Bullet" Montana - 72.5 - 14/29 - 48.5 - 3.3 - 1/0 - 4
Bullet Number5 - No suitable games
Dark Silver - 26.6 - 8/32 - 25.0 - 1.3 - 0/1 - 7
Shosuke Tanihara - 30.2 - 11/32 - 34.4 - 2.9 - 0/1 - 7
Al Mighty - 49.8 - 26/48 - 54.2 - 4.8 - 0/2 - 6
It may seem like the stats are somewhat reasonable, but you have to judge them against the run game. Why risk interceptions and massive amounts of variance when the run game can consistently grind out good yardage (possibly even better averages than passing)? Furthermore, a lot of the completions are from short dump passes for hardly any gain. A lot of the yards are YAC, so it seems to balance out. However, there's very few passes being completed for consistent yardage.
I think it's a combination of a few factors. Defensive builds have their major attributes extremely high already, while QBs and WRs are still working on attributes that they need to succeed. There's also the fact that screens are no longer used to severely inflate a QB's stats.
Now, I'm a defensive minded guy...I started coordinating as a DC and you can see that all my players are defensive backs. However, I still feel that the lack of passing is something that needs to be addressed.
I understand that an issue can come up if the top leagues are balanced and you don't want to change the sim to make the lower leagues more balanced. However, I strongly believe that something should be done. This isn't Peewees - the 38 cap is the highest cap that currently exists. The game should be balanced at this point.
I propose adding some kind of constant that gives a buff to all QBs based upon the cap level they are in. For example, it could be a 10% bonus to all stats at a 38 cap, 15% at 34, 20% at 31, etc... That way, the pro leagues stay balanced and the lower leagues become fun again.
Thanks for your time.
Before everyone rushes in and criticizes my QB's build, I'm going to break down every single QB in my team's league. You'll also notice how little some of the good teams actually pass due to their coordinators recognizing that passing is inferior to running (except 1 team that can pull off passing). I talked a little bit with an owner of a top team in the other conference, and they actually signed another HB because they couldn't get passing to work either. It's funny seeing QBs of elite teams near the bottom of attempts/passing yardage.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?league_id=143&conference_id=0
Since the stats are tainted with gutted teams, I've broken them down by filtering out anything where the difference in score was >55 points. I'm only using regular season games. I also excluded CPU QBs and QBs with less than 30 total pass attempts.
Name - QB Rating - Comp/Att - Pct - Y/A - TD/INT - Sack
Blake Titan - 70.9 - 21/39 - 53.8 - 5.7 - 0/0 - 1
Steve Roberts - 62.2 - 8/16 - 50.0 - 4.4 - 0/0 - 0
Chandler Harnish - 92.8 - 31/45 - 68.9 - 6.2 - 1/0 - 3
Jack Albert Elway - No suitable games
Roland 'The Gunslinger' Deschain - 23.8 - 7/18 - 38.9 - 2.1 - 0/1 - 3
Jack McGarrett - 72.0 - 71/135 - 52.6 - 5.4 - 4/2 - 2
Benjamin Armstrong - 152.1 - 8/10 - 80 - 16.1 - 1/0 - 0
Bryan Fischer - 55.4 - 38/77 - 49.4 - 4.2 - 0/1 - 10
Todd (the starter) Boeckman - 67.9 - 81/163 - 49.7 - 5.0 - 3/1 - 5
Blackbird XXX - No suitable games
Josh Coyne - 94.1 - 25/42 - 59.5 - 8.3 - 1/0 - 1
Tyler Maguire - 30.2 - 27/70 - 38.5 - 3.3 - 0/3 - 9
Vick Michael - 64.4 - 42/80 - 52.5 - 5.5 - 0/1 - 1
Master OfTheDrive - 87.9 - 18/30 - 5.9 - 1/0 - 0
Dunta' Pillowpants - No suitable games
Guiseppe Goodberry - 71.4 - 33/63 - 53.4 - 4.9 - 1/0 - 2
Brad "The Rifle" Winchester - 51.3 - 42/93 - 45.2 - 3.2 - 2/2 - 7
Cod-y Green - 51.0 - 13/32 - 40.6 - 3.6 - 0/0 - 2
Gabriel J Lyons - 62.2 - 32/61 - 52.5 - 4.3 - 1/1 - 0
Victor Carr - No suitable games
Kaan Kanan - No suitable games
5 Dieter Brock - No suitable games
Rick_ Lyons - 74.0 - 29/51 - 56.9 - 4.3 - 1/0 - 5
Eli Nelson Manning - 86.7 - 26/37 - 70.3 - 6.2 - 0/0 - 0
Christopher Spencer - No suitable games
George Boyd - 55.7 - 23/43 - 53.5 - 4.5 - 0/1 - 5
Vandar Tokare - 53.3 - 30/72 - 41.7 - 3.4 - 3/2 - 1
Smoove Harris - No suitable games
Joe "the Bullet" Montana - 72.5 - 14/29 - 48.5 - 3.3 - 1/0 - 4
Bullet Number5 - No suitable games
Dark Silver - 26.6 - 8/32 - 25.0 - 1.3 - 0/1 - 7
Shosuke Tanihara - 30.2 - 11/32 - 34.4 - 2.9 - 0/1 - 7
Al Mighty - 49.8 - 26/48 - 54.2 - 4.8 - 0/2 - 6
It may seem like the stats are somewhat reasonable, but you have to judge them against the run game. Why risk interceptions and massive amounts of variance when the run game can consistently grind out good yardage (possibly even better averages than passing)? Furthermore, a lot of the completions are from short dump passes for hardly any gain. A lot of the yards are YAC, so it seems to balance out. However, there's very few passes being completed for consistent yardage.
I think it's a combination of a few factors. Defensive builds have their major attributes extremely high already, while QBs and WRs are still working on attributes that they need to succeed. There's also the fact that screens are no longer used to severely inflate a QB's stats.
Now, I'm a defensive minded guy...I started coordinating as a DC and you can see that all my players are defensive backs. However, I still feel that the lack of passing is something that needs to be addressed.
I understand that an issue can come up if the top leagues are balanced and you don't want to change the sim to make the lower leagues more balanced. However, I strongly believe that something should be done. This isn't Peewees - the 38 cap is the highest cap that currently exists. The game should be balanced at this point.
I propose adding some kind of constant that gives a buff to all QBs based upon the cap level they are in. For example, it could be a 10% bonus to all stats at a 38 cap, 15% at 34, 20% at 31, etc... That way, the pro leagues stay balanced and the lower leagues become fun again.
Thanks for your time.
Edited by Ronnie Brown 23 on Oct 18, 2009 14:09:33
Edited by Ronnie Brown 23 on Oct 18, 2009 14:07:30
Edited by Ronnie Brown 23 on Oct 18, 2009 14:04:26






























