User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Fix blocking mechanics
Page:
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
My Bugs topic was locked and I was told to post this in suggestions.

I've been saying this for awhile...here's a prime example. Look at the SS.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=695946&pbp_id=2068640

It seems to me just watching a lot of dotball that whenever a defender is in a player's blocking radius, they can engage the block NO MATTER WHAT. Meaning body position, direction, speed, momentum, etc doesn't even matter (do dots have bodies? ).

I've seen it plenty of times where a player "engages" a defender from behind, and the defender just stops and the player sort of slides in for the block, like in my example. This seems way overpowered. First of all there's a thing called no blocks in the back...but the problem is players CAN engage a block from the back, and do this "slide" in thing so suddenly they're in front of the defender. It's like the player taps the defender from behind and goes "hey I'm gonna block you". Then the defender stops and lets the offensive player slide in on the other side of him and engage the block.

I'm not sure if dots even have a front or back side, but a simple fix would be to require blockers be in FRONT of a defender....you know...actually in position to block by using their agility/vision/blocking/whatever else goes into the equation to actually fight for position while engaging a block instead of it automatically engaging, then sliding in to the otherside. Basically dots should have to slide in there themselves before they make the block...not the other way around.
 
razor9
offline
Link
 
This does happen quite a bit. It might just be the sim, but it certainly looks odd when it happens.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Bump
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Here's another example:

WR on the FS:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=697396&pbp_id=1872152

Pretty funny how he freakin bulldogged that FS after the block was engaged lol. My beef is how it was engaged though. FS and WR are moving in the same direction, then WR stops FS from behind, sliding into blocking position.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
I'd like to see this get fixed as well... along with the related issue of players routinely moving through each other. (May allow these blocks from "behind"... along with ball carriers or blitzers to run between a blocker and the guy he's blocking... for example.)

Yeah "the sim graphics are not an accurate representation of what is actually happening..." but honestly that is a lousy excuse to not fix these things.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
On that example the SS was the nearest unblocked player to the ball carrier. Hmmm,. if I'm playing football thats who I'm blocking, don't know about anyone else. SS turns to head in the direction of the ballcarrier and Pow Alice, right in the kisser.

As for the FS, it's pretty obvious that the WR is much faster than the FS, so it wouldn't be any problem to get between him and the ballcarrier.

In both instances the guys went to block the nearest unblocked player to the ballcarrier, seems perfectly logical.

Hehe, that FS was getting drive blocked to Timbuktu.
Edited by greengoose on Aug 14, 2009 05:54:44
 
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
On that example the SS was the nearest unblocked player to the ball carrier. Hmmm,. if I'm playing football thats who I'm blocking, don't know about anyone else. SS turns to head in the direction of the ballcarrier and Pow Alice, right in the kisser.

As for the FS, it's pretty obvious that the WR is much faster than the FS, so it wouldn't be any problem to get between him and the ballcarrier.

In both instances the guys went to block the nearest unblocked player to the ballcarrier, seems perfectly logical.

Hehe, that FS was getting drive blocked to Timbuktu.


I don't think he is arguing that they shouldn't of went to block them but rather how the initial block is engaged. It's one of these "blocking from the back" threads but he does have a valid point on another as well. It doesn't matter the angle, once they get within a certain radius, the block engages almost perfectly when it should have a variable depending on the angle taken.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
On that example the SS was the nearest unblocked player to the ball carrier. Hmmm,. if I'm playing football thats who I'm blocking, don't know about anyone else. SS turns to head in the direction of the ballcarrier and Pow Alice, right in the kisser.

As for the FS, it's pretty obvious that the WR is much faster than the FS, so it wouldn't be any problem to get between him and the ballcarrier.

In both instances the guys went to block the nearest unblocked player to the ballcarrier, seems perfectly logical.

Hehe, that FS was getting drive blocked to Timbuktu.


I wouldn't have a problem if the WRs physically slid in there, then engaged the block. But they get the defender in their radius, then the defender automatically stops, and the WR slides into place instantly and the block is engaged. So the defender can't move while the blocker is trying to get position? It makes no sense.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
+1

It's time for holding being a penalty.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Holding wouldn't be fair because it's not the offensive player's faults this happens. It's just how the mechanics work. First things first the mechanics should be fixed, then we can maybe have it still happen rarely, and add a holding penalty.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Bump
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Wouldn't this be nice
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
I agree and I would also like to say I would definitely be in favor of their being more penalties. I think that is 1 of several reasons that you see so much scoring even amongst evenly matched teams (not the biggest reason, but still a factor). A simple holding call can really kill drives.
 
CdogM16
offline
Link
 
How about we just take out the blocking modifier that WR's have. A WR with the maybe 25 strenght and the 10 on blocking (that he rolled to start) shouldn't even be a speed bump for any SS or LB built to stop the power backs in the league.

But If that was done... every WR would cry because now it would be more important to have strenght and blocking to a respectable 35.. instead of 100+ speed.
 
Troymk1
offline
Link
 
I agree big time.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.