To whom it may concern,
I realize that i don't recall every nerf/fix that has happened, but this is something along the lines of what has happened, some of the events may even be out of order even... I'm just going by what "some or most" people had wanted and demanded as far as the nerfs that i'm showing. If i made a mistake somewhere, well sorry, but i'm trying to make a different point which is after this chain of events:
oh, its long sry
1. NERF powerbacks
then powerbacks weren't have as effected so then WR got the attention
2. NERF WR advantage on WR/CB interaction
then CB became mega blitzers
3. NERF CB blitz advantage [increase FB/HB to vision check it better]
then someone needed to get sacks so DE's were comin up w/ 100+ agility/speed to get them
4. NERF DE sack ability
now DE's suck donkey, not to mention DT's are MORE useless than DE's, but that doesn't get mentioned much because people are used to only DE's being the main play makers on the D-Line. DT's are just accepted by most as being fail i think. Therefore people start pumping ForceFumble stats and start creating insane fumble amounts with DT's/etc. since every other build is fail. People see amazing success [DUE TO: SUPER fast WR's with low carrying/str that are trying to handle the CB's, and we also see Elusive backs with SUPER speed with little carrying/str-or its Elusive backs that decided to go semi-powerbuild at some point.] Then others start making SS/FS/LB ForceFumblers and in many cases entire teams.
5. NERF ForceFumble [granted i only saw that bort nerfed FF with SureTackle, maybe im wrong] But notice that, this one small fix, where he didn't allow a 2nd FF roll on the 2nd Tackle roll, seemed to stop the insane ForceFumbles. Obviously people have been 'fixing' their builds as well. I believe this so called 'build fixing' is what makes the most difference, and to me it is unlikely that the FF insanity was stopped by the small Suretackle change although both together seems to be a good fit imo.
then the ForceFumble craze has died down and people aren't seeing much success of any kind on D-Line. Now they are accepting the FF lower(normal imo) numbers and are noticing sack/hurry amounts are down.
6. NERF OT's they are too good at stopping DE's...or even worse change the QB throwing mechanics (Which, IMO, the QB is one of the few positions that doesn't need an immediate change.) Yes, perhaps it could use a change, just not as immediate as other positions. If you change the QB in effort to fix the DE, i'm just afraid that you are "trading your car that has a broken window for a car that has a new window but a flat tire." Or something along that analogy.
Future result: Whaaa my QB sucks, nerf pass coverage or change QB mechanics back to normal. Or, Whaaa my QB hasn't been built with speed/agility and the DE's have so much time to get to him and he is getting sacked.
The fix for this 'result': Scrambling QB's will be the 'norm'. Pocket QB's will be less desirable and will likely see a thread like this one pertaining to pocket/scrambling QB's. Passing game will start to basically fail. Running the ball will see an unprecedented increase, and 'experiment HB builds' will start showing up and crazy 'Over Powered' HB's will be rampant...etc. etc.
POINT #1:
The last little bit there is obviously pure guess. Please don't take any of it to heart as i'm just showing a trend. I made this thread soley because many Nerfs/Fixes have nearly always been followed by 'exploit' builds or sim problems that are only fixed by another Nerf/Fix of some kind. As Fatbastrd said, it's a vicious cycle. I want people to realize that this is not the NFL nor is it 'real-life' football. The main difference that most are overlooking is, in the NFL, coaches/playmakers have gameplans that are based on the knowledge that:
-most WR's/CB's/D-backs are going to generally run close to the same speed
-most D-line and O-line will be close to equal in strength, and both will be able to hold/avoid blocks etc.
-most players at each position are somewhat comparable to other players on other teams of the same position, obviously talent is what makes people stand out..
-they also know that 1 mistake made by a player can be the difference between winning or losing the game, considering the scores are usually below the 40's in the NFL.
GLB on the other hand:
-any position can have the possibility of an INSANE amount of different builds. Literally your opponents can have crazy stats that you can't gameplan for, granted they may be fail builds, but every position has so many successful and fantastic build possibilities that you have to do some major scouting and perhaps be a scout bar pro to be able to guess builds.
