Jeremy Moore had 3,445 yards and 28 TD's against the 11 non CPU's. You guys got your numbers against 14 non CPU's (except Cheung who played 13 non CPU's).
Jeremy averaged 313 yards and 2.54 TD's
Walter 334 and 2 TD's Cheung 300 and 2.3 TD's Johnson 270 and 0.85 TD's Tebow 294 and 3.07 TD's
So.................... Yards Walter 334 Moore 313 Cheung 300 Tebow 294 Johnson 270
TD's Tebow 3.07 Moore 2.54 Cheung 2.3 Walter 2.0 Johnson 0.85
Regardless of how many gut jobs Jeremy Moore played, he definitely deserves to be on the list. And he probably deserves to be the MVP as he was #2 in both whereas Tebow was #1 in TD's but # 4 in yards and Walter was #1 in yards but #4 in TD's
You are measuring value right? You should be measuring percentage of Yards passed/Total Yards gained by the team, and TDs thrown*6/total points. Then you'll have a better idea of the percentage of the team's offense the QB was responsible for.