User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
I PMed the management of the Snowmen about having an agreement to not use the wildcat (QB rush) in the finals, and their OC Jacob McCandles suggested I make a public post to make it official.

I don't blame Chile for using it in our game, I'm just a bit frustrated they waited till us to use it. But I'm a firm believer that this is a game, not real football, and teams should use whatever strategies they need to, unless they wish to make agreements before hand to make the game more enjoyable. If anyone is to blame, it's GLB's magnanimous overlord, or me for not clarifying with them before hand whether that play was out of bounds or not. So GG Chile.

Anyways, it should be a good game tomorrow. Good luck to all the AAA#2 teams that are being promoted... we are gonna need it.
 
jmorgalis
offline
Link
 
i would like to clarify something. You are upset that someone waited until a big game to pull out a look they had not shown before, so as to be harder to scout? I started running some plays I had not shown before in the playoffs, especially on defense. I did not think that was out of bounds. I thought it was decent planning.

It is possible I am missing something on this, but I am not sure why an 'agreement' is necessary or why Chile did anything other than try to change things up to combat a very good and very aggressive defense. New England had to accept the loss when Miami put Ronnie Brown in the Wildcat for the first time, even though they did not know it was coming. You guys didn't even have to accept a loss. You managed to overcome it.

Not trying to flame, rather trying to understand. This is not Season 8. I hope we are not reaching the stage where AIs need to be shared prior to going into games, just to prevent frustration and being caught short on a tactic.

I apologize if I am overreacting, but I just want to make sure I get it. Innovation is a good thing.
 
PBer
offline
Link
 
^ That. Looked like Chile found a weakness in your defense and did a pretty solid job of taking advantage of it. If anything, they should have run that play even more, IMO.
 
Link
 
The wildCAT is for pussy coordinators. It is the thing I hate most about this game. Any body can clearly see who is lining up at QB, but in this game every one is just dumb and blind. Dam, I just agreed with Valhalla on something, must go see a priest
 
PBer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jacob McCandles
The wildCAT is for pussy coordinators. It is the thing I hate most about this game. Any body can clearly see who is lining up at QB, but in this game every one is just dumb and blind. Dam, I just agreed with Valhalla on something, must go see a priest



Man . . . that's just not right, dude. Even if you have a good point, you really can't go agreeing with Valhalla on anything.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jacob McCandles
The wildCAT is for pussy coordinators. It is the thing I hate most about this game. Any body can clearly see who is lining up at QB, but in this game every one is just dumb and blind. Dam, I just agreed with Valhalla on something, must go see a priest


You can agree with us, you just can't agree with Dan! There is a big difference, remember that
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jmorgalis
i would like to clarify something. You are upset that someone waited until a big game to pull out a look they had not shown before, so as to be harder to scout? I started running some plays I had not shown before in the playoffs, especially on defense. I did not think that was out of bounds. I thought it was decent planning.

It is possible I am missing something on this, but I am not sure why an 'agreement' is necessary or why Chile did anything other than try to change things up to combat a very good and very aggressive defense. New England had to accept the loss when Miami put Ronnie Brown in the Wildcat for the first time, even though they did not know it was coming. You guys didn't even have to accept a loss. You managed to overcome it.

Not trying to flame, rather trying to understand. This is not Season 8. I hope we are not reaching the stage where AIs need to be shared prior to going into games, just to prevent frustration and being caught short on a tactic.

I apologize if I am overreacting, but I just want to make sure I get it. Innovation is a good thing.


I said I was frustrated with it, not that I think there is something evil about it or that they are exploiting or I think they are bad people. Using that play when you haven't been all season is much different than throwing in new screen passes or outside runs or something of the like.

My problem with the play is that it is broken and extremely unrealistic. Watching my whole team stand in place twiddling their thumbs while their QB HB and FB marched to the side of the field makes me like GLB less. I think the game is better off this season with those plays not in the playbook. That is what this thread is about.

Edit: also I'm 95% sure the play would have worked just as well against their first two opponents.
Edited by w_alloy on Jun 2, 2009 18:12:17
 
PBer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Originally posted by Jacob McCandles

The wildCAT is for pussy coordinators. It is the thing I hate most about this game. Any body can clearly see who is lining up at QB, but in this game every one is just dumb and blind. Dam, I just agreed with Valhalla on something, must go see a priest


You can agree with us, you just can't agree with Dan! There is a big difference, remember that



O.k....I'll grant you that.
 
batsignal2
offline
Link
 
Not saying this to bring up old wounds but....this situation seems somewhat familiar to last seasons I Slam playoff game verses ARR:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=470489&mode=pbp

In this game, Valhalla used I Slam a ton that game to beat ARR in the playoffs. People complained about that usage and you defended it by saying:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2390787

Originally posted by w_alloy


We used our reputation as a passing team to set up the run. We did this in a manner that is extremely unrealistic to normal football but completely fine and increasingly standard in GLB.



I am not sure as a primary passing team in Season 8 using very heavy I Slam in the playoffs to take advantage of a "defensive miscue" by ARR as explained is much different then Chili trying to take advantage of a possible miscue of not covering the QB outside run (which is extremely unrealistic to normal football) having never used it during the year. The Wildcat has become "increasingly standard" in GLB.

Using Wildcat being "bad" vs Using I Slam being "fine" heavy is a tough argument to make. Yes, I am sure you used that play throughout the season but not in the way you did for that game. The results were the same where Sausages and Valhalla had an agreement not to use I Slam much like we now have the "No Wildcat" agreement here.

