User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #1 > Week 4 Eastern Rankings (no script)
Knightman
offline
Link
 
OK, taking a cue from Dujo, here are a set of Eastern Conference rankings that have absolutely no scientific basis whatsoever:

1. Red Bank Thundercats (4-0): The Thundercats hold the dubious honor of the team with the best record NOT to get promoted last season as a result of their first round upset loss to the New Jersey Battalion, but this is an AWESOME team! It may all work out as they may well end up with a trophy. Certainly it places the mantle of league favorite squarely upon their shoulders, and they’ve done nothing thus far to suggest that they aren’t the odds-on favorite, at least in the Eastern Conference. Tillis and McMannus have been terrorizing defenses since the old BBB#7 days, and now they’ve added Wide Open at WR1, the stellar WR from the old Niagara Rapids Championship clubs. Overall levels (yeah yeah, I know, Build >>>>> Levels, but I can’t SEE the builds) are very strong and the team has good depth. Until someone comes along and knocks them off, they’re my #1.
2. Jax Beach Juggernauts (4-0): Undefeated thus far. 24 wins in a row. Very hard NOT to rank them #1, but look at who they’ve played: two teams that are gutted (0-4), one team that’s gutted and credits its only win to another gutted 0-4 team (Rochester beat Parma), and a 2-2 team. A look at their roster shows good but not overwhelming levels. OTOH, you don’t win 24 games in a row if you don’t know how to gameplan and get the most out of your talent. That fact alone gets them to #2, but I just couldn’t put them above Red Bank. Sorry guys. Guess you can use this as bulletin board material before your game against my Purple Penguins on Monday (maybe I should’ve done this AFTER that game??)
3. American Freedom (3-1): Our resident Mod’s team has strength at CB and LT and pretty darn good overall levels in the starting lineup, but a couple problems with depth, specifically at SS and the interior OL. Nonetheless, when you look at the body of work so far this season, their resume is most impressive. They’ve provided the only loss for Texas and dropped a single contest to the #1 ranked team, the Thundercats. Their futility in the AAA World Cup is a bit concerning. They’ve posted that they didn’t gameplan for these games, but “Ranked” games come with an implicit acknowledgement that both teams will do their best to win. That being said, the only thing that REALLY matters is how they do in their league, and that’s going just fine, thank you. When push comes to shove, if you’ve got limited time or resources to devote to gameplanning, it’s the tournaments that are going to get neglected. A lot will get sorted out over the next 4 weeks with New York, both Louisvilles, and Jax Beach on the menu. One way or another, the Freedom are going to answer a lot of questions within the next 10 days.
4. Louisville Baby Kittens (3-1): OK, I’ll go ahead and get it out of the way…..it’s Loo-ISS-vill (as in Ohio), not Loo-EE-vill (as in Kentucky). This is how I keep our two “Louisville” clubs straight in my head. In any event, this is a team LOADED with a strong tradition of success and perennially powerful passing attack (ok, I had to get at least ONE alliterative “P” phrase in there). Yes they do have the one loss to my Purple Penguins, but this is a team that can beat ANYBODY and knows how to slam the door. They’ve always had excellent game planning and scouting, so although their three wins have come against competition that doesn’t have a terrific cumulative record (1-11), I still think this is a team that’s going to be right in the thick of the Championship hunt. I could be wrong, but history has shown that those who bet against the Baby Kittens usually…….lose!
5. Atlanta Purple Penguins (3-1): Frankly, I can’t rate my own team objectively. We have a pretty good team with a LOUSY coach, so we’re likely to be inconsistent. Pretty good depth. Pretty good talent. Got slaughtered in the interconference opener against Columbus but have been able to pull out the last three games. I think we’re definitely a team that expects to make the playoffs. More than that will depend on how badly I screw up.
6. Texas Tarheels (3-1): Whatsdafus’s hands down favorite for the Conference Championship is clearly a solid club, but there are some issues. Most prominent of these are the Inactives as of this writing (8/23 01:45 Eastern), of which there are ten, but more concerning is that four of them are among his top 6 CBs. With the emphasis on passing that seems to be in vogue this season, this could be a problem if it continues. There’s decent depth and two nice wins against Mudville and Oakland, both currently 2-2, but a stumble against American Freedom. That drops the Tarheels down a bit, but they certainly look like a shoo-in for the playoffs based on the early going.
7. Oakland Nation (2-2): The Nation are only 2-2, but their losses have come to two very tough teams, the Thundercats and the Tarheels. However, underestimating them will surely lead to disaster. They’ve defeated the 3-1 Cincinnati Stoners from the Western Division as well as notching a solid win against the Death Stars and as the schedule eases up, the wins will come. Talent and depth both look good, although it remains to be seen whether their strategy of using clearly outleveled players as exclusively special teamers works out. Will the savings in stamina for the starters compensate for an increased chance at a breakaway touchdown or a forced fumble deep in your own territory? Tune in next week, same Bat-Time, same Bat-Chann…..oh, I’m dating myself aren’t I?
