User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
So the NFL Network is replaying the November '85 game with the Bears at Green Bay. Really, was there ever a better defense than the '85 Bears?
 
QuakeDE45
offline
Link
 
I just bought a pretty interesting read at the dollar store LOL, its called the "The Paolantonio Report" by ESPN analyst Sal Paolantonio. It pretty much highlights the overrated and underrated player/team at every position, moment, super bowl team, coach etc. in football history. He actually had the '85 Bears as the most overrated team of all time (!!!) The '72 Dolphins were number 2.

He does acknowledge they are very, very, very good. But brings up some pretty interesting points, mostly that with all the talent they had, they should have had a dynasty no questions asked, but yet they only reached one super bowl, and their cast of characters remained largely the same, they won just two playoff games in the next 7 years.

Here is the concluding excerpt:
"How can one of the most dominating Super Bowl champions be overrated? Dynasty was at their doorstep, and they turned it away. That team had three Hall of Famers- Walter Payton, Dan Hampton, and Mike Singletary. Yet they reached just one Super Bowl. They were a peerless champion. For one year. They should have been much more."

I guess its more of a critique on the Bears post-1985 than that team, but its an interesting chapter.

 
QuakeDE45
offline
Link
 
Oh, and good luck to everyone today, we have some good matchups it looks like.

Killers vs. Eagles
Saviors vs. Redskins
Bulldogs vs. Dragons

Looking for the Bulldogs to break out here really soon. The Killers played a great game last week, we will see if they can capitalize. Saviors and Redskins should be a knockdown-drag out affair.
 
RevDAB7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by QuakeDE45


Looking for the Bulldogs to break out here really soon.


If we (The Bulldogs), can ever get all the pieces going at one time in one game we could be a really good team. I can guarantee this: We will not roll over for anyone (pun intended).

We are learning a lot about our team and could be a dangerous team to play at the end of this season.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Interesting thesis. I'd probably counter that in '85, Payton was already long in the tooth for a running back, and I believe Jim McMahon got injured the very next season on the Charles Martin body slam. That's just the offense. The defense of course lost their coordinator Buddy Ryan when Philly signed him in the off season as their head coach.

Winning a Super Bowl is damn hard. Winning several...
 
Harry Charger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by QuakeDE45
Oh, and good luck to everyone today, we have some good matchups it looks like.

Killers vs. Eagles
Saviors vs. Redskins
Bulldogs vs. Dragons

Looking for the Bulldogs to break out here really soon. The Killers played a great game last week, we will see if they can capitalize. Saviors and Redskins should be a knockdown-drag out affair.


Apparently Alpha looks down on its Zeta cousin. The Cocks and the Storm matchup tomorrow.
 
RevDAB7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Harry Charger
Originally posted by QuakeDE45

Oh, and good luck to everyone today, we have some good matchups it looks like.

Killers vs. Eagles
Saviors vs. Redskins
Bulldogs vs. Dragons

Looking for the Bulldogs to break out here really soon. The Killers played a great game last week, we will see if they can capitalize. Saviors and Redskins should be a knockdown-drag out affair.


Apparently Alpha looks down on its Zeta cousin. The Cocks and the Storm matchup tomorrow.


I know this Alpha member doesn't look down on Zeta. Alpha has only won 1 league championship. Alpha hopes to change that but I think the Cocks, Gladiadores, Storm, or Frost will make it a tough task.
 
QuakeDE45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Harry Charger
Originally posted by QuakeDE45

Oh, and good luck to everyone today, we have some good matchups it looks like.

Killers vs. Eagles
Saviors vs. Redskins
Bulldogs vs. Dragons

Looking for the Bulldogs to break out here really soon. The Killers played a great game last week, we will see if they can capitalize. Saviors and Redskins should be a knockdown-drag out affair.


Apparently Alpha looks down on its Zeta cousin. The Cocks and the Storm matchup tomorrow.


Ah nothing like that, just making a quick analysis on something that hits a little more home for some of us. You guys do the same No disrespect intended in the least.
 
QuakeDE45
offline
Link
 
Here are some other of the lists from this book some people may like to discuss and debate:

Quarterbacks:
Overrated
1. Joe Namath
2. Brett Favre
3. Terry Bradshaw
5. Tony Romo

Underrated
1. Bart Starr
2. Len Dawson
4. Randall Cunningham

Wide Receivers
Overrated
1. Lynn Swann
2. Terrell Owens
3. Cris Carter
4. Keyshawn Johnson

Underrated
1. Marvin Harrison
2. Jimmy Smith
3. Andre Reed
5. Sterling Sharpe

Super Bowl MVPs
Overrated
1. Roger Staubach
2. Dexter Jackson
3. Larry Brown
4. Jim Plunkett

Underrated
1. Phil Simms
2. Steve Young
3. Franco Harris
4. Kurt Warner


These are just a few, as I mentioned he have them for every position group, if anyone is interested I can also post those with his explanations. Just figured we could discuss/debate some football if you guys want.
 
