Anyone have any thoughts on the leaders/winners? Personally I'm not a fan of defensive MVP going to an average safety who gets a lot of clean-up tackles because he's on a bad team. You'd think the formula would distinguish that...
voltageaav
offline
offline
Lol, I knew you were gonna bring that up. My guy got the offensive MVP and Lofa got the ST MVP. Sure, the guy who got the defensive one doesn't really deserve it, but oh well.
merenoise
offline
offline
Originally posted by SteaminWillieBeamin
Anyone have any thoughts on the leaders/winners? Personally I'm not a fan of defensive MVP going to an average safety who gets a lot of clean-up tackles because he's on a bad team. You'd think the formula would distinguish that...
Who do you think should have won? Looks like the DE in 2nd place had a decent amount of sacks but most came in blowouts. You could make the argument that since he was far and away the best player on his team that he should be considered for MVP because he had the most production. Unless you don't think that any players should be considered for MVP unless they are a playoff team. I'm not saying the SS should have won by any means, just wondering who you think should have gotten it.
Anyone have any thoughts on the leaders/winners? Personally I'm not a fan of defensive MVP going to an average safety who gets a lot of clean-up tackles because he's on a bad team. You'd think the formula would distinguish that...
Who do you think should have won? Looks like the DE in 2nd place had a decent amount of sacks but most came in blowouts. You could make the argument that since he was far and away the best player on his team that he should be considered for MVP because he had the most production. Unless you don't think that any players should be considered for MVP unless they are a playoff team. I'm not saying the SS should have won by any means, just wondering who you think should have gotten it.
SteaminWillieBeamin
offline
offline
Originally posted by merenoise
Who do you think should have won? Looks like the DE in 2nd place had a decent amount of sacks but most came in blowouts. You could make the argument that since he was far and away the best player on his team that he should be considered for MVP because he had the most production. Unless you don't think that any players should be considered for MVP unless they are a playoff team. I'm not saying the SS should have won by any means, just wondering who you think should have gotten it.
Almost all of our games were blowouts, thanks largely due to the pass rush from our DEs...
The fact is , you could have a lvl 8 safety on a team on lvl 1s be an MVP in this league, just because no one else has a chance to stop the ball carrier. Personally I think tackles are about as useless a stat as they are in the NFL.
Who do you think should have won? Looks like the DE in 2nd place had a decent amount of sacks but most came in blowouts. You could make the argument that since he was far and away the best player on his team that he should be considered for MVP because he had the most production. Unless you don't think that any players should be considered for MVP unless they are a playoff team. I'm not saying the SS should have won by any means, just wondering who you think should have gotten it.
Almost all of our games were blowouts, thanks largely due to the pass rush from our DEs...
The fact is , you could have a lvl 8 safety on a team on lvl 1s be an MVP in this league, just because no one else has a chance to stop the ball carrier. Personally I think tackles are about as useless a stat as they are in the NFL.
voltageaav
offline
offline
Who should have got it? Someone with more than 10 combined sacks, forced fumbles, or interceptions. The number of tackles shouldn't even be part of the equation. The Hopilites returner up in EE Pro got screwed by some kicker who made 54 field goals. Our (Hopilites) returner scored 73 TDs on 126 punt returns. Thats 56% of all punt returns, he scored on. We have the top defense in the league, but he forced playoff teams to go for it on 4th down because they knew he would take it all the way. The system is fucked.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























