I mentioned this in the main forums and had wanted to make a thread here about it for a while.
I think most of us can agree that this season's sim has taken a step back from the past, and that's primarily because gameplanning against certain plays has proved to be fruitless.
Instead of putting together a great, diverse gameplan, teams run the same 4 or 5 money plays over the course of an entire game and are better off than teams who try to keep defenses honest by running a diverse playbook.
The greatest culprit of this is obviously the strong I HB inside run. Teams know it's coming, equip their defenders with all STR gear and go +run, blitz both safeties, even go as far to play goal line against strong I, and yet they all prove to be fruitless in stopping it.
In this sim, if a team wants to run strong I HB inside 60 times, they'll run it. You can't do anything to stop it. For a game that wants to move toward realism, I'm not digging that concept too much.
So the suggestion: how about after a defense sees the same play a certain number of times (be it 10, 15, 20, whatever) over the course of a game, they get a +% bonus to vision? It follows logic that a defender seeing the same play 30 times would be slightly quicker to react to it the 31st time.
There could be some sort of scale too. Like a 5% vision boost after seeing it 15 times, 7.5% at 20, 10% at 25, etc.
I would suggest other attribute bonuses as well, but those don't follow my 'realism' example, they're just ways to encourage more realistic gameplans.
Perhaps to make it more realistic, maybe for the same pass play 15+ times, it could be a vision boost, and for the same run play 15+ times, a block shedding % chance boost? It would also be logical to expect a DL to know what hole the play is supposed to go to after seeing it run 15 times, so they would stand a better chance to fight toward that area and thus shed their blocker more easily.
Could any of these ideas be implemented? I think it would go a long way towards forcing teams to actually gameplan and restore the interest in a lot of people who have become disenchanted with the game.
I think most of us can agree that this season's sim has taken a step back from the past, and that's primarily because gameplanning against certain plays has proved to be fruitless.
Instead of putting together a great, diverse gameplan, teams run the same 4 or 5 money plays over the course of an entire game and are better off than teams who try to keep defenses honest by running a diverse playbook.
The greatest culprit of this is obviously the strong I HB inside run. Teams know it's coming, equip their defenders with all STR gear and go +run, blitz both safeties, even go as far to play goal line against strong I, and yet they all prove to be fruitless in stopping it.
In this sim, if a team wants to run strong I HB inside 60 times, they'll run it. You can't do anything to stop it. For a game that wants to move toward realism, I'm not digging that concept too much.
So the suggestion: how about after a defense sees the same play a certain number of times (be it 10, 15, 20, whatever) over the course of a game, they get a +% bonus to vision? It follows logic that a defender seeing the same play 30 times would be slightly quicker to react to it the 31st time.
There could be some sort of scale too. Like a 5% vision boost after seeing it 15 times, 7.5% at 20, 10% at 25, etc.
I would suggest other attribute bonuses as well, but those don't follow my 'realism' example, they're just ways to encourage more realistic gameplans.
Perhaps to make it more realistic, maybe for the same pass play 15+ times, it could be a vision boost, and for the same run play 15+ times, a block shedding % chance boost? It would also be logical to expect a DL to know what hole the play is supposed to go to after seeing it run 15 times, so they would stand a better chance to fight toward that area and thus shed their blocker more easily.
Could any of these ideas be implemented? I think it would go a long way towards forcing teams to actually gameplan and restore the interest in a lot of people who have become disenchanted with the game.
Last edited Mar 19, 2009 23:07:11






