8. Louisville Nighthawks (2-2): This Louisville team is the poster child for the tendency of dominant AA teams promoting and finding their anticipated swift ascent to the Pros running into an abrupt roadblock in AAA. The Nighthawks were a juggernaut (with apologies to Jax Beach) last season, running through their league with a 16-0 record before a second round upset loss in the playoffs. They have very good talent and very good depth, but will have to adjust to the increased intensity of competition in AAA. Can they do it? Of course they can. But it will take a rededication of the coaching staff and a less one-dimensional team, especially on offense, to do it. For most teams, it takes about a season to get those issues worked through, but the Nighthawks have enough raw talent that they still should be able to secure a playoff berth.
9. New York Warriors (2-2): Waiting in the wings in case any of the above stumble will be the Warriors, who are 2-2, but whose wins have come against teams with a combined record of 1-7. Then again, their losses are to teams that are 3-1, so the Warriors appear to be a team that’s going to run in the middle of the pack—right where we’ve placed them. Their roster looks good but is a little suspect in the secondary where depth may be an issue. New York should beat the teams they’re supposed to beat, and will likely lose to those teams where they’re the clear underdog. Whether they make the playoffs or not will probably hinge on their performance against Riverhead and the Louisville Nighthawks which should make the last 4 games of the season very exciting!
10. Saint Paul Vulcans (1-3): The Vulcans are taking on the league with only 44 men on their roster, and a generally underleveled roster at that. There are a few depth problems and starters who individually fall within the typical range expected at this level, but as a group seem to be lower. Having said that, they took on and defeated a Philadelphia team that outleveled them, thus their higher ranking. The truism still holds that Gameplanning >>> Builds >>> Levels so despite Philadelphia’s superior team on paper, the Vulcans get the nod here over the Marauders.
11. Philadelphia Marauders II (1-3): The Marauders are a puzzle to me. The archives show that they were only 8-8 last season in AA and they didn’t apparently even make the playoffs, yet they find themselves in AAA. Their starting lineup looks respectable, and they’ve not embarrassed themselves in their contests thus far, but it’s hard to imagine that they will be able to achieve a better record in AAA than they did in AA. There’s definitely potential AND talent there, but the Marauders will need to show me some quality wins before I become a believer.
12. Riverhead Blue Waves (2-2): All right. This is the top rushing team in the League. So far so good. They’re a respectable 9th in total defense. Not bad at all. Their two wins were both against gutted teams—not impressive, but then again, the schedule isn’t their fault. They lost to Jax Beach (no shame there) but then got pummeled by the Nighthawks. Hmmmmm, what’s going on here? Well, it could it have something to do with the fact that 25 of their 52 players are INACTIVE! Yikes! This is not just one guy who’s on vacation—I counted 17 different agents for the players that were inactive. I don’t know if this is going to be a chronic problem for the Waves, but if it is, then there’s trouble right here in River(head) City with a Capital “T!
13. Houston Cougars (0-4): As we move to the bottom of the pack, we find more AA teams that were hugely successful having difficulty once promoted to AAA. The Cougars are yet another example, having gone 14-2 last season, qualifying for the Conference Championship, and finding AAA#1 rough sledding at 0-4. Traditionally, though, once the initial adjustment period wears off, these teams find their true colors and step up to the challenge, so beware the Cougars as the season wears on! For now, they get the edge over the other 0-4 teams based simply on how competitive their games were and strength of schedule. Not the most accurate of measures, to be sure, but for positions 14-16, pinpoint accuracy is hardly necessary. Houston has been by far more competitive than either Tampa Bay or Pittsburgh and is destined to spring a nasty surprise on someone (or someones) before this season is over.
14. Coruscant Death Stars (1-3): “Payback’s a bitch.” So goes this team’s motto for this season and indeed, the Death Stars have recruited a very respectable lineup with which to inflict pain and suffering upon the rest of the league. Thus far, though, it hasn’t gone exactly according to plan. The Death Stars have 19 Inactives on a roster of 50, of which 15 are on defense. I’m too lazy to figure out how many agents are involved again, but it doesn’t bode well. Riverhead and Coruscant both find themselves in similar positions, and if they can’t find a solution to these Inactives soon, they may well be condemned to simply playing out the string.
15. Tampa Bay Thunder (0-4): Tampa Bay is probably experiencing culture shock right about now. They’ve not been able to win a single game since promotion, whether it be regular season or scrimmage, and for a team that was 15-1 last season, that’s got to be frustrating. There’s a good foundation here, but the team is especially weak when it comes to depth in the secondary. That may make it a long season for the Thunder.
16. Pittsburgh Steel (0-4): Got to give Steelersrule credit. His team started from NOTHING before this season and had to build themselves a team from the ground up in the space of less than a couple weeks. Success has been hard to come by, but if it were easy to build a winner in AAA in 10 days then everybody would be in Pro by now. This season the Steel are going to take their lumps, but I wouldn’t bet against them next season. After all, the Steel have already proven their “metal” (hey, it’s late and I’m a little sleep deprived, ok?) by advancing to USA Pro a few seasons ago.

