User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Divisions in the conferences
Page:
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Alright,

I know this seems pretty complicated for playoff spots, but i have noticed something about the game that doesn't sit well with me, so let me explain why I think this is a good suggestion:

Really good teams are saying they are gonna gut and slow build because they cannot be the top team. In a my team's conference a 10-3 team said they are gonna separate and slow build because they can't hang. This game should not be like that. I think that divisions would be a good thing...WHY!???

1. Split the 16 team conference into 4 divisions of 4 teams a piece.
2. The champ of the division gets a trophy
3. People like trophies, they are cool, it makes them happy
4. Happy people, means more cash

It is also a short term goal for the team and something to look back on if they don't make it to a conference championship.

NOW THE REASON YOU WILL SHOOT ME DOWN:

"Doing it by division will make it harder to determine who goes to the playoffs, since all division champs should get a playoff spot."

Well, untill that code can be written (doubt it, because I cannot see a fair way to do it)...the playoffs will be decided the same way as always, from a field of 16 out of the conference in terms of record. The divisions are just for trophies and a way for a lesser team to see that all their hard work is not wasted and give am more attainable goal to be the best of 4 than the best of 16/32. There could be an avatar for a division championship that might be a smaller trophy, or a pic of a football with N/S/E/W on it (north south east west).

I think its worth a try, but there might be lots of code to work in the promoted teams.

There can be a random generation for the first go around. And the code can get more complex from season to season. I know its a coding nightmare and can see promotions wreaking havoc much like endorsements did. I just think its worth a look.

Sorry if this was already stated.

--dan
 
Link
 
I think this idea is cool.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by quzur
I think this idea is cool.


Appreciate it. i am not gonna be bumping this thread a lot because my team is decently successful, and the agents I have just like the game and they all believe that we are competitive. Its just the other teams. The conference my team is in has 3 CPU teams. That sucks ebcause there are constant flame wars about stats and CPU team games.

This would cut down the number of teams that go CPU or gut
--Dan
 
ErDrRon
offline
Link
 
Great suggestion, Dan!
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
i suggested this a few months ago. it didnt work out too well. but i still like it.
 
Link
 
The way Dan has it laid out seems to make sense to me.
 
kmart
Mod
offline
Link
 
I would like to see something like this instituted as well.
 
MF3K
offline
Link
 
I was just thinking about this the other day. I wouldn't mind (but not necessary) to have the NFL format where you play everyone in your division twice a season. Would really kick up the rivalries.
 
Nv1sion
offline
Link
 
Seems like just another non-substantial idea like colored dots.
 
iv82much
offline
Link
 
It has been suggested many times. Biggest problem is with the huge amount of promotions demotions every season it would completely destroy the division rivalry aspect of it.

I do like the idea though. It seems to me I'm the only one that thinks a huge amount of teams failing every season is a bad thing for the long term success of the game. I think a big change needs to take place for this game to really take off, I'm not sure what exactly.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MF3K
I was just thinking about this the other day. I wouldn't mind (but not necessary) to have the NFL format where you play everyone in your division twice a season. Would really kick up the rivalries.


THis is where things get hairy. Thats why i had the disclaimer that the playoff choosing system will not be different.

THere is nowhere near as much volatility between teams in the NFL as here in GLB. How many NFL teams get gutted? So not playing every team will make divisions WORSE for a struggling team if they are stuck in a division with stud teams.

Like Nv1sion said, its unsubstantial, but it is a way to form rivalries and get a little piece of flare for the team.
Last edited Mar 21, 2009 22:59:34
 
MF3K
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
Originally posted by MF3K

I was just thinking about this the other day. I wouldn't mind (but not necessary) to have the NFL format where you play everyone in your division twice a season. Would really kick up the rivalries.


THis is where things get hairy. Thats why i had the disclaimer that the playoff choosing system will not be different.

THere is nowhere near as much volatility between teams in the NFL as here in GLB. How many NFL teams get gutted? So not playing every team will make divisions WORSE for a striggleing team if they are stuck in a division with stud teams.

Like Nv1sion said, its unsubstantial, but it is a way to form rivalries and get a little piece of flare for the team.


You're right about the guts and playoff consideration. The wild card playoff spots would be unfair due to unbalanced divisions.
 
Link
 
I'd like to see this... how bout just top 2 from each division (of 4) advance. You get 2 (or 3) games vs division rivals, and then play 1 (or 2) of the other 3 divisions. Plain and simple. Divisions can be randomly created each season, to "Mix it up" and keep things fair.

Top teams still advance, worst still drop, etc. etc, since divisions are random each year.

Teams less likely to gut when they only have to beat 2 other teams (in their division) each season to make playoffs, opposed to 15.
Last edited Mar 22, 2009 03:59:46
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Angry Beavers
I'd like to see this... how bout just top 2 from each division (of 4) advance. You get 2 (or 3) games vs division rivals, and then play 1 (or 2) of the other 3 divisions. Plain and simple. Divisions can be randomly created each season, to "Mix it up" and keep things fair.

Top teams still advance, worst still drop, etc. etc, since divisions are random each year.

Teams less likely to gut when they only have to beat 2 other teams (in their division) each season to make playoffs, opposed to 15.


It would be too hard for that. If tied, it would just go to record anyways. The playoff criteria needs to stay the same until the code can be written for fairness, and ensuring that the divisions are even, in case there are 4 teams in the division with 10 wins each!!! That would suck!

I guess the divisions could be chosen by a formula that uses scouting bars of the teams to make sure each division has a "favorite" OR you can have the divisions just be teams with equal scouting bars. It would make for better rivalries and the teams have something to shoot for. Since it has no playoff implications, there will be no outcry of it being unfair.


--Dan
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
Originally posted by The Angry Beavers

I'd like to see this... how bout just top 2 from each division (of 4) advance. You get 2 (or 3) games vs division rivals, and then play 1 (or 2) of the other 3 divisions. Plain and simple. Divisions can be randomly created each season, to "Mix it up" and keep things fair.

Top teams still advance, worst still drop, etc. etc, since divisions are random each year.

Teams less likely to gut when they only have to beat 2 other teams (in their division) each season to make playoffs, opposed to 15.


It would be too hard for that. If tied, it would just go to record anyways. The playoff criteria needs to stay the same until the code can be written for fairness, and ensuring that the divisions are even, in case there are 4 teams in the division with 10 wins each!!! That would suck!

I guess the divisions could be chosen by a formula that uses scouting bars of the teams to make sure each division has a "favorite" OR you can have the divisions just be teams with equal scouting bars. It would make for better rivalries and the teams have something to shoot for. Since it has no playoff implications, there will be no outcry of it being unfair.


--Dan


I disagree. Look at the MLB's American league EAST or NFL's AFC Central, etc etc.... For how many years have those divisions been "balanced"....? There will always be an imbalance...no way to fix that...but with teams moving into and out of a division each season, only 2 teams ever stay put, while 2 new teams move into those spots. The constant rotation will give everyone a better shot and inspire the weaker teams to continue to improve.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.