User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A way to allow for users to have some say over height at creation, while adding dynamic weight change and doing away with the "Reroll" method of generating starting attributes
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
This suggestion addresses a number of factors in the game that are currently lacking. It removes the stupid “roll” system for generating your starting attributes and lets you simply put starting points where you want while also allowing you to choose your height. It also provides a simple, yet realistic way of dynamic weight change. Combined with Bort’s idea of weight classes (http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1497562), it will add more depth and realism to the game, as well as allowing for more diversity among builds – always a worthy goal.

The current roll/reroll system makes no sense. People are just going to continue to reroll until they get what they want. Why bother? Let’s scrap the system, start all attributes at 8 and give people 27 points to distribute as they see fit. This is essentially the same as the current system but now people can just put the points where they want instead of rolling 100 times seeking the “perfect” roll. If desired, we could keep the current position specific attribute max scores as spelled out here: http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Highest_Attribute_Rolls

In addition, we add the ability to choose your height. Table A found here: http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=phHQpgKmo1IPwmcrRAXHrCw&hl=en lists the average (mean) height by position of the 2008 NFL rosters in the column headed “Avg height”. This will be your starting height before spending points at creation as outlined below.

If you wish to be taller, you spend points from your 27 point starting pool. Each position will have a different point cost to add 1” at a time. This point cost is in the column headed “+1”-pts” . The max you can increase your height to is in the column headed “MaxHt” and corresponds to the tallest height currently active in the NFL. Increasing height to the max pt will use up most, if not all, of your 27 pt allocation.

If you wish to be shorter, you can gain points to add to your 27 point pool. Each position will have a different point cost to subtract 1” at a time. This point cost is in the column headed “-1”=+pts”. The minimum you can reduce your height to is in the column headed “MinHt” and corresponds to the shortest height currently active in the NFL. You gain back points for being shorter at approximately half the rate that you add inches.

Finally, let’s talk about dynamic weight. Weight is based on your ratio of strength to stamina. At a 1:1 strength:stamina ratio where strength = stamina, your weight will be calculated by multiplying the number found in the column headed AvgWt in Table A and “1” in Table B. For example, a QB of average height, 75” where strength=stamina, will multiply that height by 3 and will weigh 225 lbs.

As the QBs strength exceeds his stamina he will gain weight as shown in Table B. When the strength:stamina ration gets to 1.1:1 (ie Strength 11, Stamina 10 or Strength 60, Stamina 55), the QB will gain weight as indicated on the chart and will now multiply his height by 3.05 and will weigh 228.75 lbs. If the QB were to get to the point where strength was twice stamina (100 strength: 50 stamina), he would use the number at the far right of Table B (“2:1”) and his height would be multiplied by 3.5 and would be 262.5 lbs.

The same would work in reverse. As Stamina exceeds strength, you move left of center on Table B and lose weight.

Using Bort’s idea of weight classes to increase the impact of weight and height on factors in the game, this adds a fun and realistic new twist to the game. Not only can you spend pts at the expense of starting attributes to be taller, you can choose to be shorter and get some extra points. You can also influence your weight. Big strong offensive linemen with little strength will be heavier. CBs who can run all day but aren’t very strong will be lighter. Funny how that makes sense…

Edit to add some suggested height and weight modifiers in game:

Lighter weight = easier to tackle.
Bigger weight differential between tackler and tacklee = more stamina loss for tacklee
Shorter Height means less speed reduction when changing direction
More Height = More impact on Z-axis related checks.
More weight = more stamina loss during a play (A "coming soon" modification I believe), less weight = less stamina loss during a play (until you get tackled by someone heavier)


Last edited Apr 17, 2009 08:23:30
 
Link
 
I like this - A lot. +1!
 
