User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why "nerfs" and "berfs" are a bad idea (this is long, if you have ADD don't read it)
Page:
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Everytime Bort changes something in this game, the community is instantly stratified and polarized. When defensive ends are too powerful, defensive end owners say there's nothing wrong with that, and offensive line and QB builders say it's ridiculous. When defensive ends are subsequently nerfed, the positions are the same, but reversed. In the end, the only progress that is made is that one half of the community is pissed off, and the other half is happier. However, since GLB is an ever changing construct, with builds completely up to the whims of the player builders, Bort is never going to achieve his goal - the elimination of one dimensional, unrealistic builds - by strengthening and weakening positions left right and center. Before everybody cuts into me though, I have an alternate solution, and it occured to me when I read that apparently, now Bort is considering nerfing cornerbacks because the passing game is too weak.

Bort, the passing game is struggling this season, I agree. As an offensive coordinator, a passing game guru, and somebody who would very much benefit from the passing game being a little easier in this case because my team is built to throw the ball, I am all for improving it and making it a little more useful. Here's the problem - I don't agree that nerfing cornerbacks and giving them more vision checks to pass is the way to fix the passing game. Here's why: the bottom line is, that 90% of the time a pass is incomplete in the current sim because the quarterback throws the ball too late. The wide receiver, who may have 3 steps on the defenders, has to wait for the ball and a knot of defenders closes and knocks it away, including the original defender in man coverage whom the receiver has beaten to tempt the qb into throwing the pass in the first place. In fact, I happen to think that right now coverage is PERFECT - you see slower corners getting beat when they are on fade routes, faster ones keeping up. You see more agile corners handling cuts better than less agile corners. You see the corner sticking with his man when he should be.

What you aren't seeing is the corner being BEAT when he should be - and that's because of the way the QB throws the ball, not because the CB is too good. The 'QB leading' mechanic is simply not working. I don't know if the vision or throwing requirements are too stringent - but Jeff Garcia of Halifax, one of the highest vision QBs in the game, is not having success leading his receivers. I've seen QBs with 120 throwing including vet skills having the same issue. I've seen high confidence qbs as well. The problem, in short, is NOT in the effectiveness of the cornerbacks, but in the poor execution of the passing itself.

The bottom line? The ball and receiver need to arrive at the reception point at the same time. The receiver should ONLY stop on routes such as curl routes, and the QB should throw such routes earlier. Because the ball and the receiver are NOT arriving at the same time, we're seeing hordes of deflections, except in cases when the QB's pass quality numbers and the receivers possession skills are high enough to let him bullshit the ball into triple coverage. Nerfing CBs, just as strengthening powerbacks and offensive linemen, is NOT the answer.

Pass protection was weak because of poor blocking logic. That has not changed. We still see RGs and LGs choosing to double team a nose tackle rather than picking up the blitzer. Such things simply should not happen if the blocker has ANY appreciable amount of vision - appreciable here having the meaning 48. Lower vision should mean that it happens sometimes, but not often. However, instead of addressing the fundamental problems in your pass protection logic, you've implemented a convoluted series of nerfs and buffs for defensive and offensive linemen, made even more complicated with the addition of vet skills and advanced equipment which can give defensive linemen and offensive linemen skills that they were never intended to have. In short - each time you try to fix a problem by adjusting player BUILDS, instead of the behavior of the dots themselves, you are creating a bigger mess for yourself.

This season's pancake debacle is another clear example. How in gods name was run blocking bad before? Why was it necessary to create a million and a half pancakes? My team last season (and this season) was able to run block just fine WITHOUT the enormous strength advantage. It's not as though if the d-line isn't getting pancaked the ball can't be run effectively. There's a such thing as holding a block without knocking a defender flat on his ass.

In summary - you will find your changes a lot more effective and better received if rather than knee jerk nerfing, you do the admittedly much more difficult task of reworking the actual code that determines the interactions on these plays. Rework the pass protection mechanics, the pass completion mechanics, the coverage mechanics. Analyze the pathing and the decision making of the running back. Instituting extra vision checks and making strength work better and making speed differentials count for more or less is not going to be the final solution that you are looking for to make this game into the finished product that you want it to be. Actually getting into the nitty gritty of the sim, fixing the fundamental flaws in the logic, will go a lot longer way than simply juggling attributes and screwing with player builds, and will in general give you a much better opportunity to create the sim that you first set out to create. I do not claim this should be easy for you - it's why you're Bort and we're just players. Getting the actual code right rather than tweaking builds is much harder to do, and you might have stumbles along the way - but in the long run, screwing with the builds is never going to give you the sim you want.

