It seems any time there is a major change made, half the player universe goes nuclear over it and Bort has to fight fires to try and fix it or defend it. I think a much better, more professional way of implementing changes it to have focus groups who can discuss the ideas before they are implemented. By getting a rough consensus before implentation, new initiatives will get a lot better reception and Bort wins cause his life is made a lot easier in the process.
What do I mean?
1) This would be for non-sim issues only. Obviously Bort can't give advanced knowledge of possible sim changes to a select few, but it would apply to things like endorsements, veteran abilities, league struture changes, should we have casual leagues and other similar changes not related to the sim mechanics. The only game related discussions that may be appropriate are things like are DEs really overpowered (season 6) or the discussion on power backs that Bort started last season that discuss flaws in the sim rather than identifying what will change in the sim in the future.
2) A private forum would be set up and users would be invited (discussed below) to join the forum. Bort would introduce an idea he wants to add, or even better, variations of the idea, and let the group discuss pros and cons. Because there are a limited # of people in the forum, discussions will remain on topic and anybody who starts trolling or flaming can be kicked out of the session.
3) Bort and all the other admins should participate in the forum. If there is consensus the idea is good, then game over. If there is serious disagreement within the group, Bort and admins take time to discuss it and revise and report back to the focus group with improved ideas. Note, I'm not saying focus group gets any final say, but that if the original idea is panned, they need to come back and present the improved idea before moving forward.
4) After the focus session is over, the thread is locked and posted and stickied in the forums so everyone can read it. That way there will be no charges of secrecy or hidden advantages.
Who gets invited?
1) I would guess about 100 users is a good balance between too many ideas for anyone to be heard and too little diversity of opinion.
2) When Bort wants to launch a group, he posts it in the appropriate forum and people sign up. There will be some sort of random way of picking the final 100.
3) You can only be in one group per season (or maybe only one or two per year depending on demand?) so it isn't always the same people each time.
4) There should be a balance of active forum posters and active agents who don't post on the forums. There are tons of the latter who have good ideas but are overwhelmed by or turned off by the chaos that is too rampant in the forums. One of the problems with the current open forum threads is Bort hears the same voices over and over and they end up with too much influence, imo.
5) If the forum posting score is ever implemented, a negative score could prevent you from participating in focus groups.
Conclusion: Focus groups give Bort a way to test ideas before launch without incurring the wrath that seems to come with every idea these days (someone will always be unhappy). Using the focus groups to improve the ideas will reduce the size of the unhappy crowd as obvious flaws like with endorsements will quickly be identified before going live. Result is Bort is happier, the customer is happier, and we have a lot less drama in GLB.
What do I mean?
1) This would be for non-sim issues only. Obviously Bort can't give advanced knowledge of possible sim changes to a select few, but it would apply to things like endorsements, veteran abilities, league struture changes, should we have casual leagues and other similar changes not related to the sim mechanics. The only game related discussions that may be appropriate are things like are DEs really overpowered (season 6) or the discussion on power backs that Bort started last season that discuss flaws in the sim rather than identifying what will change in the sim in the future.
2) A private forum would be set up and users would be invited (discussed below) to join the forum. Bort would introduce an idea he wants to add, or even better, variations of the idea, and let the group discuss pros and cons. Because there are a limited # of people in the forum, discussions will remain on topic and anybody who starts trolling or flaming can be kicked out of the session.
3) Bort and all the other admins should participate in the forum. If there is consensus the idea is good, then game over. If there is serious disagreement within the group, Bort and admins take time to discuss it and revise and report back to the focus group with improved ideas. Note, I'm not saying focus group gets any final say, but that if the original idea is panned, they need to come back and present the improved idea before moving forward.
4) After the focus session is over, the thread is locked and posted and stickied in the forums so everyone can read it. That way there will be no charges of secrecy or hidden advantages.
Who gets invited?
1) I would guess about 100 users is a good balance between too many ideas for anyone to be heard and too little diversity of opinion.
2) When Bort wants to launch a group, he posts it in the appropriate forum and people sign up. There will be some sort of random way of picking the final 100.
3) You can only be in one group per season (or maybe only one or two per year depending on demand?) so it isn't always the same people each time.
4) There should be a balance of active forum posters and active agents who don't post on the forums. There are tons of the latter who have good ideas but are overwhelmed by or turned off by the chaos that is too rampant in the forums. One of the problems with the current open forum threads is Bort hears the same voices over and over and they end up with too much influence, imo.
5) If the forum posting score is ever implemented, a negative score could prevent you from participating in focus groups.
Conclusion: Focus groups give Bort a way to test ideas before launch without incurring the wrath that seems to come with every idea these days (someone will always be unhappy). Using the focus groups to improve the ideas will reduce the size of the unhappy crowd as obvious flaws like with endorsements will quickly be identified before going live. Result is Bort is happier, the customer is happier, and we have a lot less drama in GLB.






























