User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Europe West > Europe West AAA League > WE AAA 1 Mid-season Team
Page:
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Bored. Compiled looking mainly at league leaders stat page. My opinion only. Feel free to correct my picks. Maybe we can come up with a real version (or update this one as time goes by so we have a good list at the end of the year).

QB C Dub (Toledo)
HB Pop Warner (Tottenham)
FB LoLo Neal (Berlin)
WR Turbo Townsend (Chesham)
WR Thick McSquatboy (Chesham)
TE Jack Morning (Barcelona)
OG Bigger Thanyou (Berlin)
OG Mary Mary (Berlin)
OT Max Pugh (Berlin)
OT Alton Brown (Brussels)
C Snot Dangler (Stockholm)

DT Isaac Sopoaga (Berlin)
DT Killer Ace (Berlin)
DE Reginald Ivory (Berlin)
DE Ator Jones (Arkansas)
LB French Doughnut (Stuttgart)
LB Roman Thunder (Rusty)
LB Bjorn Onderstal (Gascony)
CB Don Gore (Philadelphia)
CB James Hagg III (Hamburg)
FS Eric Berry (Amsterdam)
SS Matthew Dagger (Texas)
 
AggieAnthony
offline
Link
 
It would be cool to have a Team 1 and Team 2 out of this. But it would take alot of work!
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
The problem with this is that CBs and FSs should not have high tackling numbers, cause that means that they're not doing their job. If the CB is letting his man catch the ball, that means he's not covering him. So, what was your criteria for all the DBs?
 
DrunkenLemur
offline
Link
 
Basically it is impossible to actually know who is doing the best job at any of these positions because of the huge disparity in quality of opponents. I can make a case for pretty much my entire team being #1 at every single position.
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Gargus, the 2 CBs were the interceptions leaders.

FS was based on tackles since I didn't see a leader in INT, PD, FF, etc.
SS is the league leader in tackles.

Part of the safety's job is to stop things from going past them, right? So tackling #'s would not be an indication of a bad safety.

Similarly, CBs can have higher tackling numbers if used on special teams or if they were contributors to the run D. My CB had 5 tackles last game, 2 against the run.

Thanks for the input, y'all. A second team would be awesome. I wasn't THAT bored at the time, lol. Maybe with added input, we can have a 2nd team.
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenLemur
Basically it is impossible to actually know who is doing the best job at any of these positions because of the huge disparity in quality of opponents. I can make a case for pretty much my entire team being #1 at every single position.


I feel ya. It hurts having only 1 Toledo guy on that team. I think 2 or 3 of our linebackers could have made it, and we've got quality guys at every position. In many cases, team tactics and the quality of a player's teammates will make a HUGE difference.
 
DrunkenLemur
offline
Link
 
Sure, but what I'm saying is, there is no way for this list to be meaningful unless you put a lot more time into it. I appreciate what you tried to do, but it's really pretty meaningless if you just go by raw stats. A good example is the back from the trolls. He gets like 85% of their offense run through him, hence his big numbers. C Dub is another example, good player, but still 11 points behind the top rated QB in the league, etc etc.

Almost all of Berlins pancakes can be attributed to pathetic defensive lines that they have faced, the two real matchups have been much more reasonable (top # was 5 pancakes against Pimp Daddies, 2 against Toledo)
Last edited May 12, 2008 11:43:04
 
vabills
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenLemur
Sure, but what I'm saying is, there is no way for this list to be meaningful unless you put a lot more time into it. I appreciate what you tried to do, but it's really pretty meaningless if you just go by raw stats. A good example is the back from the trolls. He gets like 85% of their offense run through him, hence his big numbers. C Dub is another example, good player, but still 11 points behind the top rated QB in the league, etc etc.

Almost all of Berlins pancakes can be attributed to pathetic defensive lines that they have faced, the two real matchups have been much more reasonable (top # was 5 pancakes against Pimp Daddies, 2 against Toledo)



Or a certain back who is #2 in the league because he shares a lot of carries with the #13 in the league.

Or a certain tackle from the bovines who got no pancakes when they actually played a decent team.
Last edited May 12, 2008 11:45:32
 
DrunkenLemur
offline
Link
 
sure, Jimmy isn't a bad back - but like I said, the same thing can be said for #3/#4 combo eh? - again it is going to take a lot of effort to truly differentiate the talent.
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenLemur
Sure, but what I'm saying is, there is no way for this list to be meaningful unless you put a lot more time into it. I appreciate what you tried to do, but it's really pretty meaningless if you just go by raw stats.


Bingo. I'm kind of hoping this will be a springboard for people who WILL put more time into it than me. Or maybe I will at a later date. Who knows.

I just meant this list to be a start--not even a very good start--just a start, lol.

As for the players getting their offense run through them, McFadden and Tebow put up monster years because the offenses relied very heavily on them. Colt Brennan made a name for himself mainly because of the system that he was in. Stats are one of the few ways we have to compare players, but I do understand it's far from perfect.

(P.S. I'm not meaning to sound like an a-hole, haha.)
 
DrunkenLemur
offline
Link
 
oh, I totally agree, Tebow is completely overrated, anyone who touched the ball as many times as he did, and whose # was called that many times, was bound to put up those kind of numbers. 20/20 is amazing, but the number of plays called for him was far far far above anyone else, possibly ever.

I think Pop has had an impressive season, and likely has been the MVP, because of how valuable he's been to his team individually.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
perhaps yards per carry should be the criteria for HB's, and then instead of having individual lineman, maybe the lineman associated with the best yards/carry or least about of sacks... something like that.

Also, for DB's, in the system that we're in SS and FS shouldn't be getting a lot of tackles. Yes, they're important, but if one of my CB's isn't doing his job, my guy has to go over the top to help out... where my guy could instead read the QB and force him to make a bad decision.
Last edited May 12, 2008 11:58:43
 
DrunkenLemur
offline
Link
 
I think YPC, combined with a minimum # of carries, is a good starting point, but you have to factor in who they were up against as well. I'm sorry but the teams in Alpha are just plain weaker - no 2 ways about it, so the #'s put up by teams like the trolls + berlin simply aren't as impressive as they could be in my eyes.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenLemur
oh, I totally agree, Tebow is completely overrated, anyone who touched the ball as many times as he did, and whose # was called that many times, was bound to put up those kind of numbers. 20/20 is amazing, but the number of plays called for him was far far far above anyone else, possibly ever.

I think Pop has had an impressive season, and likely has been the MVP, because of how valuable he's been to his team individually.


One also has to account for durability. If Pop didn't have great stamina, and a great line... he wouldn't do anything!
 
jasonshepp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdupuy3
Gargus, the 2 CBs were the interceptions leaders.

FS was based on tackles since I didn't see a leader in INT, PD, FF, etc.
SS is the league leader in tackles.

Part of the safety's job is to stop things from going past them, right? So tackling #'s would not be an indication of a bad safety.

Similarly, CBs can have higher tackling numbers if used on special teams or if they were contributors to the run D. My CB had 5 tackles last game, 2 against the run.

Thanks for the input, y'all. A second team would be awesome. I wasn't THAT bored at the time, lol. Maybe with added input, we can have a 2nd team.


What about teams that play zone a lot? The CB's will have a significant amount of tackles in that instance.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.