User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Player Personality Suggestion
Page:
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I know this is long, but hopefully someone has the patience to read it.


I'd like to say that this is an amazing game. The only major problems I have with the game is that, from a player's standpoint, there's a lack of things to do to prepare for a game and there's a lack of inter-team interaction.

I've come up with a concept for Player Personalities to try to alleviate these two concerns.


Note: If I say "week" in here, I'm talking about the 2 time in between 2 games, not an actual week in real-time.

---------------------------------

As most of you who have played organized sports know, how well the players on each team mesh with each other shows itself on the football field. This concept is designed to emulate that.

Basically, each player will be able to choose one of two personality types.

The first is "Locker-Room Cancer." A player with this personality type would use rants and verbal abuse to coerce his teammates into performing better. To balance this out, each of the Actions this player can undertake have negative side-effects, such as decreased morale or confidence for the next game.

The second personality type is "Team Leader." As you'd expect, a player with this personality type is the direct opposite of the Locker-Room Cancer. These players would focus on mentorship and pep-talks to inspire their teammates. Their bonuses would be used to combat the negative effects of the Locker-Room Cancer's actions, but can also be used to give stat bonuses to the same position.



The idea here is to get teammates working together to boost the quality of their teammates. Having a team full of Locker-Room Cancers would be great for boosting the stats of your players, but you'd have a team filled with players with low confidence or morale as a result. The result would probably be similar to the T.O. fiasco in Philly.

If you recall the 2002 Buccaneers when they made their Super Bowl run, they had loud-mouthed trash-talkers like Warren Sapp and Keyshawn Johnson and team players like Derrick Brooks, Ronde Barber and John Lynch to balance things out. The result was a group of players who played well under the fire of Sapp and Johnson, but the attitudes of those two were held in check by the Team Leaders.

---------------------------------

Now that we've covered the two basic types of personalities, I'll explain what "Personality Actions" are. These would be actions players can use to boost the skills of themselves or their teammates. The idea is to have around 10-15 Personality Actions for each of the two types with players having 3 Personality Points. The Points can either be obtained by default or have a level requirement attached to them.

Personality Actions would reset each time a game is played, at which time players can choose new actions for the new "week". This would prevent stat-stacking from week-to-week and would also allow the attachment of stipulations to certain actions.

As you can imagine, 20+ human players on a team all boosting each other could get out of control pretty quickly. To combat this, Personality Actions would have certain stipulations attached to their use. Some would be relatively simple, requiring only that you're a Starter or a Backup. These would be weaker, applying bonuses only to players of your position. Other, more powerful Personality Actions would be tied to Seasonal or Game performance. For a HB, a Personality Action might require that they have 3 TDs or 150 yards rushing in the previous game. Since these actions would be harder to get, their benefits would be more powerful. Finally, the most powerful personality actions would require that a player be an Offensive/Defensive/ST Captain (this would need to be added to the game, as well). These Actions would be the most powerful, since only 3 players on each team can use them.

---------------------------------

Now that I've got the basics layed out, I'd like to provide some more specific examples of Personality Actions to give a taste of what I'm getting at here. Keep in mind that these are just concepts to give an idea of how the personalities are supposed to work together. The values of bonuses can be tweaked for better balancing.


-- Team Captain Actions -- (Can only be used by those who are marked as Team Captains by the owner.)

- Inspiring Presence (Team Leader)
You give an inspiring speech in the huddle following an opposing score. All players on your unit (Offense, Defense, ST) gain +1 to all stats. This effect cannot stack. When your team scores, this effect ends.

- Raucous Celebration (Locker-Room Cancer)
You run onto the field and break into a uncontrollable dancing fit following a score by your team. All players on your unit gain +1 to all stats. This effect cannot stack. When the opposing team scores, you ensuing sideline meltdown ends this effect.


-- Starter Actions -- (Can only be used by those who are marked as starters at their position.)

- Game Film Session (Team Leader)
You call all players from your position into the film room to analyze tape on the opposing team. All participants gain +2 Vision and Confidence for the next game.

- Boasting (Locker-Room Cancer)
You boast about your starting job. Your Vision and Confidence are increased by 2. All other players at your position lose 10 morale.


-- Backup Actions -- (Can only be used by those marked as backups at their position.)

- Benchwarmer (Team Leader)
You keep the bench warm for the starter, decreasing the rate-of-decay of their stamina during a game by 10%.

- Media Interview Meltdown (Locker-Room Cancer)
You have a destructive meltdown during a media interview due to low playing time. The team fines you double your daily salary, but your Vision and Confidence are increased by 2 for the next game.


-- Other Actions -- (Use determined by previous game performance/oucome, or by seasonal performance.)

- Night of Fun (Team-Leader... Requires a Victory in previous game)
You take 2 players out for a night of fun. The relaxing activities restore 10 morale and boost their Confidence by 2.

- Verbal Abuse (Locker-Room Cancer... Requires you be on the field for 40+ plays in the previous game)
You heap verbal abuse on a player for their lack of contribution. The target player loses 10 morale and 2 Confidence for the next game, but the results of their training are increased 25%.

