First of all let me say that I think fumbles are fine for the most part. There are two instances where fumbles seem to me to be a legitimate issue. Elusive backs and Return men. These builds are focused on Speed and Agility. They should not be required to have the same amount of strenght/carrying that a powerback would have, the more points an elusive back has to put into str/carrying the more like a powerback with terrible SA choices they become. Powerbacks = 2 attributes. Elusive backs = 4 attributes. (I'm dismissing confidence and vision here on purpose.)
I believe the solution is to have two distinct types of tackles.
Type #1:
A ball carrier is running forward with no intent to avoid a tackle. This player when hit by a defender with a successful tackle roll should have to have more carrying and strength in order to avoid a fumble than definition #2 as the tackler has hit the ball carrier squarely and was able to put all of his momentum and body weight into the tackle.
Type #2:
A ball carrier is running forward with intent to avoid tackles through elusive SA type moves or through attempting to use agility to create "glancing blows". These players should not require as much carrying or strength to avoid a fumble as the tackler has not hit the carrier squarely, limiting the force which can be applied in the tackle.
Definition #2 would also apply to tackles from behind as most of these types of tackles are the result of a tackler hitting a leg while diving forward, very little force applied in the tackle.
If anyone has any suggestions or ideas to add to this I'll update the OP.
I believe the solution is to have two distinct types of tackles.
Type #1:
A ball carrier is running forward with no intent to avoid a tackle. This player when hit by a defender with a successful tackle roll should have to have more carrying and strength in order to avoid a fumble than definition #2 as the tackler has hit the ball carrier squarely and was able to put all of his momentum and body weight into the tackle.
Type #2:
A ball carrier is running forward with intent to avoid tackles through elusive SA type moves or through attempting to use agility to create "glancing blows". These players should not require as much carrying or strength to avoid a fumble as the tackler has not hit the carrier squarely, limiting the force which can be applied in the tackle.
Definition #2 would also apply to tackles from behind as most of these types of tackles are the result of a tackler hitting a leg while diving forward, very little force applied in the tackle.
If anyone has any suggestions or ideas to add to this I'll update the OP.






