For a summarized version of the argument in bullet form:

Originally posted by Bones Brigade


I know it has been stated before, but I would really rather not see any NEW features (Def. Play Creator, for example) for season 9 and I would greatly prefer to see some core SIM issues fixed:

1) O line blocking assignments, vision pickups of blitzes and general pathing of blockers

Which would then allow DEs and DTs to get 'un-nerfed' because O linemen\FBs\TEs\HBs would actually be interacting logically

2) QB - WR pass logic, target\route interaction. IF vision checks for WRs to see the 'final destination' of the pass is required, then it makes sense to also require that check for DBs. TBH - most DBs have much higher vision than WRs already, so for well built DBs, this would be a non-issue\non-nerf anyways.




Note: I refer specifically to the passing game in this post because it is the clearest example of the fundamental problems with the approach of nerfing to normalize stats rather than addressing the core problems in the sim. I am not by any means saying pancakes, power backs, speed ends, or any other of the 'iconic' nerfs and buffs that have happened in this game are good or are working fine - I'm saying that the fundamental logic behind implementing ANY and ALL nerfs needs to be addressed.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 12:36:17
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Wall of Text

FATALITY
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
ferfs
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Wall of Text

FATALITY


Don't say I didn't warn you (see thread title)
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Wall of Text

FATALITY


 
xcoach2
offline
Link
 
needs bullets pts
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Again, I'm not denying it - I even posted in the thread if you are 'offended' by people putting thought into posts and making an editorial, don't read the damn thing. Thanks for your valuable contributions to the discussion though. God, I love GLB public forums.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xcoach2
needs bullets pts


That is constructive though - I will try to go through and edit
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 11:55:44
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Again, I'm not denying it - I even posted in the thread if you are 'offended' by people putting thought into posts and making an editorial, don't read the damn thing. Thanks for your valuable contributions to the discussion though. God, I love GLB public forums.


Thanks!

But we don't loves walls of text. tl;dr version please.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
You're exactly right, I've been saying this for a while now.

I've pretty much had to eliminate short passing from my offensive game-plan, as medium/long passes, actually have a similar completion rate, if not higher.

There is no short, high percentage passing game in GLB right now, which is a huge flaw in the SIM, that needs to be fixed NOW.

Last season, I was able to run short, quick throws, that were very reliable, and carried a higher completion percentage than longer throws, which is how it should be. But for some reason this season, the QB is completely incapable of leading a WR on a shorter route, which makes no sense whatsoever.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 11:57:35
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by rj414

Again, I'm not denying it - I even posted in the thread if you are 'offended' by people putting thought into posts and making an editorial, don't read the damn thing. Thanks for your valuable contributions to the discussion though. God, I love GLB public forums.


Thanks!

But we don't loves walls of text. tl;dr version please.


Well, since you aren't my target audience, I really don't give a shit - the people I want to read it are people interested in or *capable* of changing the game - just don't have access to an admin or mod forum to put it there.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
I agree with alot of it. The only reason I would argue in favor of a vision check for a cb is because it was a nerf on WR that caused them to need the check. It really makes no sense to not have the same thing on a DB playing in man.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Again, I'm not denying it - I even posted in the thread if you are 'offended' by people putting thought into posts and making an editorial, don't read the damn thing. Thanks for your valuable contributions to the discussion though. God, I love GLB public forums.


i think you screwed yourself with that massive text vomit above. You can easily make your points in a much easier to read and audience friendly manner. At least I think you can but i refuse to read that shit
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
You're exactly right, I've been saying this for a while now.

I've pretty much had to eliminate short passing from my offensive game-plan, as medium/long passes, actually have a similar completion rate, if not higher.

There is no short, high percentage passing game in GLB right now, which is a huge flaw in the SIM, that needs to be fixed NOW.


Absolutely - and this boils down to the mechanics of the passing game, not the CBs being too good.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by rj414


Again, I'm not denying it - I even posted in the thread if you are 'offended' by people putting thought into posts and making an editorial, don't read the damn thing. Thanks for your valuable contributions to the discussion though. God, I love GLB public forums.


Thanks!

But we don't loves walls of text. tl;dr version please.


Well, since you aren't my target audience, I really don't give a shit - the people I want to read it are people interested in or *capable* of changing the game - just don't have access to an admin or mod forum to put it there.


I'm interested in what you have to say. I just don't have 10 minutes to listen to you. If you could summarize I'd care.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.