---------------------------------

What do you guys think of this concept? Allowing a large team to boost everyone's stats can get out of control, which is why Personality actions need to have stipulations attached to their use and why the number of Actions each player can use will need to be limited based on the total number of actions available.

This concept would give players something to do besides training each day and would encourage players to interact with each other in order to obtain maximum effectiveness. The Team Leaders would need to be sure that they're balancing out the negative effects of a Locker-Room Cancer's actions (such as the Verbal Abuse concept above) so that the team isn't starting a ton of players with low Confidence and Morale.

Another concept would be to allow the personality types to affect the opposing team, such as a Locker-Room Cancer making public victory gaurantees to demoralize the opposing team. This would allow you to combat the boosts of the opposing teams and would keep rampant stat hoarding in check.

If the limitations on the Personality Actions aren't enough to keep stat bonuses within a reasonable amount, another idea would be to allow each character to only be affected by a maximum of 2-3 actions between each game.

Finally, it's important to note that players can change and with all the roster moves, teams might get to the point where they have too many of one personality type. To combat this, giving players the ability to change types is needed. While players are changing types, which could take 2 games, they can neither use nor be affected by Personality Actions.


What do you all think?
Last edited Mar 22, 2008 10:53:01
 
Meryk
offline
Link
 
Whoa! That is long. I got through the first quarter of it, though, and an off-shoot of this idea came to me.

What about having veteran influences? For instance, take a QB like Brett Favre. Chances are he had a huge impact on younger QBs. This would be position only influences, and could go hand-in-hand with the suggestion above. Cancer vs Cancer could cause negative impact, while Leader vs Cancer could cause a positive impact.

I'll try to read the rest of that novel later. I have a migraine right now.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Yeah. I didn't realize how long it was until I posted it. I didn't intend for it to be so long, but once I started the ideas started flowing. That's the result.

I like your spinoff idea. The idea of having to balance personalities at position as well as on the overall team adds more depth, but if this were to be added, there would absolutely have to be a way to change your personality. It'd make it very hard to find new players if you're looking for a run-stopping NT with a leader personality or a pocket-passing QB with a cancer personality.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Wow, this is well thought out. I like the general concept. Obviously the abilities would have to be fleshed out, etc.

We're definitely trying to think of things for players to do on off days, and ways to get them more involved in the team other than just playing the games.

I think a better name than "Locker Room Cancer" might be "Rabble Rouser" or something like that. Seems like nobody would want to sign somebody who's labeled a "cancer" no matter what they did for the team.
 
kostitsyn
offline
Link
 
Good ideas overall. Need to be tweaked alot, need to add some and stuff, but yea it's a good start and would make the game a whole lot more interesting in day off since we play once every 2 days. The other day is a bit boring overall so yeah having more stuff to do and look at is good for sure.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Wow, I REALLY like this idea. One of the biggest problems I've had with some of the ideas people had for players to do on off-days is it ends up screwing team owners who have players since they don't have time to do these things on the off-days.

With an idea like this, players have things do do/adjust, while owners aren't really hurt by not doing these things for their players.

Legacy +5
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
I'm glad you guys like the idea. Bort, that's a good point on the "Cancer" name. I just used it because it was the first label to pop into my head.

kostitsyn, as I said, it's just a concept, so I know it's going to need tweaking, etc. That's exactly why I didn't spend time coming up with 20-30 different potential actions. I just came up with enough for you guys to get the gist of what this could be.
 
Verloren
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I like this idea as well, but I'm not such a big fan of the major boosts to everything. A smaller boost would do just fine and allow teams to pull these guys together, but a strong negative impact would balance this out. My next point will relate to this.

Meryk touched upon an important thing there. Not all players will be team leaders and not all will be rabble rousers. You have to give something to the guys who hold the team together, but don't really inspire players to do better. Think of it as the core of a team. They do what is asked of them, and usually show others how it is done by example by giving it 110% all the time. These players aren't the ones that get all the big hype, but they usually are respected in the locker room for giving it their all, and are the dependable guys in a team.

You can't have everybody on the team be a team leader. That just leads to arguments amongst players in a locker room (and I've been on a team where everybody tried to take control). There should be some really negative things when everybody tries to be one, or a rabble rouser. You've mentioned this as well, when talking about the Bucs and how some players would hold the team in line and lessen the impact. Something really bad should happen when the entire team is full of rabble rousers as well.

And another point. Sometimes when a smack talker on team A guarantees a victory, chances are a team leader of team B will be able to turn those words back around on him, and do something along the lines of "Let's prove team A wrong!" and give team B more confidence.

Just a few ideas to balance out what you've suggested, but it is one of the best ideas I've seen posted here.
Last edited Mar 22, 2008 12:49:36
 
bburger991
offline
Link
 
Instead of the Cancer just getting the same boost as the other guys, like the starter one and captain, shouldn't it be something like, he gets +4 to each of the mentioned at the expense of harming everyone elses morale?

