User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #4 > Me? I'm SO Against This Coaching Thing
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
As much as I'd love to have Warren Slop, coach of the Tallahassee Thunder announced, this is a HORRIBLE idea.

First and foremost, i don't want to fucking recruit a team, AND FUCKING 15 COACHES.

a FUCKING EQUIPMENT MANAGER, ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?

im in private forum, they sum it up pretty well.

Originally posted by OttawaShane
We feel that the coaching model as described by Bort will harm my enjoyment of the game and interest in continuing to support GLB. Some of the reasons for this include:

1. Will imbalance a game that has just recently been stabilized.

2. Will perpetuate the advantage held by season 1 players right at the time that users who joined later are able to have success.

3. Given the timing it appears that there will be little to no testing performed to ensure this doesn't cause another 1 or more seasons tainted by bugs/exploits.

4. Adds an element that is several steps too far from actual football - equipment crafting takes GLB far too far into WoW territory.

5. When key game elements are missing or don't seem to be functioning as they should - FG replays, pathing issues, blocking dynamics, etc, etc, it doesn't make sense to be spending limited programming time on change that doesn't fix the fundamentals of the game.

6. This change adds to the administration required to run a team, but gives no indication of adding to the fun factor of the game - including being a coach. Its simply more paperwork for everyone.


Coaching was a "nice" idea that has grown completely out of control. Given the number of game imbalances, calculation issues, exploits and an apparent lack of testing, there is every reason to be concerned that this model is too big and too gamechanging while really not adding anything exciting to the realism of the simulations or the fun factor in daily gameplay.


 
Tex Scram
offline
Link
 
If anything, I'd rather just see a Madden-like coaching system where it's just something you buy along with stadium upgrades. I'd even throw in other things like Madden's medical facility to add other bonuses to the team.
 
Pjkuchta
offline
Link
 
Are two separate threads in the same forum really necessary? Geez, We know you dont like it already.
 
Tex Scram
offline
Link
 
Make your voice heard here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=230
 
awooga
offline
Link
 
Dawgs - If they delay a season, restrict the number of coaches, and take on more feedback, doesn't most of your concerns get alleviated?

I kinda like the idea. Adds another wrinkle to the game. As long as its done properly.....
 
Bob Miley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tex Scram
If anything, I'd rather just see a Madden-like coaching system where it's just something you buy along with stadium upgrades. I'd even throw in other things like Madden's medical facility to add other bonuses to the team.


I dont think they'll like being Madden-like.

I don't mind the idea, I have been working on this character for a year an a half, so it's like, if I retire him, that time goes basically down the drain. His stats won't matter for much(like they do anyways) and to be honest, I'll miss the little guy.

I don't see a problem with it if they test things out, work on it while doing other things and come up with a finish project that everyone can agree with.
Edited by Bob Miley on Sep 9, 2009 10:26:55
 
Sequtugh
offline
Link
 
Kinda agree with dawgs on this. There are so many other things that Bort could be working on - like the broke-ass sim engine. This seems like a money grab to me, to keep the older guys interested in keeping their player-turned-coach around and pump more money into boosting them all over again. Once again, the idea of a *TEST SERVER* to play this kind of shit out seems to me to be the best idea ..... but we all know how far that suggestion has gone
Edited by Sequtugh on Sep 9, 2009 10:25:25
 
Sequtugh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bob Miley

I don't mind the idea, I have been working on this character for a year an a half, so it's like, if I retire him, that time goes basically down the drain. His stats won't matter for much(like they do anyways) and to be honest, I'll miss the little guy.


My point EXACTLY

 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awooga
Dawgs - If they delay a season, restrict the number of coaches, and take on more feedback, doesn't most of your concerns get alleviated?

I kinda like the idea. Adds another wrinkle to the game. As long as its done properly.....


too complicated for the majority of users now. too much else broken. need some more FUN aspects, not more work.
 
Link
 
wait....this game is stabilized?
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cool Hand Bsby
wait....this game is stabilized?


when compared to the past?

with mismatched leagues, over powered power backs, non-exisitant passing game... yes. its much more stable.
 
Bugman_AZ
offline
Link
 
Just another way for Bort to retire earlier. He knew the Season 1 agents were going to start retiring players and get 70% flex back. That would have meant a huge drop in revenue. Fuck the coaching idea. It benefits noone but Bort. Fix the rest of the game first damn it. This gimmick bullshit is wrecking the game. Coaches ?!?!?! Haha ... blow me.
 
Link
 
it'd be a great idea if each team just had an owner forced to do everything. add in coaches, let them coordinate the offense, defense, special teams. but we don't have that situation. we already have GMs to do that.

if coaches were to replace GMs, and do their jobs, I could see it being worthwhile. make it something that will actually be work, vs, just glorying in your old player now sittin around doin next to nothin. implementing THAT, in one season, would be a logistical nightmare, and pretty much impossible at this point. also take into account that many GMS out there are true experts and GM for many teams that pretty much would suck without them. they'd have to have a player retire and become a coach, then get signed to that team in that capacity to continue to help in that way. NO way we could do that in 1 season.

if they were to filter in coaches, letting retired players actually be on the roster and assign them GM duties (exceptions being trades, stadium stuff... player coaches would just do things regarding tactics) and give them small bonuses for their areas of expertise, eventually player coaches would BE the GMS. 10 seasons down the road or longer, for all teams to make the switch.

For coaches to make sense, they should have been implemented a loooong time ago, and do what GMs do. right now they are just a carrot to keep old players from having to retire. really no other purpose. that is not a good enough reason.

Jack
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.