User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
clownassassin
offline
Link
 
There have been a lot of posts in many of the threads in this forum expressing the opinion of players from the East that the East is better than the West and vice versa. I always felt like this was like me telling people that "I'm way taller than my cousin", when I'm 6'2" and he's 6'1 7/8". Yes, I am taller, but the truth is that even though I am slightly taller, describing myself as "way taller" would only be evidence of me being delusional or of not having a firm grasp of the English language.

I love numbers and I can sit all evening looking at numbers and be happy. So now I'm drinking beer and analyzing the level #'s of all the starters on all the teams that made the playoffs this year. I did this by looking at the rosters of teams and not their home page since a lot of teams are starting back ups during the scrimmage games. I didn't include non-playoff teams in this analysis, because I didn't feel like doubling my work to produce what is to follow. I also did not include the kickers and punters in this analysis.


Here are the teams ranked in order by totals of levels of all starters/ starters on offense/ starters on defense

Mukesh 394/197/196
Toronto 378/186/192
Bedford 374/190/184
Rebel 366/186/180
Kingston 359/181/178
Nova 356/181/175
Manitoba 355/180/175
Hamilton 353/172/181
Prison 352/173/179
Texas 338/170/168
Kamloop 337/176/161
Alberta 333/166/167
Cincinnati 333/168/165
Winnipeg 332/177/155
Centennial 325/161/164
New Braunf 301/153/148


The total difference between all the starters on all the teams between East and West is 130 points spread across 176 starters. That is an average of 0.738 levels per starter which rates out to 3.693 SPs. The average level 16 starter has well over 300 points distributed between Attributes and Special Abilities. This means that the East's playoff teams have on average about 1% more points assigned to their starters than the West.




Last edited Jun 1, 2008 23:17:55
 
EricW34
offline
Link
 

You and numbers man.
back to beer.


Eric
 
Avondell
offline
Link
 
Someone has an inferiority complex
 
Big_Sexxy_II
offline
Link
 
I'm actually surprised at these results. Generally, I consider the Zebras depth their greatest strength. I didn't realize we were actually that much stronger from a starters standpoint.
 
Lappdancer
offline
Link
 
Really? you have 5 level 19 starter and we have zero. Overall though I think that advantage is small and easily overshadowed by tactics and other factors.
 
Link
 
Why no love to kickers and punters. Our kicker has been lights out all playoffs. If it wasn't for him (and special teams in general) we would not have made it to the championship game.

Still, good analysis. Glad to see the Actuarials getting a little bit of respect.
 
jimbo011791
offline
Link
 
Memphis 337/173/164
Tied for 11th
 
nottom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by clownassassin
That is an average of 0.738 levels per starter which rates out to 3.693 SPs.



[nitpick]
0.738 levels is actually more like 5.904 SPs since you also get 3 points autoassigned on level up based on position
[/nitpick]
Last edited Jun 2, 2008 09:13:54
 
rbowden
offline
Link
 
That is a bit surprising.. Kamloop is only 11th despite our appearance in the conference championship. Either we'd been overachieving a bit, or the tactics and gameplay settings gave us an edge.
Last edited Jun 2, 2008 11:16:31
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
This is missing a few things that are probably hard to quantify.

1. Custom gear is worth another couple levels.
2. The difference between crappy and good builds can be worth a couple levels.
3. The level of back-ups can be important. Mukesh has had the strongest starters since I've been looking at them, but they make the craziest coaching decisions. Dude...those CPUs and inactives you play as backups don't make you stronger.

I'll go ahead and make a prediction for next season. I think Toronto wins it, hands down, unless they decide to join us in AAA.
 
a5chen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbowden
That is a bit surprising.. Kamloop is only 11th despite our appearance in the conference championship. Either we'd been overachieving a bit, or the tactics and gameplay settings gave us an edge.


But 7 of the 10 teams above you are from the East.

You'd be the 4 rated team in the west by CAs starter level analysis.

