User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bizarre Substitution issues in our playoff game today.
Page:
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=794955

In our game today, we experienced some completely bizarre substitution issues.

First, lets get the following out of the way.

1. These positions are set to 98/99 sub settings.
2. It has been confirmed that our "favor backups" is set to off (like it has been for 6 seasons now).
3. None of the affected players were on any of the special teams units, and a manual check of all our punts / kickoffs / returns verified this.
4. Our energy / depth chart / advanced energy / sub settings have remain unchanged for the last 3 sims.

Okay here's what we saw.

1) Our starting C played for 21 snaps, and his backup for 52. Over the previous 2 games, that breakdown had been 30 / 33, and 42 / 44. The slight disparity stems from the fact that C1 has a stamina of 55, while C2 has a stamina of 62. They both finished the game with 97 energy and 100 morale.

Watching the sim, we had a 15 play drive in the 2nd qtr that C1 was in for all of 3 plays for, interspersed. C2 was in for 12 of those plays. Even after sitting and resting for a significant amount of time, C2 would come in to start the next drive.

***EDIT**** Upon further review, it appears our starting center only saw the field when our AE settings forced him to. i.e for the 1st qtr, on 3rd down and in the redzone, we force starters. Those are the only times he came in to relieve "his backup".


2) - Our starter at WR1 did not play a single down in the entire second half until the 2 minute warning. He came in for one play while his backup WR1 played the entire 2nd half. Furthermore, WR1 never ever subbed out in the 1st half. At all. Not even during our 15 play 2nd qtr drive. He has 52.5 stamina to the backups 51.7 In our prior 2 games with these settings, we did not see this type of play distribution at all. They both finished this game with 94 energy. This phenomenon was not seen with WR2 or WR3 slots.


What concerns us especially is that we are seeing these oddities only after a teamwide use of Heart of a Champion (for some) and Hometown Hero for others. The question was raised by someone in our team that perhaps Hometown Hero is jacking with stamina calculations in some unforeseen way. Possibly even subtracting stamina


If I look harder, i bet I will find other oddities in our game, but these were the two most glaring.

Can someone please take a look at our game behind the scenes and figure out what the heck is going on?

Thanks!
Scott
Edited by Joe Buck on Sep 18, 2009 15:27:49
Edited by Joe Buck on Sep 18, 2009 15:11:12
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
More:


Noticed this with the QB's too. Upon further review, the number of plays each had...

Q1: fouts - 11, kosar - 0
Q2: fouts - 26, kosar - 6
Q3: fouts - 0, kosar - 15
Q4: fouts - 1, kosar - 14


Fouts is the starter, Kosar the backup.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
...
Edited by Jiddy78 on Sep 18, 2009 15:19:54
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Sounds like advanced energy tactics.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Sounds like advanced energy tactics.


sounds like a bug in the advanced energy tactics you mean?

I confirmed 98/99 energy settings, and that there is nothing prefering backups at all. We have some isolated force starter settings (like last two minutes of the half) that appeared to be what forced our WR1 to pop in at the end.
Edited by Joe Buck on Sep 18, 2009 15:14:47
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe Buck
Originally posted by cwisler

Sounds like advanced energy tactics.


sounds like a bug in the advanced energy tactics you mean?

I confirmed 98/99 energy settings, and that there is nothing forcing starters or prefering backups at all.


Yeah, sorry for not being clear on that.

If you don't have Favor Backups on at all, it may have to be looked into a bit.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
ITT: Fakeass Cries TBH


Wow. You're such a smart-guy. Take your trolling to some other forum, you... troller. This is a forum for srs discussions about beetles. wait...wat? Bugs, I mean.

Get back to CPL, troll.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Originally posted by Joe Buck

Originally posted by cwisler


Sounds like advanced energy tactics.


sounds like a bug in the advanced energy tactics you mean?

I confirmed 98/99 energy settings, and that there is nothing forcing starters or prefering backups at all.


Yeah, sorry for not being clear on that.

If you don't have Favor Backups on at all, it may have to be looked into a bit.


Literally nothing has changed on any of our settings in the last 3 games, and they've all been of the same type of score.....blowouts.
 
Stephen A
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Yeah, sorry for not being clear on that.

If you don't have Favor Backups on at all, it may have to be looked into a bit.


any looking into this would be very much appreciated... especially since the next round of games is in two days.

no rush

hope you can find something.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Okay i think i have isolated it even more at least for our Center oddity.


He was only in on the first play of the game, and then after that only in "forced situations".

I dont want to give away necessarily where we force starters or don't. But for the rest of the game, he only trotted in in only those situations.

Will send you a separate PM cwisler.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Just throwing it out there since I don't like to mess with Joe Buck since St. Louis boys can be really temperamental, but that can happen if the backup player sets his play intensity to relaxed.

The WR issue I have seen from time to time with my WR. He plays most of the 1st half, gets winded, and spends most of the 3rd quarter with his finger up his butt.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Just throwing it out there since I don't like to mess with Joe Buck since St. Louis boys can be really temperamental, but that can happen if the backup player sets his play intensity to relaxed.

The WR issue I have seen from time to time with my WR. He plays most of the 1st half, gets winded, and spends most of the 3rd quarter with his finger up his butt.


I'll confirm with the agent, but i'm 99% sure that isn't the case. Unless he just changed it to that right before the playoffs, it wouldnt explain how the prior games went differently than this.

 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Just throwing it out there since I don't like to mess with Joe Buck since St. Louis boys can be really temperamental, but that can happen if the backup player sets his play intensity to relaxed.

The WR issue I have seen from time to time with my WR. He plays most of the 1st half, gets winded, and spends most of the 3rd quarter with his finger up his butt.


sticky hands imo
 
neoprxis
offline
Link
 
FWIW, 3 teams I'm on had this happen this year. In all 3 cases, absolutely nothing was changed with the energy settings or depth chart for the game before, the game it happened, and at least one game after. All 3 teams were back to normal playing time after the 1 anomaly game, just as they had been before it. It seems to strike randomly.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Neoprxis
FWIW, 3 teams I'm on had this happen this year. In all 3 cases, absolutely nothing was changed with the energy settings or depth chart for the game before, the game it happened, and at least one game after. All 3 teams were back to normal playing time after the 1 anomaly game, just as they had been before it. It seems to strike randomly.


weird.......i am encouraged to hear it goes back to normal immediately afterwards.

Could you possibly provide links to those games? The more instances of it we can show, the more likely it moves up the chain.

And did you see both those things we saw? A) Starter for whole 1st half, backup for whole 2nd (except for force) and B) Starter only in on forced plays, backup in for the rest.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.