User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #4 > Warren Slop or Raph Taylor?
Page:
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
Who would you rather have?

This is a pretty seriously tough question.

On one hand, you've got one of the most devastating Pass Rushers to come through GLB. Averages around 3 sacks and 3 hurries a game on his career. At his best scored 141 tackles, 65 sacks, 72 hurries, and 11 FFs in 16 games. If a QB drops back 30 times a game, 20% of the time Slop is going to have some sort of impact on the play. Amazing.

On the other hand, you've got one of the fieriest game changers in GLB period. Taylor arguably put together the most impressive season ever in season 9, getting attention from nearly everyone in GLB. 141 FFs, 306 tackles, and 7 picks? OMGWTF! Averaging over 10 tackles a game, he proved he could do it in the Pros as well, notching 126 tackles and 41 FFs. Dude is sick and will keep OCs up all night. No, there's no way to game plan around it.

So, who do you take? The game changing SS or the unstoppable Pass Rusher?

I personally think the best teams are built around the lines, so I'd ever so slightly be inclined to take Slop, but its hard to ignore the impact so many TOs would bring to a team.

Looking forward to seeing how the season rolls out and if these guys can remain unberfable.
 
Lef Grebo
offline
Link
 
Taylor. Turnovers have more of an impact then sacks/hurries.
 
pksskulls
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lef Grebo
Taylor. Turnovers have more of an impact then sacks/hurries.


 
djoe
offline
Link
 
I love having Slop on the same line as Norse, but I agree with the turnovers. Although I think the offense recovers way too many fumbles in this game.
 
catcher_0_3
offline
Link
 
I'm gonna go with Slop on this one. I've had the unfortunate pleasure of playing both these guys too many times and I believe that Slop has had a bigger impact in those games. It could be the fact that Tally has traditionally had a better team when compared to Carolina, so I worry about them more in general. But I'm also a "win in the trenches, win in the game" proponent so that could be it as well. Either way, these are easily the 2 best Defensive players I have ever faced off against. Anyone want to compile an epic list of players? I don't know what the criterion would be, I guess just guys who ball extraordinare.

Names of mention:

Nikka Barna (averages/season): 130 tackles, 25 hurries, 28 sacks, 25 TFL, 10 pass deflections
Hobbit .0./ Little Hobbit: For those of us who watch game tape, we know how big of a pain in the ass this guy is.
 
Moo45
offline
Link
 
I love Nikka but we didn't gameplan around him in the finals last year. No doubt he's great and I'd love to have him on my team. Moreso than Slopp. Especially because of the TFLs. Drive stoppers. Slopp pass rushes really well and thats about it. He was kept to minimal sacks vs good teams. He gets about 2 other tackles per game other than the QB and for what its worth, I don't think the QB is effected by sacks and hurries as much as they should be. His 9 FFs are nice for sure...but compared to Taylor....its not even close. Taylor is like Nikka with the FFs. If you look around any league....the team with the best +/- in turnovers is usually at the top. Furious had +87 turnover ratio last year. Thats how we're designed and that's why I think we won last season.

I do agree with you that the D Line is the place to start when building a Defense though =p

Don't know Hobbit...
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
Yeah. I'll put our DL up against any in GLB, it was my pride and joy. I cherry picked every single guy there and it was honestly one of the main reasons selling points I propositioned HATE with on the merger. I was like, dude, we could have the sickest DL in GLB hahahaha and the rest is history.

Couldn't agree more Moo, DLs and good depth win games.
 
Moo45
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=348079&playoffs=0
This guy was money last year. Same sort of guy like Slopp. Apparently a 'mundane' and 'obvious' build but I don't know the truth to that.
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
haven't seen too many DTs with numbers like that.

sick.
 
Moo45
offline
Link
 
That was in USA AAA last year so maybe you guys can find out next year how comparable Slopp can/will be
 
Link
 
whoever has a higher punting skill
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ANDY_VIGLIOTTI_ISAJOKE
whoever has a higher punting skill


dude.

you found slops secret, he's got 69 punting.
 
HATEMOBSTER
offline
Link
 
I want to see Need Ur Love's build more than anyone. http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=267528&playoffs=0 I don't know what it's like to have a Raphael Taylor on the team so it'd be nice to have that for a season or two, but then again Slop is the drive killer getting sacks on 1st through 3rd down all game long. As far as I'm concerned Slop is top 5 DE's in GLB and Taylor is a top 5 safety in glb.
 
Moo45
offline
Link
 
damn...he's got some silly stats too. There is one thing in common I've noticed with these killer DTs.....and its not a standard attribute.
 
catcher_0_3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Moo45
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=348079&playoffs=0
This guy was money last year. Same sort of guy like Slopp. Apparently a 'mundane' and 'obvious' build but I don't know the truth to that.


A guy bought his build off ebay and posted it. It wasn't really mundane because it is pretty sick, but it was kind of obvious that he had some really high stats. Basically really high strength, speed, and agility. High vision, 2nd capped I think, and low tackling, only soft capped.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.