User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #7 > Tex's Statistical Power Ratings - Week 5
Page:
 
Tex Scram
offline
Link
 
Well, I'm a bit of a numbers nerd and I was bored at work yesterday, so I threw together a little application that scrapes league data from GLB and computes a few different ratings formulas that measure various aspects of each team's performance.

Enjoy.

http://grimland.uta.edu/glb/SouthAmericaA7-Zeta-Week5.html
http://grimland.uta.edu/glb/SouthAmericaA7-Alpha-Week5.html

All columns are sortable.





Formula explanations:

AIA:
Just looks at wins and losses. Rewards wins over good teams.

JLG:
Just looks at wins and losses. Rewards wins over good teams, and penalizes losses to bad teams.

OMF:
An attempt to predict what a team will score in a given game based on their previous game performances. It takes average score into account, but also recent extreme high or low scores, and winning or losing trends. This one especially suffers from a small sample size, so it should get more accurate as the season goes on.

DMF:
Much like OMF, but this one attempts to predict points allowed rather than points scored (thus lower is better). Same limitations apply regarding sample size.

RPI:
The same formula found on the Wikipedia page for RPI (Ratings Percentage Index), minus the bit about home games counting less and road games counting more. RPI is just measuring the strength of the teams you've already played. The more cupcakes you've had, the lower your RPI. The tougher the teams you've faced, the higher your RPI. Your winning percentage is a small component, but in general it doesn't really say a whole lot about your own team's strength.



NOTES:

I call these ratings rather than rankings, because not all of them are useful for direct comparisons between teams. AIA and JLG are the only ones that could even possibly be used to compare teams against each other, with JLG being the more accurate one.

All of the formulas except OMF/DMF give more weight (in an indirect way) to conference games, and less importance to the Week 1 non-conference game.

These are formulas that I mostly came up with on my own (except RPI and parts of OMF/DMF). I'm no statistician so they could be flawed or useless or misleading or just plain wrong. But it's fun to play with numbers.
Last edited Mar 4, 2009 19:16:03
 
Seiya Kou
offline
Link
 
That RPI fomula looks to be pretty acurate. It rates us at 458 (assuming higher the number the better) which puts us around 9th in the league, which is a fair guess at this point as we haven't played a top tier team yet. Good post, we all enjoy rankings, numbers based or otherwise.
 
Tex Scram
offline
Link
 
By looking at your conference I can see that while three of you are undefeated, the Anacondas and Dragons have done so against much better opponents than the Saviors as indicated by the AIA and more accurately JLG, as well as the fact that their RPIs are much higher (higher RPI means you've played a tougher schedule, and means very little about the quality of your team).

Not to say that the Saviors are a lesser team, just that the quality of their opponents has been lower so far.
Last edited Mar 4, 2009 14:18:46
 
fpopescu
offline
Link
 
I disagree with it but its ok its just for fun, I know for a fact that the Anacondas have started witht the toughest schedule except those teams get knocked down well because they got knocked down, so the Saviors look at their scedule and they haven't beaten anyone yet, oh well.
 
Tex Scram
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fpopescu
I disagree with it but its ok its just for fun, I know for a fact that the Anacondas have started witht the toughest schedule except those teams get knocked down well because they got knocked down, so the Saviors look at their scedule and they haven't beaten anyone yet, oh well.



I'm not 100% sure what you said, but I think you said the same thing I did.

I don't attempt to order the table based on my opinions of the teams. The initial order is simply the order listed on the conference page (i.e. in order of GLB tie-breakers).
Last edited Mar 4, 2009 14:24:35
 
RevDAB7
offline
Link
 
Keep this up. I like this information.

Numbers to back up opinions.
 
Mean Green
offline
Link
 
Great work!!!
 
QuakeDE45
offline
Link
 
Awesome!
 
Seiya Kou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fpopescu
I disagree with it but its ok its just for fun, I know for a fact that the Anacondas have started witht the toughest schedule except those teams get knocked down well because they got knocked down, so the Saviors look at their scedule and they haven't beaten anyone yet, oh well.


Yeah, I said exactly this in my response. We're ranked about 9th in RPI which is about right as we haven't beaten anyone yet.
 
fpopescu
offline
Link
 
I'm not 100% sure what you said, but I think you said the same thing I did.

I don't attempt to order the table based on my opinions of the teams. The initial order is simply the order listed on the conference page (i.e. in order of GLB tie-breakers).


Acutally your post must have been put up right about the same time I was writing mine I agree with you and not the rankings, but it doesn't really matter till the end.
 
Tex Scram
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fpopescu
Acutally your post must have been put up right about the same time I was writing mine I agree with you and not the rankings, but it doesn't really matter till the end.


I call them ratings rather than rankings, because I don't attempt to rank the teams in any subjective order. The whole point is to draw your own conclusions based on the aggregation of the different measurements.

Having said that, if I were forced to pick one of these formulas that most accurately ranks teams in order of "best", I'd definitely say it's the JLG score. It's pretty simplistic, but it factors in the strength of the teams you've faced much more accurately than the simpler AIA score to give a reasonably solid objective ranking relative to the other teams in the conference.
 
QuakeDE45
offline
Link
 
Very nice set of rankings there Tex, thanks for doing them for us. Always nice to have a launching pad for debating
 
Xcesiv7
offline
Link
 
very nice
 
fpopescu
offline
Link
 
Sorry I was being a pain in the ass I shouldn't complain because I can't get even that far with this stuff, so again sorry to be stupid I respect the work that you have done and I will stop being an asshole about stuff, everyone puts in good time in this game if you get in these boards that probably means you are dedicated so kudos to all of you and lets have some freaking fun, next games in 47 hours good luck to half of you.
 
Tex Scram
offline
Link
 
I didn't think you were an ass, I was just confused when you said you disagreed until I realized you misunderstood what chart was for. I think you saw that the Saviors were listed ahead of your team and you thought I was ranking them as a better team, but I wasn't. In fact, click on JLG and RPI to sort by those columns and you'll see that it says the Anacondas have not only performed the best, but they've done so against the toughest opponents so far. And the same holds true on the Week 6 chart.

Once again, the initial order is just whatever it is in the Conference standings table.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.