User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Someone give me cliffs on the weight fix
Page:
 
Link
 
thx

mods pls sticky

Jed edit: Since I moved the giant thread to bugs to keep going with the real talk of how to fix the issue, feel free to use this one for general discussion. To recap Bort's comments:

Originally posted by Bort
Have never confirmed nor denied such rumors tbh. If there were secret attributes, they would be secret, no?

Though yes, random situations could appear to make one player play better than another from time to time, and certain skill combos might work better than others.


Originally posted by Bort
Nope, I've never said had and fast either way. Maybe these things exist, maybe they don't, or maybe I think it would be interesting to add someday so I don't want to officially strike it off the possibility list by giving a hard answer...

Also, even if an "attribute" were "hidden" like you describe, it doesn't mean you wouldn't be able to affect it somehow. Just sayin'.


Originally posted by Jed
OK, so you can confirm that there is nothing in place behind the scenes that pre-determines one player will always, say, run a route faster, block better, or throw more accurately than another player with the same exact skills, SA's, VA's, and equipment? If there is/ever will be something behind the scenes, it'll be like what you describe there, to make things more random?


Originally posted by Bort
I agree that any "hidden" stuff is or will be random like I'm talking about. I think game to game and play to play randomness to be very important and interesting ideas, that mirror real life events. Sometimes players show up for the game, other times don't for whatever reason. Abilities to affect those factors are my favorite ones, actually. I love the streaky ability, though it might need some updates to work less all or nothing. I also like clutch. Some players tend to come up big more often in real life.

Edited by Jed on Sep 2, 2009 08:04:02
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Things were broke, and they are now fixed, but only sort of.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Bort should really at least say what the problem was, what caused the problem, what the effects did to the sim, and what not. I mean, considering this problem has possibly been here since season 1 (not sure just guessing) people probably should at least know considering he fixed it
 
DaMayan
offline
Link
 
Sept 1, 2009
- Fix to mitigate potential issue with data transmission errors for the weight column on some players, that could potentially increase/decrease effective stats (esp. velocity) for those players. A floor and ceiling for effective player weight has been added to fix the issue.

Cliff enough?
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
Bort should really at least say what the problem was, what caused the problem, what the effects did to the sim, and what not. I mean, considering this problem has possibly been here since season 1 (not sure just guessing) people probably should at least know considering he fixed it


i thought weights of players really didnt mean anything until like season 3 or something...
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Things were broke, and they are now fixed, but only sort of.


Not "sort of," "maybe."
 
DaMayan
offline
Link
 
In layman's terms weight had a data issue causing players to have wierd weight's like 20000 or 0000.21

Bort added a check to ensure the weight was between resonalbe boundry's. So if the weight was 200000 it would have be wrong and would be checked again until it is reasonable. Probably with a fail safe after a couple iterations at a median weight.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Anybody have a link to the thread that lead to this change?
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
Bort should really at least say what the problem was, what caused the problem, what the effects did to the sim, and what not. I mean, considering this problem has possibly been here since season 1 (not sure just guessing) people probably should at least know considering he fixed it


He did in that monster X-factor thread. Let me try to explain, though it seems like an odd explanation to me.

When the sim runs it pulls all the players in from the database. For some reason connection problems caused players to have corrupt values in the weight table. This meant some players were benefiting from extremely low weights. Bort couldn't fix this problem, so he added a script to check to make sure all values were within a sane range.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
It's not so much that he couldn't fix them as much as it's not a guaranteed fix, so putting something like this in place will act like a fix right now if that is the problem so if it is, the problem will act fixed till a real fix is in place and work to show that it is indeed the problem at the same time
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
It's not so much that he couldn't fix them as much as it's not a guaranteed fix, so putting something like this in place will act like a fix right now if that is the problem so if it is, the problem will act fixed till a real fix is in place and work to show that it is indeed the problem at the same time


To be fair, debugging is a bitch.
 
Real LT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Things were broke, and they are now fixed, but only sort of.


PERFECT!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Real LT
PERFECT!


More band-aided than fixed tbh.
 
Real LT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
More band-aided than fixed tbh.


GLB treats cancer with band-aids, SOP.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by chronoaug

Bort should really at least say what the problem was, what caused the problem, what the effects did to the sim, and what not. I mean, considering this problem has possibly been here since season 1 (not sure just guessing) people probably should at least know considering he fixed it


He did in that monster X-factor thread. Let me try to explain, though it seems like an odd explanation to me.

When the sim runs it pulls all the players in from the database. For some reason connection problems caused players to have corrupt values in the weight table. This meant some players were benefiting from extremely low weights. Bort couldn't fix this problem, so he added a script to check to make sure all values were within a sane range.


so there WAS an X factor of sorts and now it is gone, ala the ultimate nerf of all players?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.