User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Sim Bug or Replay Bug, You choose.
Page:
 
Troymk1
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=716842&pbp_id=10993241

If the Receiver is making spin moves and breaking tackles, then the ball popping out is a fumble, NOT knocked loose.

 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
he caught and attempted to spin and got knocked out, he didn't have the ball in his possession long enough.

look at the todd yoder play last night vs the jags, he scored a TD but they said no because the ball came out afterwards and said he didn't have it long enough.
 
Troymk1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
he caught and attempted to spin and got knocked out, he didn't have the ball in his possession long enough.

look at the todd yoder play last night vs the jags, he scored a TD but they said no because the ball came out afterwards and said he didn't have it long enough.


Mate seriously.

This is a computer SIM, everything is 1 or 0

There ARE no grey areas.

To effect a broken tackle he must have had possession. Correct?

To have a ball popped loose and count as an incomplete, he did not have possession. Correct?

So either the Replay is reporting the events in wrong order (which I seriously doubt.)

OR there is a SIM bug allowing this nonsensical sequence of events.

QED
Fix the bug, make it a fumble.


 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
hey I am trying to answer the question the best way that I know how, without knowing the entire sim-code.

maybe the text is wrong or whatever, but I was just trying to explain how the replay looked vs the text.

sorry mate
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Troymk1
So either the Replay is reporting the events in wrong order (which I seriously doubt.)


Not so much the wrong order but that it all happens at the exact same time.

I.e. the WR spins, the missed tackle and the PD attempts all take place at once.

The events would be something like:

1 - catch
2 - spin
2 - tackle/pd
2 - re-rolls vs original catch value
3 - "output event log"

 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Troymk1

So either the Replay is reporting the events in wrong order (which I seriously doubt.)


Not so much the wrong order but that it all happens at the exact same time.

I.e. the WR spins, the missed tackle and the PD attempts all take place at once.

The events would be something like:

1 - catch
2 - spin
2 - tackle/pd
2 - re-rolls vs original catch value
3 - "output event log"



hmm eerily similar to what I said
 
Troymk1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Not so much the wrong order but that it all happens at the exact same time.

I.e. the WR spins, the missed tackle and the PD attempts all take place at once.

The events would be something like:

1 - catch
2 - spin
2 - tackle/pd
2 - re-rolls vs original catch value
3 - "output event log"



I don't know Koncorde that makes me uncomfortable. But IIRC Bort did say it's a hazy amount of time before a catch can become a Fumble. I don't like that a Spin move can occur in that parcel of time.



 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
The problem I think is that it wasn't originally coded that way. I.e. it was originally:

Input > Output > Result

Now it's more:

Input > Output > Delay Output > Re-Roll > Input > Output
Input > Output > Trigger Event
Input > Output > Result

Whether a PD and a spin move should coexist is still a good question btw. Though I think it's more an anomly of the output logic than any actual bug.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Troymk1

So either the Replay is reporting the events in wrong order (which I seriously doubt.)


Not so much the wrong order but that it all happens at the exact same time.

I.e. the WR spins, the missed tackle and the PD attempts all take place at once.

The events would be something like:

1 - catch
2 - spin
2 - tackle/pd
2 - re-rolls vs original catch value
3 - "output event log"


I assume "2" would serve as the "possession" roll. The defender should not be allowed to have a "tackle" roll at this point. That is the bug.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Not really. The attempted tackle is also an attempted "Knockled Loose", hence why it all kind of has to happen at once. Until the ball is resolved as "caught" then everyone has to roll to either make a PD or make a tackle, and any or all failures will be recorded.

The "bug" is that it is recorded as a "missed tackle" instead of a "missed knockled loose opportunity" or variation thereof.

The ability of the WR to "spin" without possession of the ball is also more of an issue.
 
The Big House
offline
Link
 
I believe this was the player's choice. He didn't have to spin to try to touchdown it, He instead made a big mistake and not spin.
 
Troymk1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Not really. The attempted tackle is also an attempted "Knockled Loose", hence why it all kind of has to happen at once. Until the ball is resolved as "caught" then everyone has to roll to either make a PD or make a tackle, and any or all failures will be recorded.

The "bug" is that it is recorded as a "missed tackle" instead of a "missed knockled loose opportunity" or variation thereof.

The ability of the WR to "spin" without possession of the ball is also more of an issue.


Bring it to El Borto's attention if you will.
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=784905&pbp_id=13666910

It even says a "missed diving tackle" was made after the catch, and THEN its knocked loose, AND a deflected pass after 3-4 yards gained by the HB??
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
I think the problem is the window for knocking loose passes is TOO LONG. That's also the reason you see so many knocked loose passes.

You could be saying, well, if the window was too long, wouldn't those all be fumbles instead, and we'd see a huge increase in fumbles? No...because Jackhammer only gives a bonus to KL...not fumbles.

Anyways, that's just my $.02.
 
Slinger17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Avenger
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=784905&pbp_id=13666910

It even says a "missed diving tackle" was made after the catch, and THEN its knocked loose, AND a deflected pass after 3-4 yards gained by the HB??


Now this is a bug
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.