Harry Charger
offline
Link
 
Sheeeit. Larry Brown should be #1 on overrated MVPs
 
Mean Green
offline
Link
 
That was Larry Brown best game of his life... if I recall right the only game he did something right!!! but I'll take it!!!

And there is know way Brett Favre is overrated... IMO hes the greatest QB ever to play the game! or at least that I've gotten to see
 
Tex Scram
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by QuakeDE45

Quarterbacks:
Overrated
1. Joe Namath
2. Brett Favre
3. Terry Bradshaw
5. Tony Romo

1. Never saw him play
2. I think he's rated exactly how he should be - amazingly durable guy, not a great passer, just makes plays happen on the fly with incredible instinct and awareness
3. Never saw him play
4. I didn't think he was rated all that highly. Has the potential to be like Favre if he can stay healthy


Originally posted by QuakeDE45

Underrated
1. Bart Starr
2. Len Dawson
4. Randall Cunningham

Never saw any of these guys play


Originally posted by QuakeDE45

Wide Receivers
Overrated
1. Lynn Swann
2. Terrell Owens
3. Cris Carter
4. Keyshawn Johnson

1. Never saw him play, but being a Cowboys fan I'll go with this
2. Upside as good as anyone that ever played, but highly inconsistent throughout his career
3. Never saw him play
4. Didn't realize he was rated highly to begin with


Originally posted by QuakeDE45

Underrated
1. Marvin Harrison
2. Jimmy Smith
3. Andre Reed
5. Sterling Sharpe

1. Known as one of the greatest WRs around? How is he underrated?
2. Don't know anything about him
3. Everyone says he never got the recognition he deserved, which seems like pretty universal recognition to me
4. Don't know anything about him


Originally posted by QuakeDE45

Super Bowl MVPs
Overrated
1. Roger Staubach
2. Dexter Jackson
3. Larry Brown
4. Jim Plunkett

All were before my time


Originally posted by QuakeDE45

Underrated
1. Phil Simms
2. Steve Young
3. Franco Harris
4. Kurt Warner

How can a Super Bowl MVP be underrated? Isn't that about the highest rating one could get?
 
Harry Charger
offline
Link
 
Randall Cunningham? Dude. He was a badass and played for Buddy Ryan and the Iggles.

Dexter Jackson was the TB CB that picked Gannon off repeatedly.

Tex, I know you better than that. You're just being lazy.

Chris Carter / Randy Moss combo with Robert Jordan made the Vikings wish for the late 90s - early 00s.

Jimmie Smith had the best game ever for me in Fantasy when he caught something stupid like 5 TDs and 200 yards against the Baltimore Ravens. Yes, the same year the Ravens had that defense and won the superbowl. Cocaine is a wonderful drug. The man was an FFL machine. You could usually draft him late, get 1100 yards from his ass (if he wasn't suspended for drugs) and have two stellar games from him a year. That 5TD gem helped me beat Holley's team, so it was doubly sweet, especially after Holley taunted me earlier that day because Jason Elam, my kicker, decided to go break his back covering a KR.

Sterling Sharpe is the black guy on one of the NFL pregame shows that always sounds like he's got a mouthful of bubblegum. Played TE.

Last edited Mar 11, 2009 16:52:50
 
QuakeDE45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Harry Charger


Sterling Sharpe is the black guy on one of the NFL pregame shows that always sounds like he's got a mouthful of bubblegum. Played TE.



Aw come on Harry Thats Shannon Sharpe! Sterling was his brother. He was really good put up good numbers until a neck injury ended his career after 6-7 years. Anyone else think Shannon is annoying as hell? LOL
 
Harry Charger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by QuakeDE45
Originally posted by Harry Charger



Sterling Sharpe is the black guy on one of the NFL pregame shows that always sounds like he's got a mouthful of bubblegum. Played TE.



Aw come on Harry Thats Shannon Sharpe! Sterling was his brother. He was really good put up good numbers until a neck injury ended his career after 6-7 years. Anyone else think Shannon is annoying as hell? LOL


That's right. That's what I get for chastising someone

Shannon is as annoying as hell.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.