-when a handful of users find a good build, it is basically 'mass produced' and it seems to knock GLB off balance, and people demand sim and code changes.
-mistakes can be made by players, and not change the outcome of the game. obviously yes, if a CB misses a tackle or something on a WR and that WR gets a TD, yea...that's a big change. BUT. imo, the build variety can allow certain players to excel against Team A, but do poorly against Team B.
People think they find the "God build" for a certain position, but eventually people will find that you can't be stacking your 1 attribute to the 6SP level or 7SP level and not do anything to your other stats in between and still be successful against every team (i do agree most positions should have 1 or 2 attributes to be the highest, but not that high, here's why) For One, certain positions should have more balance than people are making them with because that would most definitely put a giant bandaid made of steal on this whole "God build mass production" crap. For Two, UMMM maybe you guys don't realize this, but your player is basically limited to 10 SEASONS. Just looking at one of my players i see it took about 6 seasons to get him to 43 with full boosting, and he's almost where i want him. I was a pretty extreme 'slowbuilder/attribute stacker" for single/double attributes at one point, and i realize that i'll probably have spent 6-7 seasons getting this player to the 'desired" or acceptable build, stat wise. That's WITH boosting and CE and all of the oldest tricks in GLB as far as building players go. During that time, my players lacked in MANY areas obviously, and overly excelled in 1 or 2 areas. Overall, they were somewhat not as effective as a balanced build.
I'm just wanting people to ask themselves, is it really worth over half of your player's lifespan to be slowbuilding, or sometimes not on a team, or under-performing, and/or useless, JUST to have roughly 3-4 or so seasons of good stats, where you will still end up playing against other people who have done the exact same thing and who have just as good of builds? Maybe yes perhaps, but if i have another wave of players i make, I think it would be fun to do a mixing of balanced building and yet getting good attributes still. And yes, you can have balanced builds and still have very diverse builds, its all about where you specialize. I'd much rather see my players go from 'high school play' to 'college' to 'pro' level, not from 60% of his lifespan in kindergarten straight to 'Hall of Fame" for a couple seasons [I KNOW EXAGGERATION, don't whine about this.] idk, something to think about perhaps
POINT #2:
I agree, as everyone else does, that a fix to O-Line should be made. I'd like to emphasize O-Line and not just the OT. If your gonna help the DE, why not FINALLY give the DT a chance to shine too. Bort made a good suggestion, decreasing the blocking radius for the OLine, which is genious. It doesn't mess with much of the game mechanics, it should be easy to test, and it should be fairly simple to tweak if we see a huge shift in gameplay for whatever reason, unlike other possible 'fix solutions' which could become a pain i'm sure. I think all types of builds can benefit from it:
-Super elusive DE's: if the blocker cant keep this DE from squirming around him, he will no longer be able to catch him from behind with his legs and still hold a DT on the other side with his hands, or so it seems from some replays
-Power DE's: Getting a good stun or defensive pancake on the blocker will allow enough time to get around and out of the blockers range, granted the DE didn't forget about speed/agility/vision.
-Any other mixed builds should have equal success imo, as long as the radius is tweaked with a fine tune needle.
-DT's will likely see a small increase in sacks, but rather be able to get to the HB/scrambler/short passes easier; DE's should average back to 'normalish' sack ratings. Overall i think that this would create an AWESOME AWESSSSOOME Line of Scrimmage battle and give way for EPICness. Imagine...a DT build that's different, and still effective!! That's gonna create a change in C/G builds!! haha it would be awesome to see the same interactions between DT's/C's/G's that you do with the pre-nerf OT's and DE's. It would also give the O-Line AND D-Line some diversity
This is of course if it plays out IRL like it is in my mind lol
HEY YOU DID IT!! all done reading yay,
cheers
EDIT: I'd like to the the 5 or so random people that have stated some of this info or close to it in other threads, and gave me the motivation for this one.
