User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make Carrying Tactics Relevant To Fumble Chance
Page:
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
I've noticed that there are concerns that forced fumbles are overpowered this season due to a combination of defenders fixing their builds to adjust to power backs and the fumbling buff that Bort gave to Monster Hit/Big Hit and the Power Tackler VA, to the point where people are suggesting that a back needs 70 strength/70 carrying/5 Cover Up not to fumble multiple times a game (see this thread: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2560130&page=6#21736330 ).

My suggestion would be to make the likelihood of a fumble highest when the ball carrier is set to the -100 side of the carrying tactics and lowest when the ball carrier is set to the +100 side of the carrying tactic.

The football-logic reason for this is that it should be easier for defenders to square up and cause a fumble (or Monster/Big Hit) when the ball carrier is running right at them and harder for defenders to find an angle to square up and cause a fumble when the ball carrier is trying to elude the defender.

The first GLB-logic reason for this is that if it is indeed true that a ball carrier needs high strength/carrying/cover up to not fumble multiple times a game, then there will be no more elusive backs in the game, b/c there aren't enough SPs to spread around.

The second GLB-logic reason for this is that, unlike almost any other overpowered skill set we've had in this game, 4+ fumbles a game is not only unrealistic, but completely destroys the competitive balance.

Anyway, just my $0.02.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Other options discussed in that thread to deal with the problem were:

1. Reduce the effect that strength has on preventing fumbles and increase the effect that carrying has.

2. Introduce a new ball-carrying slider with the two extremes being Fight For More Yards (risk fumbling) and Cover Up (risk getting tackled at the point of impact).
 
Mordaloch
offline
Link
 
the slider should be like this:

[Carrying]
<--------------------------|------------------------------>
cover up____________________break tackles


the slider is all the way to the left is better chance to NOT fumble but less chance to break tackles, all the way to the RIGHT is better chance to break tackles but more chance to fumble.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 11:12:17
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
I
My suggestion would be to make the likelihood of a fumble highest when the ball carrier is set to the -100 side of the carrying tactics and lowest when the ball carrier is set to the +100 side of the carrying tactic.


I don't have any facts to support this, but to me this seems backwards to me. Usually elusive ball carriers expose the ball much more when making their moves than do power backs.
 
MentalMisfit
offline
Link
 
guess HB can't get away with only 40 carrying anymore. Doesn't need to be changed at all every defense player had to train tackling to 60-70 to attempt to stop power backs now its your turn to spend 2 seasons getting your carry skill up
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mordaloch
the slider should be like this:

[Carrying]
<--------------------------|------------------------------>
cover up____________________break tackles


the slider is all the way to the left is better chance to NOT fumble but less chance to break tackles, all the way to the RIGHT is better chance to break tackles but more chance to fumble.


I like that.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MentalMisfit
guess HB can't get away with only 40 carrying anymore. Doesn't need to be changed at all every defense player had to train tackling to 60-70 to attempt to stop power backs now its your turn to spend 2 seasons getting your carry skill up


I don't have a HB with less than 55 carrying, and the OP in the thread I linked to had carrying over 60. Tackling at 60 and carrying at 60 shouldn't yield 5 fumbles a game.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
Originally posted by Gyuri1

I
My suggestion would be to make the likelihood of a fumble highest when the ball carrier is set to the -100 side of the carrying tactics and lowest when the ball carrier is set to the +100 side of the carrying tactic.


I don't have any facts to support this, but to me this seems backwards to me. Usually elusive ball carriers expose the ball much more when making their moves than do power backs.


From the thread I linked to (only one data point, admittedly):

Originally posted by player66
Originally posted by jrry32


Yea, like how it was easier to hit Earl Campbell straight on than Barry Sanders. With Sanders, you normally could get him a full on big hit because he was juking so often and was so quick. I definitely agree with that.


http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/S/SandBa00.htm

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/C/CampEa00.htm

lol proves poot and my point sanders 41 fumbles on 3062 carries, campbell 43 fumbles on 2187 carries. Strength should have little to do with fumbles.


