Actually, it's more the blockers' fault. The TE was supposed to chip the SS and then block the LOLB. The FB is supposed to seal off the SS or CB on the outside. Your RB saw that his angle wasn't going to work and bumped it outside and the play broke down.
quick question? Why did you train or put SP into throwing? That build is way to balanced. Come on, don't put SP into catching till later in your career. Same with stamina, you don't need more stamina than you have vision or carrying. I say retire him and start over. and put the equipment back on.