I realize that i don't recall every nerf/fix that has happened, but this is something along the lines of what has happened, some of the events may even be out of order even... I'm just going by what "some or most" people had wanted and demanded as far as the nerfs that i'm showing. If i made a mistake somewhere, well sorry, but i'm trying to make a different point which is after this chain of events:
oh, its long sry

1. NERF powerbacks
then powerbacks weren't have as effected so then WR got the attention
2. NERF WR advantage on WR/CB interaction
then CB became mega blitzers
3. NERF CB blitz advantage [increase FB/HB to vision check it better]
then someone needed to get sacks so DE's were comin up w/ 100+ agility/speed to get them
4. NERF DE sack ability
now DE's suck donkey, not to mention DT's are MORE useless than DE's, but that doesn't get mentioned much because people are used to only DE's being the main play makers on the D-Line. DT's are just accepted by most as being fail i think. Therefore people start pumping ForceFumble stats and start creating insane fumble amounts with DT's/etc. since every other build is fail. People see amazing success [DUE TO: SUPER fast WR's with low carrying/str that are trying to handle the CB's, and we also see Elusive backs with SUPER speed with little carrying/str-or its Elusive backs that decided to go semi-powerbuild at some point.] Then others start making SS/FS/LB ForceFumblers and in many cases entire teams.
5. NERF ForceFumble [granted i only saw that bort nerfed FF with SureTackle, maybe im wrong] But notice that, this one small fix, where he didn't allow a 2nd FF roll on the 2nd Tackle roll, seemed to stop the insane ForceFumbles. Obviously people have been 'fixing' their builds as well. I believe this so called 'build fixing' is what makes the most difference, and to me it is unlikely that the FF insanity was stopped by the small Suretackle change although both together seems to be a good fit imo.
then the ForceFumble craze has died down and people aren't seeing much success of any kind on D-Line. Now they are accepting the FF lower(normal imo) numbers and are noticing sack/hurry amounts are down.
6. NERF OT's they are too good at stopping DE's...or even worse change the QB throwing mechanics (Which, IMO, the QB is one of the few positions that doesn't need an immediate change.) Yes, perhaps it could use a change, just not as immediate as other positions. If you change the QB in effort to fix the DE, i'm just afraid that you are "trading your car that has a broken window for a car that has a new window but a flat tire." Or something along that analogy.
Future result: Whaaa my QB sucks, nerf pass coverage or change QB mechanics back to normal. Or, Whaaa my QB hasn't been built with speed/agility and the DE's have so much time to get to him and he is getting sacked.
The fix for this 'result': Scrambling QB's will be the 'norm'. Pocket QB's will be less desirable and will likely see a thread like this one pertaining to pocket/scrambling QB's. Passing game will start to basically fail. Running the ball will see an unprecedented increase, and 'experiment HB builds' will start showing up and crazy 'Over Powered' HB's will be rampant...etc. etc.
POINT #1:
The last little bit there is obviously pure guess. Please don't take any of it to heart as i'm just showing a trend. I made this thread soley because many Nerfs/Fixes have nearly always been followed by 'exploit' builds or sim problems that are only fixed by another Nerf/Fix of some kind. As Fatbastrd said, it's a vicious cycle. I want people to realize that this is not the NFL nor is it 'real-life' football. The main difference that most are overlooking is, in the NFL, coaches/playmakers have gameplans that are based on the knowledge that:
-most WR's/CB's/D-backs are going to generally run close to the same speed
-most D-line and O-line will be close to equal in strength, and both will be able to hold/avoid blocks etc.
-most players at each position are somewhat comparable to other players on other teams of the same position, obviously talent is what makes people stand out..
-they also know that 1 mistake made by a player can be the difference between winning or losing the game, considering the scores are usually below the 40's in the NFL.
GLB on the other hand:
-any position can have the possibility of an INSANE amount of different builds. Literally your opponents can have crazy stats that you can't gameplan for, granted they may be fail builds, but every position has so many successful and fantastic build possibilities that you have to do some major scouting and perhaps be a scout bar pro to be able to guess builds.
-when a handful of users find a good build, it is basically 'mass produced' and it seems to knock GLB off balance, and people demand sim and code changes.
