User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > WTF! - WR at HB on critical down???
Page:
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
We have checked and rechecked our depth chart assignments and ai, there no way our WR should have been in there... we don't even do cheesy crap like that to begin with.

I would love for someone to explain this BS to me. We have the game in the balance, and the freaking sim decided to just drop a WR in at HB...

Unbelievable.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=713285&pbp_id=10891293
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Well trying to figure out why the sim did this:

1 TE on the Depth chart, goal line requires 3. It should have pulled the other 2 TEs in, but I'm wondering since they weren't on the 'basic' Depth chart, they weren't considered to be placed.

So, you have the TE on the Depth chart, the FB on the Depth chart, and a WR on the Depth chart all playing TE.
Then your HB on the Depth chart got bumped to playing FB, defaulting a WR to the HB position.

Still unsure why the sim wouldn't pull those other 2 TEs in though.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Well trying to figure out why the sim did this:

1 TE on the Depth chart, goal line requires 3. It should have pulled the other 2 TEs in, but I'm wondering since they weren't on the 'basic' Depth chart, they weren't considered to be placed.

So, you have the TE on the Depth chart, the FB on the Depth chart, and a WR on the Depth chart all playing TE.
Then your HB on the Depth chart got bumped to playing FB, defaulting a WR to the HB position.

Still unsure why the sim wouldn't pull those other 2 TEs in though.


basially this and also maybe it is a mystery nerf by bort
 
Techy
offline
Link
 
TE custom slots don't mean a thing if the play doesn't call them out in the AI, the above explanation is correct.


Goal Line Formation includes 3 TE's, you have 1 on your depth chart, so it'll pick FB's, then WR's.

now you have no FB (Playing TE), so it picks your HB, to play FB, now you have no HB(Playing FB), so it picks a WR to play at HB.


Backups are key.
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
what a crock of shit... we have 3 tes and 2 fbs on our roster and this STUPID, IDIOTIC sim decides to grab a WR to run?

how can it even do that when we have the back designated as RB1 and our powerback in that slot?
Edited by elvistcb on Sep 3, 2009 12:44:34
 
Kayoh
offline
Link
 
It's an easy fix - just put the other 2 TEs on the TE DC and set your advanced energy settings at TE to 1/2.
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
why would that even matter?... we had rb1 designated at that slot... if it did anything stupid, it should have been to grab some random player to fill a te slot
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by elvistcb
why would that even matter?... we had rb1 designated at that slot... if it did anything stupid, it should have been to grab some random player to fill a te slot


Well it seems like the HB slot is filled after the TE and FB slots. So, I don't see what harm it could do to put the other TEs on the 'basic' TE depth chart. That should solve the problem for the future.

EDIT: And put the other HBs at the HB position. Just use RB1/RB2 designations in your AI to avoid the wrong HBs running the ball. Seems like the sim will only pull players from the 'basic' depth chart, like Techy said.
Edited by cwisler on Sep 3, 2009 12:48:49
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
I donno.... whatever the case, its one of the most boneheaded things I have seen this stupid sim engine do in the entire time I have been playing this game
 
Kayoh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kayoh
It's an easy fix - just put the other 2 TEs on the TE DC and set your advanced energy settings at TE to 1/2.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by elvistcb
I donno.... whatever the case, its one of the most boneheaded things I have seen this stupid sim engine do in the entire time I have been playing this game


It probably doesn't pull players from anything more than the 'basic' depth chart because of players having to sit if they played a game in the past 48 hours. This way it avoids pulling those players into the game.

When I refer to 'basic', I'm talking about the depth chart not including custom slots, just an fyi.
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
I mean we have 3 HBs, 2 FBs and 3 TEs on the roster ------ how stupid is the computer when the best it can figure out is to drop a wr at HB and and freaking HB at FB..

its funny to some degree... but very sad at the same time
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by elvistcb
I mean we have 3 HBs, 2 FBs and 3 TEs on the roster ------ how stupid is the computer when the best it can figure out is to drop a wr at HB and and freaking HB at FB..

its funny to some degree... but very sad at the same time


Because of this more than likely:

Originally posted by cwisler
It probably doesn't pull players from anything more than the 'basic' depth chart because of players having to sit if they played a game in the past 48 hours. This way it avoids pulling those players into the game.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
I'm not going to say for a fact I know where the sim defaults too when trying to fill positions that are included on the basic depth chart, but I do know this:

http://img529.imageshack.us/img529/4338/goallineblitzbetaameric.jpg

Your formation specific depth chart calls for using your TE, HB, and FB slots on Goal Line Offenses. I would think that if your AI is set a specific way, and your depth chart is incomplete for the play requirements, that this would be one of the default places for the sim to check.

Also, with custom slots available at HB, FB and TE, it just doesn't make sense not to fill your regular slots and adjust your energy settings and formation depth charts. You have to protect yourself from strange things happening, 1st, not on Bert's sim to be perfect.

Also, you HB that had the most carries, had 8 TFLs, pretty good chance you weren't getting that 1st down anyway.
 
Techy
offline
Link
 
The ROSTER does not matter when it comes to who plays at what position. The DEPTH CHART is the ONLY thing that affects that.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.