Momara94
offline
Link
 
-1
height isnt really a factor so all non WR and CBs will be as short as possible to start off w/ awesome rolls
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Momara94
-1
height isnt really a factor so all non WR and CBs will be as short as possible to start off w/ awesome rolls


Did you miss that part where I talked about increasing the role of both height and weight?
Last edited Apr 14, 2009 21:42:38
 
Momara94
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Momara94

-1
height isnt really a factor so all non WR and CBs will be as short as possible to start off w/ awesome rolls


Did you miss that part where I talked about increasing the role of both height and weight?


yea but if you do that you put all the people who disregarded height and weight at a disadvantage which will cause mass retirements
 
george96
offline
Link
 
-1, too complex and we can't seem to fix basic issues as of season 8!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Momara94
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Momara94


-1
height isnt really a factor so all non WR and CBs will be as short as possible to start off w/ awesome rolls


Did you miss that part where I talked about increasing the role of both height and weight?


yea but if you do that you put all the people who disregarded height and weight at a disadvantage which will cause mass retirements


wouldn't be the first time GLB *nerfed* something. They'll get over it. Changes happen.
 
Momara94
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Angry Beavers
Originally posted by Momara94

Originally posted by drifter


Originally posted by Momara94



-1
height isnt really a factor so all non WR and CBs will be as short as possible to start off w/ awesome rolls


Did you miss that part where I talked about increasing the role of both height and weight?


yea but if you do that you put all the people who disregarded height and weight at a disadvantage which will cause mass retirements


wouldn't be the first time GLB *nerfed* something. They'll get over it. Changes happen.


yea but its hard enough to find players now
we dont need retirements right now
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by george96
-1, too complex and we can't seem to fix basic issues as of season 8!


Not too complex at all. Might be hard to comprehend for some but the formulas invovled are remarkably simple.
Last edited Apr 14, 2009 21:47:30
 
thegreat23
offline
Link
 
+1

It seems like a pretty realistic idea.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Momara94
Originally posted by The Angry Beavers

Originally posted by Momara94


Originally posted by drifter



Originally posted by Momara94




-1
height isnt really a factor so all non WR and CBs will be as short as possible to start off w/ awesome rolls


Did you miss that part where I talked about increasing the role of both height and weight?


yea but if you do that you put all the people who disregarded height and weight at a disadvantage which will cause mass retirements


wouldn't be the first time GLB *nerfed* something. They'll get over it. Changes happen.


yea but its hard enough to find players now
we dont need retirements right now


You're one season away from declines starting on season 1 players. Get ready for mass retirements to be a way of life.

Plus, as pointed out, the game is in "Beta". Things change. Things improve. Fear of change is a weak excuse for not improving the game.

 
HeadlesssKES
offline
Link
 
Just real quick..

I like the basic concept. The way of going about it may have to change, though.

First and foremost, you do NOT get more points by becoming shorter. Getting shorter still loses you one point per inch, or whatever.
Reason being is that the shorter you are, the lower your center of gravity.... basically, a PB WANTS to be short. A C may want to be short as well to help push... all run blockers wants to be short...

Anyway, if this were to be implemented, of course the current roll max would have to be used.. there needs to be a ceiling, IMO. Maybe make it 20 for all attributes, all positions?
 
rehash
offline
Link
 
not realistic with the height...weight i dont mind but this isnt needed
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HeadlesssKES
Just real quick..

I like the basic concept. The way of going about it may have to change, though.

First and foremost, you do NOT get more points by becoming shorter. Getting shorter still loses you one point per inch, or whatever.
Reason being is that the shorter you are, the lower your center of gravity.... basically, a PB WANTS to be short. A C may want to be short as well to help push... all run blockers wants to be short...

Anyway, if this were to be implemented, of course the current roll max would have to be used.. there needs to be a ceiling, IMO. Maybe make it 20 for all attributes, all positions?



While being shorter has some advantages at the positions you list, it also has disadvantages. A shorter Center will never be as heavy as a taller one can be. The same goes for a HB - a power back will not be as heavy if he is shorter; a speedback who is shorter will be even lighter as his stamina is likely to exceed his stamina by quite a bit, making him even easier to tackle.

Also, if you were to make it so that lighter players took a bigger stamina hit when tackled by heavier players (another good idea), there would be additional reasons to not be short and light.

I thought of a flat attribute max, but there is so much variation in the current max rolls that I thought it best just to leave those in place.
Last edited Apr 14, 2009 22:01:39
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rehash
not realistic with the height...weight i dont mind but this isnt needed


How do you figure?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.