As always, this is all just for fun. No offense to anyone or any team is intended.
Edited by Knightman on Aug 22, 2009 23:07:56
 
Dujoman
offline
Link
 
Good stuff man! I ran out of stuff to write!
 
kcfdx
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the writeup Knightman. I hope we can live up to the lofty goals you've set for us.
 
Moondog22
offline
Link
 
wow knightman that was epic! i think you ranked us fairly too. we stumbled pretty bad against oakland, but its a good organisation they got going there so theres no shame in it. other than that, or matchup with red bank in week 6 should be the high point of our season. if we beat them i think we can secure a home playoff berth. hopefully we will meet as 4-1 (us) and them at 4-1/5-0, so that we can win the head to head over them and be in good shape to make the playoffs. going to be a knock out game cant wait!
 
Warwynd
offline
Link
 
Wow!!! Great to see Knightman doing a write-up again!!!
 
Wei Wu Wei
offline
Link
 
Good job. I really appreciate the effort to compose an informed listing like this.


I look forward to more.
 
Primate
offline
Link
 
The inactives are a GLB-wide problem, imo. A ton of gen 1 guys have become disillusioned with the game, and another ton have just lost interest.

 
Primate
offline
Link
 
Nice write up, btw...
 
smittdog101
offline
Link
 
Good write up.
 
wollfrnd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warwynd
Wow!!! Great to see Knightman doing a write-up again!!!


+1

As always, it was a very fun read. Knightman, thank you for doing this.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
I agree with everyone else and I couldn't have done it better. Very well done and unbiased.
 
cosine4
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Good write up, thanks for doing this.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.