Leaving aside what happens in the NFL for a moment, if triple capped carrying/triple capped strength and lots of Cover Up is needed to prevent multiple fumbles a game, then there will be no elusive backs.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 11:20:58
 
Mordaloch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by MentalMisfit

guess HB can't get away with only 40 carrying anymore. Doesn't need to be changed at all every defense player had to train tackling to 60-70 to attempt to stop power backs now its your turn to spend 2 seasons getting your carry skill up


I don't have a HB with less than 55 carrying, and the OP in the thread I linked to had carrying over 60. Tackling at 60 and carrying at 60 shouldn't yield 5 fumbles a game.


keep in mind your energy level and morale level at the time will affect your stats if you been demoralized and are tired you will cough up the ball even if you match his tackling with your carrying.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mordaloch
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by MentalMisfit


guess HB can't get away with only 40 carrying anymore. Doesn't need to be changed at all every defense player had to train tackling to 60-70 to attempt to stop power backs now its your turn to spend 2 seasons getting your carry skill up


I don't have a HB with less than 55 carrying, and the OP in the thread I linked to had carrying over 60. Tackling at 60 and carrying at 60 shouldn't yield 5 fumbles a game.


keep in mind your energy level and morale level at the time will affect your stats if you been demoralized and are tired you will cough up the ball even if you match his tackling with your carrying.


Oh, I know, but if that means that the only way to prevent fumbling all the time is to match tackling with carrying, match strength with strength and have 60+ confidence and 60+ stamina so as not to get too tired or loose too much morale, then there aren't really all that many SPs to go around.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
I understand about the big hit, but a lot of time a big hit isn't what causes a fumble. It can, but most of your fumbles are caused by somebody just getting their hand or helmet on the ball in the right spot, or someone just being stronger and being able to rip out a ball that isn't tucked properly. I would like to see some actual data that really compares the 2 as the group. Comparing Barry Sanders vs Earl Campbell really doesn't mean much.
 
player66
offline
Link
 
i see you beat me over here! agree with slider for cover up/ fight for yards
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
My suggestion would be to make the likelihood of a fumble highest when the ball carrier is set to the -100 side of the carrying tactics and lowest when the ball carrier is set to the +100 side of the carrying tactic.

This was suggested in earlier seasons as a response to the power back craze and makes sense both from a game mechanic and realism standpoint.


And on a sidenote, why do the same people with no high level players constantly post in the suggestions forum? Butler312, Mordaloch, and those in the same group, you guys should wait until you have some experience before you start commenting on every part of the game. Unless of course you're multis of experienced players, in which case feel free to carry on.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I understand about the big hit, but a lot of time a big hit isn't what causes a fumble. It can, but most of your fumbles are caused by somebody just getting their hand or helmet on the ball in the right spot, or someone just being stronger and being able to rip out a ball that isn't tucked properly. I would like to see some actual data that really compares the 2 as the group. Comparing Barry Sanders vs Earl Campbell really doesn't mean much.


Well then strength shouldn't play a role at all then in causing fumbles in GLB.

Good luck finding that data, as I don't think there's a site that compares elusive/power backs in the NFL.

The point remains, though, that in GLB 4+ fumbles a game will decide every game, as fumbles on returns almost always lead to TDs. Requiring very high amounts of strength and carrying for all ball carriers will mean that there will only be power backs, and, by next season once the FSs and CBs start adapting, only power WRs. So GLRugby, in other words.
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I understand about the big hit, but a lot of time a big hit isn't what causes a fumble. It can, but most of your fumbles are caused by somebody just getting their hand or helmet on the ball in the right spot, or someone just being stronger and being able to rip out a ball that isn't tucked properly. I would like to see some actual data that really compares the 2 as the group. Comparing Barry Sanders vs Earl Campbell really doesn't mean much.


but it would be almost impossible just because the other side of the ball can not be taken into account. I would say a player trying to fight for more yards has a much higher chance of fumbling (based on my 15 odd years of coaching and playing football).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.