Because guys like TO, Sapp, Chad Johnson, ..etc are/were some of the best players in the league, and cared only about themselves, not what it would do to the team.
 
kostitsyn
offline
Link
 
There could also be things for the Sam Bolsters like if he says he's gonna catch 10 passes it could boost his confidence a little bit to start the game, maybe like +2. If at half time he doesnt get half of his catch so 5, it really hurts his confidence and morale, by a fair margin for the 2nd half. If it reaches 5, then maybe his catching gets up by 3-4 and his confidence by another 3 so it gets up by 5. If in the 4th quarter he's still on pace to get 10 so lets say 8, he keeps the boost, but if coming in the or during 4th quarter he reaches 10. Well then he turns out as a game breaker guy. (Prolly could add some game situation as well like if they lose by a TD, if it's close or something) Maybe this could help his skills much and prolly boost the special abilities.(Could also boost stamina for the remaining of the game)

It'll need to be tweaked so the boost isnt too high and how much boost you get thruout the game could depends on how hard the thing he's gotta do are.

Just throwing ideas.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
That's a cool idea, too, kostitsyn, but you'd have to make it so that players can't just boast that they're going to make some easy-to-reach goal. You shouldn't be able to boast that you're going to get 2 catches as a starting WR, or that you're going to throw for 40 yards as a pocket passer.

Verloren, I get what you're saying about having a third personality type for the standard guys on the team, but I couldn't really figure out how to implement that. Plus, the concept was long enough with just 2 personality types; three would have made it unbearable to read. Maybe you can make it so the third type, which would be a middle-of-the-road type guy, can make themselves resistant to the stat debuffs of the Cancer players with the side-effect being that the bonuses provided by the Team Leaders aren't as effective.
 
undaunted
offline
Link
 
i love the ideas and the suggestions are great, but to be honest lets keep it simple. the stuff originaly posted was good. maybe it should just be 3 personality types, with a few different actions that can be preselected before a game so that the players can mix and match the different effects and such for what theyll need to do in the next game.

say the next team has a real good rushing game, the defensive players could do actions pre-game that would give the o-line and the linebackers a boost to stop rush's and stuff. something simple, but effective.
 
Sam Bolster
offline
Link
 
I know this suggestion is mainly about somethings you can do in between games but reading that I got to thinking about personality types

What If you had more then just two personality types?

Team Leader-
PRO: Would give an inspirational speech to his group and get them fired up for the next play. He would be the guy that makes sure that everyone is on the right page and everyone is doing there job.

CON: If you misses a tackle for a touchdown gets burned for a touchdown throws in interception or fumbles the ball or anything like that

Example: Your QB RB or your MLB

Team Trashtalker-
PRO: Any big play he does like lights someone up from the line intercepts the ball forces a fumble swats a ball to the ground or throws a deep pass and scores or on a 40 yard rush or catches a ball and totally takes someone to school like Sam Bolster.

CON: Player gets shut down

Example: Sam Bolster or anyone defensive player

Team Role Player-
PRO: Ok so If an offensive Lineman totally pancakes someone to the ground twice in a row.

CON: QB gets hit with a sack or RB get hit in the backfield

Example: An offensive Lineman

Team Energizer-(aka X-Factor)
PRO: When a player that is not a huge player but comes up big for you one a play the team gets excited.

CON: Player gets shut out of the game.

Example: FB and TE


Not sure about anything else but thats about what they would do.

Now I think that the Coach should be able to label the players or the players itself label themselves.
Now the examples are just examples anyone can be a trash talker like Phillip Rivers in the playoffs . Anyone can be a team energizer or X Factor.



HERE is what it would affect for your player and team.



Team Leader-

PRO: Would help the team out in confidence and moral and vision possibly

CON: Moral goes down and Confidence.



Team Trashtalker-

PRO: Helps out Confidence and adds some skills to there players ability accordingly to help them out.

CON: when trashtalkers get put down usually there Moral and Confidence goes down


Team Role Player-

PRO: The player everyone likes and gives them a better moral and confidence possibly.

CON: Vision and confidence go down.



Team Energizer:

PRO: Gets a couple points in Stamina and Confidence

CON: Stamina takes a hit along with Moral



Now just give me some thoughts. I know this is not all thought out as of yet but just give me some help out on it. It can be adjusted and all that I only took about 10 minutes on this so no biggy in if you don't like it. I just decided to think of some more personalities since I think there are more then just 2 personality types in football. There can also be more types I just thought of some basic ones.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Bolster, that's a good concept, but it still comes down to just choosing the option that best fits your player. It's not as involved as my original concept was designed to be.

My original concept was designed to give the whole team something to interact with and give players things to do other than just wait for the next game to roll around. You'd spend off days choosing actions to boost the quality of yourself or your teammates.
 
Sam Bolster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Legacy
Bolster, that's a good concept, but it still comes down to just choosing the option that best fits your player. It's not as involved as my original concept was designed to be.

My original concept was designed to give the whole team something to interact with and give players things to do other than just wait for the next game to roll around. You'd spend off days choosing actions to boost the quality of yourself or your teammates.


Yeah maybe somehow It would be a reputation that someone has. I know your original post was about interacting in between games and all that It's just took a thing about personality and just added to it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.