User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Uncapped Minor Leagues > Uncapped Minor League #20 > Anyone else think something is wrong with the MVP system?
Sec
offline
Link
 
Of course, I'm plugging the guy on my team (where incidentally I run the special teams as well), but a guy on a 8-8 team that didn't make the playoffs is going to get the MVP.

I know about how stats in blow-outs affect the race, so don't bother posting that here. But, even if you look at Tibor's game log, all of his TD's came in blowouts (only two of the games didn't have a score difference of 100 points).

Most of Crazylegs TDs came in blowouts as well. However, he had special teams TDs in 4 games that the score difference was less than 100 points, including one against the current 5th ranked team in the conference.

So, this bring me to what I see as the biggest flaw in the system. Check this game out:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=599983

Not a single punt by the current number 4 ranked team. Now, am I upset at Crete? Nope, every once-in-a-while you throw something out there to see what will happen. What I am upset with is that game of ZERO punt returns against a good team cost Crazlegs the MVP. So, the ultimate compliment for a return man (i.e. don't punt to him), ends up being a detriment in GLB. If anything, this should have made his status in the MVP race go up. However, it dropped him down to 5th and he's spent the rest of the season trying to catch up.

Anyway, it sucks for Crazylegs' agent to lose what would have been a second straight special teams MVP because of a flawed system. I know it will never be perfect, but overall team record and if competitive teams choose 'not' to punt to your guy should have an effect on the race. There has never been an MVP from a .500 or lower team. Period. Also, the less people kick to you (Devin Hester from a couple years back) the 'better' everyone thinks you are.

/rant.
Edited by MadcatWillie on Jul 22, 2009 09:05:53
 
jdpbernal
offline
Link
 
The MVP system is really flawed!!!!
 
Dan2008
offline
Link
 
I agree that the MVP system is flawed. The offensive MVP always goes to a QB or HB. No matter how good an O-Line player is, there is no way they will get an MVP award. However, since we know it is flawed, the best thing to do is ignore it. The best thing for GLB to do is to scrap it. No matter what system is put in place, it will always have more peolple hating it than liking it.

The suggestion that the MVP must come from a team that has a winning record is extremely arbitrary. What if someone is by far the best player in the league and carries his team to a play-off spot with an 8-8 record? How can that player not even be considered for MVP status?

I agree that normally the less people kick to you, the better they think you are. However, sometimes this happens because they screw up their AI. Should someone get an MVP bonus because the other team screwed up their AI?

I am not picking on your post. I am just trying to point out that no matter what system is put in place, there will always flaws. Either accept it or ignore it. I choose to ignore it.
 
Sec
offline
Link
 
It's harder to ignore when a season long endorsement is on the line. But I agree with the inability to create a perfect system. And, I wasn't suggesting that the MVP has to come from a team with a winning record, I was pointing out that they didn't make the playoffs. And, in that respect, when has there ever been an NFL MVP on a team with a .500 record? I'm sure there's some obscure trivia reference there, but no one can think of anybody off the top of their heads. Rookie of the year? Yeah, that can happen on any team. MVP, not likely.

If a guy carries a team to the playoffs (even with an 8-8 record) I agree that he should be considered. But the player mentioned in my first post is not on a playoff team.
Edited by MadcatWillie on Jul 22, 2009 21:40:55
 
soulellis
offline
Link
 
There must be something wrong with it , when my DE Dutch " lights out " Jackson does not get the Defence MVP for Eastern with 116 sacks and 16 FF


 
gebster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by soulellis
There must be something wrong with it , when my DE Dutch " lights out " Jackson does not get the Defence MVP for Eastern with 116 sacks and 16 FF




nope a guy got it that came in and only played 6 games in the league and got 227 tackles and 71 FFs
 
Tendoncutter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MadcatWillie
And, in that respect, when has there ever been an NFL MVP on a team with a .500 record?


You really shouldn't by any means compare the NFL to a game where you often win with 100+ points.
 
Sec
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tendoncutter
Originally posted by MadcatWillie

And, in that respect, when has there ever been an NFL MVP on a team with a .500 record?


You really shouldn't by any means compare the NFL to a game where you often win with 100+ points.


So, what you're saying is that Bort isn't trying to make this like the NFL? That would just be silly.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.