Probably needs some sort of adjustment for main backup levels by average number of plays per game.
 
Meryk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshiro
This is missing a few things that are probably hard to quantify.

1. Custom gear is worth another couple levels.
2. The difference between crappy and good builds can be worth a couple levels.
3. The level of back-ups can be important. Mukesh has had the strongest starters since I've been looking at them, but they make the craziest coaching decisions. Dude...those CPUs and inactives you play as backups don't make you stronger.

I'll go ahead and make a prediction for next season. I think Toronto wins it, hands down, unless they decide to join us in AAA.


We have a strong group of starters, but we have struggled to pull in backups. Those that we do have seem to have found a home with Mukesh, and will likely stick around for a few seasons. We only have two CPUs, and one is 3rd on the depth chart. The other is at FB, and for the life of me, I can't find a backup FB.

I hope Toronto does find a way to move up. If you finished in the top 4 of your conference this season, you need to move up to stiffer competition. That's how I feel.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Meryk
Originally posted by Kenshiro

This is missing a few things that are probably hard to quantify.

1. Custom gear is worth another couple levels.
2. The difference between crappy and good builds can be worth a couple levels.
3. The level of back-ups can be important. Mukesh has had the strongest starters since I've been looking at them, but they make the craziest coaching decisions. Dude...those CPUs and inactives you play as backups don't make you stronger.

I'll go ahead and make a prediction for next season. I think Toronto wins it, hands down, unless they decide to join us in AAA.


We have a strong group of starters, but we have struggled to pull in backups. Those that we do have seem to have found a home with Mukesh, and will likely stick around for a few seasons. We only have two CPUs, and one is 3rd on the depth chart. The other is at FB, and for the life of me, I can't find a backup FB.

I hope Toronto does find a way to move up. If you finished in the top 4 of your conference this season, you need to move up to stiffer competition. That's how I feel.

We may be able to sell you one for $250,000. We are a FB making factory.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Meryk
Originally posted by Kenshiro

This is missing a few things that are probably hard to quantify.

1. Custom gear is worth another couple levels.
2. The difference between crappy and good builds can be worth a couple levels.
3. The level of back-ups can be important. Mukesh has had the strongest starters since I've been looking at them, but they make the craziest coaching decisions. Dude...those CPUs and inactives you play as backups don't make you stronger.

I'll go ahead and make a prediction for next season. I think Toronto wins it, hands down, unless they decide to join us in AAA.


We have a strong group of starters, but we have struggled to pull in backups. Those that we do have seem to have found a home with Mukesh, and will likely stick around for a few seasons. We only have two CPUs, and one is 3rd on the depth chart. The other is at FB, and for the life of me, I can't find a backup FB.

I hope Toronto does find a way to move up. If you finished in the top 4 of your conference this season, you need to move up to stiffer competition. That's how I feel.

I forgot to add. . .

If you still need CPU players to fill in positions, every once in a while look for higher levels. I think GLB has CPU players (FB) at level 13. Much better than level 5.

But you would probably be better off cutting them and just having a starter.
 
Kenshiro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by clownassassin
The total difference between all the starters on all the teams between East and West is 130 points spread across 176 starters. That is an average of 0.738 levels per starter which rates out to 3.693 SPs. The average level 16 starter has well over 300 points distributed between Attributes and Special Abilities. This means that the East's playoff teams have on average about 1% more points assigned to their starters than the West.


This may have already been mentioned, but that 1% is wrong, or at least a little misleading.

Each level you boost you get 8 points, each earned level you get roughly 10 points (the extra 2 points are from training) and every 8th level you get an extra 4 points from equipment, so saying 0.738 levels per starter only equates to 3.693 SPs is an understatement.

The 300 points for an average level 16 player seems really high too. I would ignore all the points in worthless stats. My center doesn't really need his 7 points in throwing or kicking. A 0.738 across the board level advantage is probably at least a 5% difference.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.