User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Alright, the forums are getting some bad press in the #2 forum, and ron is complaining . SO, I am getting an all zeta team voting together:

Here are the guidelines:

1. Im am making a list of players that I think would be the frontrunners (top 3 in each position)
2. Put out a "Pre poll" list so the owners can see who was chosen, then make a case for their players. Thats how you get the other "nominations" for the ballot box
3. Here is the breakdown of nominations:

QB: 6 to choose from, 1 chosen

HB: 6 to choose from, 1 chosen

FB: 6 to choose from, 1 chosen

O-Line: 6 to choose from, 2 chosen (except center). THIS IS A HARD POSITION TO WEIGHT. Basically it comes down to pancakes. SO I take the players with the highest Pancake to Total plays ratio. (pancake percentage)

WRs: 12 to choose from, 3 chosen

TEs: 8 to choose from, 2 chosen (blocking and receiving)

Defense: Based on 4-3

D-Line:
DTs (includes NT): 8 to choose from, 2 chosen
DEs: 8 to choose from, 2 chosen
OLBs: 10 to choose from, 2 chosen. A guy with 98 tackles and 12 forced fumbles may not make the list if he has 54 missed tackles. Make sure to look at those BAD stats.
MLB: 6 to choose from, 1 chosen
CBs: 12 to choose from, 3 chosen. I weigh PDs more than INTs in this respect. High tackles means that he was not covering his man good enough.
FS/SS: 6 to choose from, 1 chosen (for each position).

Kicker/Punter/PR/KR These are self explanatory

Voting Rules:
1. Everyone can vote
2. You can only vote for TWO players from your own team..no matter how many were nominated

Offensive MVP: Person with the most offensive votes
Defensive MVP: Person with most defensive votes
POY: Ussually the position that was UNANIMOUS.

I will do a second team if there are more than 30 votes. Last time i did this i only had 16 votes. It really shows you how lonely it is on the forums...you actually see hpow many people read them. Not that many,

Worse comes to worse, there will be an Honorable Mention.

I will start compiling a list of my nominations tonight and tomorrow night, and then other owners and GMs can nominate overlooked players. Especially O-line. Other than pancakes...there is hardly anything to go by. So I need performances.

--Dan
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Oh yeah, hopefully someone does this for alpha. then there can be a pro bowl. Maybe that should be one of the offseason things bort does. He could make a lot by charging 25 FP for each player to participate.

--Dan
 
ErDrRon
offline
Link
 
Nice, Dan! Thanks for your work on this. The squeaky wheel (me) wins again! LOL

Last edited Mar 17, 2009 21:19:33
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
if you want some help w/ this dan, ill help
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jloescher3
if you want some help w/ this dan, ill help


I appreciate it J. I am actually gonna postpone this until AFTER the playoffs. because of all the CPU jobs and running up the score, I would not want anyone to alter their gameplan to make their guy get more stats (well...we all know that jimbo will get 50 carries in a CPU game). Also, guys who do not have lots of CPU games...it will give them a chance to get some more stat padding before voting.

ALSO, I think the playing field will be evened out if we include playoff stats. it will fall in the Quality WIn category. And i gfeel it NEEDS to be done.

Also, it will give us all something to look forward to do in the offseason.

I have compiled a list of some pre nominations (except the Safeties FS/SS). So there is a start.

The hardest thing is the O-line. Especially centers. They are WAYY down the list for pancakes. ANd I hate going by pancakes, but its really all we have. Passing teams suffer a bit. But, going by a pancake to play percentage/ratio works pretty well and doesn't get too many guys crying bloody murder. You will see backups in the first team...it happened when i did it a while ago in AA.

--Dan

P.S. I will post frontrunners and "Fringe" players before the playoffs as a teaser.
 
blue5213
offline
Link
 
I'm sure there's a Greasemonkey script somewhere that will show you sacks allowed by specific players, which would probably help out with the offensive line nominations. I know there's one out there for failed coverages, if that'll make your CB/FS/SS list-making easier.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blue5213
I'm sure there's a Greasemonkey script somewhere that will show you sacks allowed by specific players, which would probably help out with the offensive line nominations. I know there's one out there for failed coverages, if that'll make your CB/FS/SS list-making easier.


