I don't have any problem with Favre. NFL teams are business, first and foremost.
Is he past his prime? Yes.
Is he a better choice than Sage Rosenfels? Yes.
Is he a better choice than Tavaris Jackson? A hundred times yes.
Will Favre being on the team created a HUGE amount of unpredicted income? Yes.
And, if you factor in that the Vikings have a twice as good O-line as the Jets did, Adrian Peterson, and a much better defense than the Jets, I don't see any reason why old washed up Favre can't be the QB on their playoff team. If the Vikings keep him to 30 passes or less a game (which shouldn't be hard with AP), and don't leave him in for wins (i.e. go all high school style and actually sub people out). I think he'll be a perfect fit for the team.
Will he become Brett Favre of 1996? Nope.
Will he lead any stat categories (besides possibly interceptions)? Nope.
Will he get banged around and used up like he did with the Jets? Nope.
Teams are going to aggressively pass rush Brett Favre because they want to bang him up, they want to take him out and have the Vikings dive-bomb like the Jets did in the second half of the season. But, that's a very thin line to take when you have Adrian Peterson in the backfield. A tiny bit of overpursuit and that draw play or quick pitch goes for 70 yards and a TD. I think if utilized correctly (I.E. not made to throw 50 times a game, and used to set-up draws with AP used to set-up play action) I think the Vikings will win the NFC North. Will it be 100% because of Favre, no, not at all, but I certainly wouldn't give the same odds to a Vikings team led by Jackson or Rosenfels (incidentally I live in Houston and have watched Rosenfels play, he's got great mechanics, but makes some seriously bad decisions when the game is on the line, and I don't just mean the Indy game from last season).
Most of the Favre drama comes from the media anyway. If an OT or G or C did the same thing as Favre (and they have before) does anyone hear about it? Nope. Favre is a crazy person who loves the game of football, he's going to attract the media no matter what he does. He's competitive to a fault (staying much past his prime), but we only care because everyone puts him in front of the camera, or maybe he puts himself in front of the camera.
Either way, the Minnesota Vikings are a business and more revenue comes from well-known players, wins, playoff games, and ultimately the Super Bowl. While everyone is tired of Favre's song and dance, it's probably the best investment the Vikings could have made this close to the season. He's back into an offense he doesn't have to learn, and he has arguably the best running back in the league behind him.
Does that mean the Vikings will win it all? Nope.
Does it mean that the Vikings, playoffs or not, will make more money than they did last season? Yes. And that is the real answer.
-MC
Heh. Got a little carried away.