User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Please no "Coaches"
King of Bling
offline
Link
 
I totally agree with this:

Originally posted by OttawaShane
We feel that the coaching model as described by Bort will harm my enjoyment of the game and interest in continuing to support GLB. Some of the reasons for this include:

1. Will imbalance a game that has just recently been stabilized.

2. Will perpetuate the advantage held by season 1 players right at the time that users who joined later are able to have success.

3. Given the timing it appears that there will be little to no testing performed to ensure this doesn't cause another 1 or more seasons tainted by bugs/exploits.

4. Adds an element that is several steps too far from actual football - equipment crafting takes GLB far too far into WoW territory.

5. When key game elements are missing or don't seem to be functioning as they should - FG replays, pathing issues, blocking dynamics, etc, etc, it doesn't make sense to be spending limited programming time on change that doesn't fix the fundamentals of the game.

6. This change adds to the administration required to run a team, but gives no indication of adding to the fun factor of the game - including being a coach. Its simply more paperwork for everyone.


Coaching was a "nice" idea that has grown completely out of control. Given the number of game imbalances, calculation issues, exploits and an apparent lack of testing, there is every reason to be concerned that this model is too big and too gamechanging while really not adding anything exciting to the realism of the simulations or the fun factor in daily gameplay.
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
I voted yes, but not this season.

The idea of coaching is good. The current proposed implementation is bad.

Head Coach - Can influence Fan Support/Morale
Offensive Coach - Can improve training for the offensive unit or specified positions of the offense OR add modifiers to energy/morale in-game OR provide scouting for upcoming Defense
Defensive Coach - Can improve training for the defensive unit or specified positions of the defense OR add modifiers to energy/morale in-game OR provide scouting on upcoming Offense
ST Coach - Can improve training for ST unit (K/P/KR/PR/any player on ST DC not on ODC or DDC) or specified positions of the ST unit OR add modifiers to energy/morale in-game OR provide ST scouting for upcoming ST unit
Equipment Manager - Can "craft" AEQ (some randomness involved in what is created).

Coaches can be created from any player who is at least 200 days old OR level 28 (5 seasons, unboosted, max XP). Max value for a coach (coaching Skill Points) will be given for any player over 440 days old and at least Level 65. CSP will be pro-rated for lower level coaches.

Leave it at that, and I can go for it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
I voted yes, but not this season.

The idea of coaching is good. The current proposed implementation is bad.

Head Coach - Can influence Fan Support/Morale
Offensive Coach - Can improve training for the offensive unit or specified positions of the offense OR add modifiers to energy/morale in-game OR provide scouting for upcoming Defense
Defensive Coach - Can improve training for the defensive unit or specified positions of the defense OR add modifiers to energy/morale in-game OR provide scouting on upcoming Offense
ST Coach - Can improve training for ST unit (K/P/KR/PR/any player on ST DC not on ODC or DDC) or specified positions of the ST unit OR add modifiers to energy/morale in-game OR provide ST scouting for upcoming ST unit
Equipment Manager - Can "craft" AEQ (some randomness involved in what is created).

Coaches can be created from any player who is at least 200 days old OR level 28 (5 seasons, unboosted, max XP). Max value for a coach (coaching Skill Points) will be given for any player over 440 days old and at least Level 65. CSP will be pro-rated for lower level coaches.

Leave it at that, and I can go for it.


as far as equipment managers go he should just add a +1 bonus to one piece of equipment on each player. for the season. but blanket the +1 so it would have to be +1 speed for all players....

 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Everyone who votes no is not smart, season one players will have a 5% penalty in less then a season and a 10% penalty in two.

You should not have to wait to create a coach

 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazy454
Everyone who votes no is not smart, season one players will have a 5% penalty in less then a season and a 10% penalty in two.

You should not have to wait to create a coach



God bless you, but I disagree. Its better to wait and get it right, than rush into something that is horribly wrong. And right now, based on the history of GLB, this has all the earmarks of something that is horribly wrong.
 
Covenant
offline
Link
 
I voted no. All I'd like is a little tab or sometihn where retired players stats are kept in a hall of fame type thing. Where you can look at all your old guys, and when someone checks your profile they can see your golden oldies.

Coaches is just pointless, Sub standard method to try and keep us spending on flex
 
Moo45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Covenant
Coaches is just pointless, Sub standard method to try and keep us spending on flex


...and thats why I think this vote is useless. Bort does this game more for money not necessarily to make the best game possible.

 
cardfan
offline
Link
 
Measure failed.....

For now.
 
griz
offline
Link
 
I think each team should have about 27 coaches.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Moo45
...and thats why I think this vote is useless. Bort does this game more for money not necessarily to make the best game possible.



it is his only job. and who are we to stop paying someone in these economic times.
 
Covenant
offline
Link
 
We for him to deliver the best game he can possibly make. We shouldnt have to pay a higher rate for lesser product
 
King of Bling
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Covenant
We for him to deliver the best game he can possibly make. We shouldnt have to pay a higher rate for lesser product


Not the clearest oration, but I agree...I think
 
Covenant
offline
Link
 
Meh lol. Was a very late night for me. we pay him to deliver etc.. .

 
Alief86
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Covenant
I voted no. All I'd like is a little tab or sometihn where retired players stats are kept in a hall of fame type thing. Where you can look at all your old guys, and when someone checks your profile they can see your golden oldies.

Coaches is just pointless, Sub standard method to try and keep us spending on flex



Right On
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.