Anyone have those scripts?

--Dan
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
screw you zeta
 
seahawks3726
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
Originally posted by jloescher3

if you want some help w/ this dan, ill help


I appreciate it J. I am actually gonna postpone this until AFTER the playoffs. because of all the CPU jobs and running up the score, I would not want anyone to alter their gameplan to make their guy get more stats (well...we all know that jimbo will get 50 carries in a CPU game). Also, guys who do not have lots of CPU games...it will give them a chance to get some more stat padding before voting.





LMAO, so what is the difference if we run 5 wr streaks all game, or we give the ball to jimbo???? Is there some GLB Law that says u can only run the ball 10 times per HB against CPU teams???? LMAO wow dude..
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
hmmm......i guess if you want my help we could do it where we exclude certain games and then extrapolate from the data to fit it to a 16 game spread.....wouldnt be that bad......just more excel work lol
 
Lambda
offline
Link
 
there's also a script that does sort of pro bowl rankings based on stats, although you would have to weed out guys that just exploded on cupcake teams
 
blue5213
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
Originally posted by blue5213

I'm sure there's a Greasemonkey script somewhere that will show you sacks allowed by specific players, which would probably help out with the offensive line nominations. I know there's one out there for failed coverages, if that'll make your CB/FS/SS list-making easier.


Anyone have those scripts?

--Dan


Sacks Allowed: http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/38012

SA only shows plays in which the OL in question was on the field when a sack was registered; it doesn't say whose fault it specifically was. You could probably take the top five players in pancakes at each OL position and then run the script to see who allowed the fewest sacks in that group, though.

Coverage: http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/38874

Does a better job with LB and CB coverage than safeties; it tends to blame the safeties if they're closer to a receiver that a CB really messed up covering.
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
screw you zeta


LOL... You could join forces with the Cartel GMan if you are feeling left out!
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blue5213
Originally posted by cptafw163

Originally posted by blue5213


I'm sure there's a Greasemonkey script somewhere that will show you sacks allowed by specific players, which would probably help out with the offensive line nominations. I know there's one out there for failed coverages, if that'll make your CB/FS/SS list-making easier.


Anyone have those scripts?

--Dan


Sacks Allowed: http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/38012

SA only shows plays in which the OL in question was on the field when a sack was registered; it doesn't say whose fault it specifically was. You could probably take the top five players in pancakes at each OL position and then run the script to see who allowed the fewest sacks in that group, though.

Coverage: http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/38874

Does a better job with LB and CB coverage than safeties; it tends to blame the safeties if they're closer to a receiver that a CB really messed up covering.


Thanks!!!
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seahawks3726
Originally posted by cptafw163

Originally posted by jloescher3


if you want some help w/ this dan, ill help


I appreciate it J. I am actually gonna postpone this until AFTER the playoffs. because of all the CPU jobs and running up the score, I would not want anyone to alter their gameplan to make their guy get more stats (well...we all know that jimbo will get 50 carries in a CPU game). Also, guys who do not have lots of CPU games...it will give them a chance to get some more stat padding before voting.





LMAO, so what is the difference if we run 5 wr streaks all game, or we give the ball to jimbo???? Is there some GLB Law that says u can only run the ball 10 times per HB against CPU teams???? LMAO wow dude..


Just split the carries with your other HB...and you won't take crap.

Look at it from OUR perspective:
You give one guy 90% of the plays in a CPU game and expect us to not say anything.

Come on man...you're killing me. No, there is no law...but what reason is there to give a guy 50 carries in a CPU game. Hmmmm. Ah just kidding. Lighten up. Plus, it must have been an AI glitch. i know I mess up when trying to give other players stats in a CPU game. Like get the HB slots mixed up in the AI. Our Hb actually had more carries than ol' jimbo in a CPU game because I messed up the HB depth chart. The backup did not get any carries and was only on the field for Punts. My team forum gave me crap for 4 days because of that.

Its just some ribbing.

--Dan
Last edited Mar 18, 2009 18:50:24
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.