I don't have an issue with Valhalla nor do I have an issue trying to use the Wildcat play. I think using a right vs wrong based on GLB ethics is tough argument to make because they are normally based on most recent trends and not all of GLB history. Until this game becomes more lifelike where if a HB lines up at QB the defense can shift into a run contain offense not stay in a pass orientated defense, we are going to have these arguments and who can say what is really "right" vs "wrong" to do.

Besides, we all know Valhalla uses bonus token boosts to win games anyway....

 
Galileo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by batsignal2
Not saying this to bring up old wounds but....this situation seems somewhat familiar to last seasons I Slam playoff game verses ARR:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=470489&mode=pbp

In this game, Valhalla used I Slam a ton that game to beat ARR in the playoffs. People complained about that usage and you defended it by saying:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2390787

Originally posted by w_alloy



We used our reputation as a passing team to set up the run. We did this in a manner that is extremely unrealistic to normal football but completely fine and increasingly standard in GLB.



I am not sure as a primary passing team in Season 8 using very heavy I Slam in the playoffs to take advantage of a "defensive miscue" by ARR as explained is much different then Chili trying to take advantage of a possible miscue of not covering the QB outside run (which is extremely unrealistic to normal football) having never used it during the year. The Wildcat has become "increasingly standard" in GLB.

Using Wildcat being "bad" vs Using I Slam being "fine" heavy is a tough argument to make. Yes, I am sure you used that play throughout the season but not in the way you did for that game. The results were the same where Sausages and Valhalla had an agreement not to use I Slam much like we now have the "No Wildcat" agreement here.

I don't have an issue with Valhalla nor do I have an issue trying to use the Wildcat play. I think using a right vs wrong based on GLB ethics is tough argument to make because they are normally based on most recent trends and not all of GLB history. Until this game becomes more lifelike where if a HB lines up at QB the defense can shift into a run contain offense not stay in a pass orientated defense, we are going to have these arguments and who can say what is really "right" vs "wrong" to do.

Besides, we all know Valhalla uses bonus token boosts to win games anyway....


Only in the playoffs...


 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
If I was ARR last season I would have been "frustrated". I have not called what Chile did in this game "wrong". I think this situation is very comparable to the one last season. In both cases there is an issue with the sim that makes certain things unrealistic and overpowered, and I think in these situations managers from both teams should try to talk about things beforehand so that nobody is blindsided. Which is why I said I was to blame in the OP. If there is no understanding it is within teams' rights to use the tools at their disposal, realistic or not.
 
jmorgalis
offline
Link
 
The difference between the Wildcat and the LOLSlam is that you could know exactly what was coming with the SI Slam and still not stop it. The Wildcat is effective in two scenarios: 1. Lower level leagues where defenders have no vision, 2. When it is a total surprise. (Ask Cobra Kai how effective it has been with it. Nice rushing numbers, but not a whole lot of wins)

And the idea that it is totally unrealistic doesn't wash because most of what happens on here without the ability to adjust a failing gameplan on the fly is totally unrealistic, but that is just how this game has to be designed. Of course you could see that a HB was at QB if you had realtime intelligence built-in, just as I could see after one play of the HB running free down the seam that perhaps we should cover him next time. But you can't, because you cannot adjust for holes or opportunities as the game progresses.

So ultimately, we have a team that found that you chose to not pay attention to a particular possibility and chose to use it, out of position penalty and all. Bravo to that.

The fact that the Snowmen hate the play is irrelevant. Their agreement to "play fair" is more out of a dislike of the play rather than a statement about how ethical the play is. The HB at QB2 is easily stoppable if the possibility is considered. The fact that Valhalla didn't consider it is not Chile's fault and it's not a broken play any more than any play on GLB is broken.

Considering how unrealistic most defenses are anyway, I find this argument pointless. But one last time, wildcat <> lolslam. Completely different.

Anyway, all this does is add intrigue to a conference championship. I will be rooting for the Snowmen, in part because I want to believe i was 0.5 yards away from playing for it all . Best of luck to all participants.
 
wbudwhite
offline
Link
 
+1
 
wbudwhite
offline
Link
 
I think that the wild cat vs I slam thing is not the same argument. The I slam could not be stopped. The wildcat is very stoppable. I use wildcat for ARR and have seen it shut down many times. The thing with I slam there was no way to shut it down until Bort nerfed it. With wildcat all you have to do is scout the play pick the situation and out a LB on QB spy and it is done.

I really do not see the same deal as last year with the I slam.

I do see that when Valhalla is in a championship game there always has to be some deal about plays not being used.

John
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wbudwhite
I think that the wild cat vs I slam thing is not the same argument. The I slam could not be stopped. The wildcat is very stoppable. I use wildcat for ARR and have seen it shut down many times. The thing with I slam there was no way to shut it down until Bort nerfed it. With wildcat all you have to do is scout the play pick the situation and out a LB on QB spy and it is done.

I really do not see the same deal as last year with the I slam.

I do see that when Valhalla is in a championship game there always has to be some deal about plays not being used.

John


This whole argument is completely inane. I know I should drop it, but there is such easy ownage to be had...

When we slammed against you guys you could have easily stopped it with a standard defense. At that point we did not have the personnel to pull it off. We didn't have a power back and our linemen had no SAs and unused SP and were giving up too many levels (they improved a ton over the offseason). You used a horrible defense against it (3-3-5 cover 2) and we still only averaged 4 yards per carry. Also we only slammed for 35% of that game and less the game after.

Sad that you are still bitter about it. Should I bump the power rankings thread where you put us at 10th this season?

I really couldn't care less about how similar you guys think the situation is, and it doesn't matter at all.
Edited by w_alloy on Jun 2, 2009 23:16:28
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.