We have some of those in my league too - kind of annoying. the 3 LBs and LE are 40 + on one team - everyone else is around level 23, no CPUs. Of course I was a bitch and pm'd the administration.
The initial sort was based on average level. If you have a 43 on the team, the rest of the team must be significantly lower level. Given the state of the roster on the team with the 43 HB I'm not sure I'd worry about it.