-mistakes can be made by players, and not change the outcome of the game. obviously yes, if a CB misses a tackle or something on a WR and that WR gets a TD, yea...that's a big change. BUT. imo, the build variety can allow certain players to excel against Team A, but do poorly against Team B.
People think they find the "God build" for a certain position, but eventually people will find that you can't be stacking your 1 attribute to the 6SP level or 7SP level and not do anything to your other stats in between and still be successful against every team (i do agree most positions should have 1 or 2 attributes to be the highest, but not that high, here's why) For One, certain positions should have more balance than people are making them with because that would most definitely put a giant bandaid made of steal on this whole "God build mass production" crap. For Two, UMMM maybe you guys don't realize this, but your player is basically limited to 10 SEASONS. Just looking at one of my players i see it took about 6 seasons to get him to 43 with full boosting, and he's almost where i want him. I was a pretty extreme 'slowbuilder/attribute stacker" for single/double attributes at one point, and i realize that i'll probably have spent 6-7 seasons getting this player to the 'desired" or acceptable build, stat wise. That's WITH boosting and CE and all of the oldest tricks in GLB as far as building players go. During that time, my players lacked in MANY areas obviously, and overly excelled in 1 or 2 areas. Overall, they were somewhat not as effective as a balanced build.
I'm just wanting people to ask themselves, is it really worth over half of your player's lifespan to be slowbuilding, or sometimes not on a team, or under-performing, and/or useless, JUST to have roughly 3-4 or so seasons of good stats, where you will still end up playing against other people who have done the exact same thing and who have just as good of builds? Maybe yes perhaps, but if i have another wave of players i make, I think it would be fun to do a mixing of balanced building and yet getting good attributes still. And yes, you can have balanced builds and still have very diverse builds, its all about where you specialize. I'd much rather see my players go from 'high school play' to 'college' to 'pro' level, not from 60% of his lifespan in kindergarten straight to 'Hall of Fame" for a couple seasons [I KNOW EXAGGERATION, don't whine about this.] idk, something to think about perhaps
POINT #2:
I agree, as everyone else does, that a fix to O-Line should be made. I'd like to emphasize O-Line and not just the OT. If your gonna help the DE, why not FINALLY give the DT a chance to shine too. Bort made a good suggestion, decreasing the blocking radius for the OLine, which is genious. It doesn't mess with much of the game mechanics, it should be easy to test, and it should be fairly simple to tweak if we see a huge shift in gameplay for whatever reason, unlike other possible 'fix solutions' which could become a pain i'm sure. I think all types of builds can benefit from it:
-Super elusive DE's: if the blocker cant keep this DE from squirming around him, he will no longer be able to catch him from behind with his legs and still hold a DT on the other side with his hands, or so it seems from some replays

-Power DE's: Getting a good stun or defensive pancake on the blocker will allow enough time to get around and out of the blockers range, granted the DE didn't forget about speed/agility/vision.
-Any other mixed builds should have equal success imo, as long as the radius is tweaked with a fine tune needle.
-DT's will likely see a small increase in sacks, but rather be able to get to the HB/scrambler/short passes easier; DE's should average back to 'normalish' sack ratings. Overall i think that this would create an AWESOME AWESSSSOOME Line of Scrimmage battle and give way for EPICness. Imagine...a DT build that's different, and still effective!! That's gonna create a change in C/G builds!! haha it would be awesome to see the same interactions between DT's/C's/G's that you do with the pre-nerf OT's and DE's. It would also give the O-Line AND D-Line some diversity
This is of course if it plays out IRL like it is in my mind lolHEY YOU DID IT!! all done reading yay,
cheers
EDIT: I'd like to the the 5 or so random people that have stated some of this info or close to it in other threads, and gave me the motivation for this one.

Edited by Galoonga on May 21, 2009 05:27:07
Edited by Galoonga on May 21, 2009 05:23:14
Edited by Galoonga on May 21, 2009 05:20:09
Edited by Galoonga on May 21, 2009 05:17:34



























